Tubby’s Pizza

Best pizza in Marysville. Very reasonable prices as well!
We love the taco pizza. Toppings are fresh and the crust is solid. I also love the blt foldover!

I pick up pizza from here on a regular basis seeing as its about 4 blocks from my house. They have a great $ 6.00 one item medium deal every day of the week. Their mediums are almost the size of some pizza place’s large. We stick to the regular crust option although the thicker crust isn’t bad. Their sauce and toppings are pretty good too, although once you get more than a couple toppings they really tend to shrink in size. The staff is always nice and give you prompt service. We have tried the wings before but keep coming back to the medium one topping for six bucks. You really cant beat that deal. Marysville has many average to below-​average pizza places that honestly seem to be overpriced for the market they serve. Pizza hut next door has screwed up our order on numerous occasions. The pizza at tubby’s is consistently good so there are no surprises. If you are looking for a gourmet-​type pizza you may want to stick to columbus because this is not the place. If you want a good, no frills pizza for a decent price then you won’t be disappointed.

Sometimes we get pizza from here for work, so I really don’t know about the service. As long as it arrives on time and hot, we’re happy.
As for the food– it’s average pizza. Nothing outstanding about it, but nothing offputting either. Crust isn’t bad. Cheese and sauce are forgettable. Toppings aren’t awful, but it’s stuff you could grab at random at the grocery and throw on yourself.
If it was the only place in town, I’d go there, but it wouldn’t hold up to any competition. I would rather we get it from Donato’s, Monarch, or Benny’s, but it’s usually not my call.

Had to hang up the phone and order somewhere else some young kid picked up the phone and couldnt understand my phone number which i repeated twice slow for him and still didnt get it right, wanted to give this place a try but costomer service is key…

Sub-​par service (how about a smile and a «hello» instead of a dead stare?) and average pizza. Garlic cheese bread was maybe better than average and inexpensive for its size, but certainly not a reason to visit again.
Pizza: Pepperoni is low-​quality. Sausage is pretty good, leaving a little bite from its seasonings. Dough is pretty chewy. Pepperoni pizza tasted just better than a frozen name-​brand pie. Sausage was better, but mainly due to meat quality.
As far as local Marysville pizza joints, there are better options.

This place reminds me of a place our family use to eat at all the time back in Columbus on the westside. Tubby isn’t fancy, but he does it right for the right price. The subs are great too. My husband is super picky from the north side of Columbus, and he loves Tubbys.