I have had many guests from Italy who after sampling many places in the area relate that Sal’s pizza is more like the original from Italy than any other! The staff are fun and personable. The price is great and the Giant Pizza is just that! I like their salads a great deal and the garlic knots will make your tongue so happy. Evan the cannoli is a welcome treat. I read the review where their are complaint or concerns but I have been going there for over three years and with«real Italians» and their comments I think is one of the best in the area!
Bob C.
Tu valoración: 2 Estero Island, FL
Asked for extra oregano or put some on box. Never happened. Soggy pie. Was delivered. Gave delivery man almost $ 7. On $ 21 Pizza but would not sit box on bar. Just not a good pizza or experience.
Rolando T.
Tu valoración: 4 Cape Coral, FL
For me is ok I like the taste and the price is right so I think is a good place for a Sunday pizza.
Beth D.
Tu valoración: 1 Cape Coral, FL
No stars. Complete lack of customer service. Could have cared less that we ordered 3 pizzas promised in 30 – 45 minutes. Upon arriving at store 45 minutes later they began to make pizzas. Another 35 minutes later pizza was ready. No compensation given, no apology! Will NEVER be back and will gladly let all know how awful their service is.
Peter M.
Tu valoración: 5 Los Angeles, CA
Best pizza in the cape! Sal’s has been around forever and I hope their Giant Pizza never goes away!
Adam C.
Tu valoración: 5 Cape Coral, FL
finally found a decent new york pizza joint 2 slices for 1
Danita T.
Tu valoración: 5 Columbus, OH
This place is great! Delicious pizza, friendly staff, large portions, and reasonable prices. The ingredients are made fresh daily, including the pizza dough, cheese, and sauce. If you’re in the mood for pizza or Italian food, this is the place. My husband and I had the grilled chicken Cesar salad and the Supreme pizza… excellent choices for our first time here.
Claudia P.
Tu valoración: 5 Cape Coral, FL
My boyfriend and I love this place! Great pizza and very nice customer service. I ordered for delivery and the older man wasn’t very nice when dropping off my pizza. The pizza out weighs that though and the garlic knots are very delicious!
Barbara M.
Tu valoración: 3 Fort Myers, FL
I’m giving this 3 stars because I felt it was 2 stars but my husband and daughter thought it was more like 4 stars. We got two pizzas, a large and a small. The crust on the large was a bit soggy, not crisp at all. The crust on the small was much better. We got bacon on the small and it was sooo salty. I did enjoy the sauce. Just a note: On the large, I was using a coupon for 2 toppings. I was not able to get two half toppings to count as one topping(i.e., I was getting mushroom on the whole thing, then wanted pepperoni on one half and bacon on the other half). I was going to be charged for 3 toppings. When I asked about it when we picked the pizzas up, I was told that’s how the owner does it for coupons. I have never heard of a pizza place not accepting two halfs as one topping. Don’t think we’ll be going back.
Victor L.
Tu valoración: 2 Clyde, NC
Years ago this used to be my favorite pizza in the Cape, but recently I’ve given it a couple of tries hoping to get a taste of what used to be. Sadly I am very disappointed. It’s true that it’s an attempt at a NY style pizza but falls short. The pizza by the slice seemed old and not crisp on the bottom so you can’t do the NY fold and get that«crack» in the crust. I’ve also ordered a Sicilian pie and it’s expensive and NOT a true Sicilian pie but more of a Chicago deep dish. Don’t be surprised when you open the box and it’s a circle and cut like a normal pie… Yeah.
Scooter B.
Tu valoración: 5 Cape Coral, FL
Sal’s IS the pizza place in Cape Coral. We’ve dined in, picked up, or had delivery. The best way is to dine in because then your pie comes piping hot to the table. Pick up is my next choice and delivery, while convenient, just doesn’t get the pie to the house hot enough. On to the taste, though. Great veggies and meat combos, I especially love the meatball topping. No scrimping on portions and the dough is just perfect. The garlic knots are a must have. The staff is very friendly and accommodating. I do wish they were open a bit later on Friday and Saturday night. You really can’t get a better pie in SW Florida.
Geri M.
Tu valoración: 2 Cape Coral, FL
Wanted to like it, gave it numerous tries, always disappointed. Be sure to look at the dates of the other reviews as the 4 stars are definitely an outdated measure. It’s not easy finding good pizza in Cape Coral, but it’s a fair trade off for the 300 days of sun.
Paul W.
Tu valoración: 4 Cape Coral, FL
I’ve reviewed sal’s in the past and over the last few times they’ve definitely improved on service. The pizza is incredibly good and whenever I have ordered a pie on my way home from work on their website, it always consistently waiting, and hot out of oven.
John H.
Tu valoración: 4 Cape Coral, FL
Got a large pizza and an order of wings. The pizza was really good, the wings were just average. The pizza was built well with a good amount of toppings and the crust was nice and crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside. The wings were okay. I consider myself a wing connoisseur and have certain snobbish standards so to the non snobby the wings might have been really good. But basically the wings should have been crispier and the buffalo sauce tasted right out of a jar. Overall will definitely be back for pizza but maybe not the wings.
Jose V.
Tu valoración: 4 Cape Coral, FL
Great Stromboli and great service food is very good pizza is good meat ball sub is good my daughter love it
Brian R.
Tu valoración: 3 Cape Coral, FL
The pizza is ok but the last few times i had it dropped the ball the pizza is very doughy and too saucy for my liking
Laura R.
Tu valoración: 4 Cape Coral, FL
Great pizza and service! Stopped after driving by quite a few times. It was not crowded at all and it was great to sit outside on their patio. Service was super efficient and very nice. The pepperoni pizza is fantastic, big slices, NY style, very good. Definitely recommend the garlic knots — exactly what you want in a doughy, buttery, garlicky appetizer!
Paige S.
Tu valoración: 3 Olympia, WA
This place has opened and closed more times than I can count. It always returns as Sal’s pizza, but the pizza is usually different each time. Most the time visiting here, the pizza is delicious, and the garlic knots are great! It’s small inside and usually not very busy. It’s a hard location to park in and a very small parking lot.
Cory C.
Tu valoración: 4 Aurora, CO
Pretty good New York style pizza. Garlic knots very buttery and cheesy. Yum. Friendly service.
Cheryl K.
Tu valoración: 5 Parkland, FL
Best NY style pizza /pizzeria in Cape Coral. Yesterday stopped in for 2 slices and a soda — $ 3.99 — an d their slices are giant. The cheese is real. Seriously if you’re from NYC area /Long Island area Sals pizza is pretty damn good. Have no idea about the take out pies or dinners etc but the two counter slices were great!