Nice Guys Pizza

Super relaxed and fun atmosphere. We ordered one of their specialty pizzas and it was probably one of the greatest pizzas I’ve ever had. Being a pizza enthusiast, it’s a pretty big deal to find a good local pizza place.
The restaurant is divided into two parts, the bar/​restaurant and the game room. The bar has 30 craft beers (I purchased a craft beer from Tampa, and it was pretty phenomenal as well) and a super awesome price for craft beer (I’m usually spending $ 8 – 9 a pint, this was about $ 5 from what I remember on my check).
The game room had a bunch of pin ball machines (it was my first time playing), tons of neat art work on the walls, comfy couches and board games. It was a lot of fun to mellow out and chill in, especially after the adventure I had in Fort Myers/​Cape Coral already.
I’m definitely coming back again. I even left with a neat sticker that I will cherish forever.

We love this place. Tried the Hot Honey pizza for the first time and it was amazing! We always order the garlic knots too! They are usually great but this time they were a little one note for me. I had to add a little salt to cut the fat a bit. Its been a while since we visited. It was nice to see that they had expanded and added an entire pinball machine room. Will go with some quarters in our pocket next time. If I’m being honest my only real complaint was when the server dropped his towel on the floor and then picked it up to wipe our table down. I wasn’t in the mood to say anything but it was a little disappointing. Other than that… kudos Nice Guys! See you again soon!

Love this place. Consistently delicious. Must order the General Tso pizza and garlic knots. French fries are good too. So much beer to choose from. This place is a real gem. Everyone that comes to visit me, ends up here one night. Little joint but really awesome.

Love the atmosphere and pinball machines.
The pizza is absolutely delicious. Great crust… great toppings… the hot honey pizza is so good…

Pizza — Beer — Pinball: a winning combination!
Located on Cape Coral Parkway, so it’s easy to find. Parking can be a challenge. The first few places we tried were marked for other businesses only, so expect to do some looking and maybe you can avoid getting frustrated.
We visited on a Saturday evening. It was packed and stayed that way while we were there. This is a small no-​frills bar that is set up for food service along one wall and in front. The lighting is dim. The music is good. The décor and overall ambiance is fun and funky with a lot going on everywhere you look. The menu is irreverent and succinct. Suited for those that don’t take themselves too seriously and are ready to enjoy their surroundings and exceptional food.
If you’re a beer drinker, you score big here. If not, there are some choices but they are more limited.
The PIZZA! That PIZZA! We like pizza and usually get a standard order with traditional toppings. However, after reading and hearing so much praise for the specialty pizzas, we really wanted to try one. It was difficult to choose. The combinations are inventive and intriguing.
Pizzas come in three sizes: 12″, 14″ and 16″. We ordered a 14″ Hot Honey (hot honey, salami, prosciutto, provolone, parmesan, mozzarella, fresh tomato and garlic). And, not realizing how filling this meal would be, ordered some yummy garlic knots to start. We ate until we were bursting because it was SO GOOD but had to take home almost half of both. Next time we’ll order a bit less… or will we? The leftovers made a tasty lunch the next day.
We enjoyed spending time in the «other side» of the place where they have pinball machines and a lounge. We made it an evening playing the room but eventually settled at the Kiss and Game of Thrones machines for the longest stretch. Neither of us had played pinball for years and it was a blast! Good times. Good times.
Final Assessment: Fun and funky ambiance. AMAZING food made with fresh quality ingredients that are prepared with skill and attention to detail. Excellent assortment of pinball machines for your gaming pleasure. Easy 5 Stars!

We love this place! Food is great and lots of craft beer. The only complaint is it is very small… But, making it bigger may take away from its local appeal. One of our favorite places to eat.

One of my favorite songs…“What is hip… can you tell me if you think you know…” well I do know, and I can tell you. Nice guys pizza. Amazing pizza… great beer… a room full of pinball machines… and a dj like at the front door. Nuff said.

Even though we have been inside several times with the kids now they don’t accept them … Too bad we can’t go back anymore

LOVE THIS PLACE! Food takes a life time to come out but it’s absolutely hands down worth the wait! Got some honey pizza, that was fire!!! Loved it! Garlic knots were on point!!!
**When you try to take decent photos but fail miserably when you have looked at everyone else’s because it was really late at night and the quality sucks!

Nice Guys has the best pizza in SW Florida. I’ve visited numerous times and they never fail to please in terms of great food and service. They are very creative with their pizzas and the results are often unique and outstanding. I’m eating a leftover slice as I write this! I also want to mention their wings which honestly also are the best in SW Florida. I’ve also tried their salads and all were great. And they have great beers, including some that I’ve usually never seen or tried, and I’m a beer connoisseur. Give it a shot!

The pizza was insane, had the chosen one, and the Washington carver. Total insanity.
80’s craziness on the walls and bar, vinyl for sale, Betamax recorder on top of the cooler. Feels like I finally found my bar.
Room next door has the best selection of pinball machines I’ve seen in years.
Beer was all over the place, but perfect for me. Cool hipster feel, and the people really are. Nice.

If you’re looking for a family fun atmosphere, condescendingly friendly staff, with lightning fast stale pizza, in typical styles you know and love… then you should probably go to Pizza Hut or Little Caesars. they’re great at that sort of thing. This pizza place is about nontraditional as you’re gonna get. Run by a great staff, serving a brilliantly refreshing and exciting menu, that include but not limited to sandwiches (both cold and hot), Mozzarella sticks, wings, and deep fried Oreos. It’s the sort of place that some would call «gourmet» or something… but Nice Guys wouldn’t. they’d just call it good food. It’s the type of place that takes chances, for those who enjoy adventure, excitement, and maybe a bit of mayhem… but you know. in their Pizza and Beer.
Whether you’re ordering a bottle of Bud Lite, a can of Ultra, or some draft IPA from the foot hills of Portland OR, made fresh by the tireless efforts of some guy in a bird suit while he sucks on an empty corncob pipe… they will serve it with the same enthusiasm; every time. Don’t expect any snobbery here… unless that’s the sort of thing you want, and then they’ll go toe to toe with the best of ‘em. There is Pinball, board games, and always someone there to shoot the shit with… unless it’s a Monday, you’re out of luck.
Yeah, it’s about the size of shoe box, food that’s both popular and delicious does take a bit longer to get to you, and the staff aren’t afraid to tell you to fuck off if you’re acting like a belligerent jerk face. But those qualities are not a drawback by any means; Nice Guys Pizza has a refreshing, no frills, laid-​back atmosphere that you won’t get from a focus group approved restaurant… if that’s what you’re looking for. well there are plenty of places out there where they will bend over backwards when you ask to see the manager because your pizza might have a burnt spot on it… I mean… that’s not to say Nice Guys won’t respond kindly, but they’re not going to do because it’s corporate policy, but because they are Nice Guys.

Washington carver pizza is simply astoundingly delicious.
It’s a hipster place in cake coral.
Beers are mostly small batch brewery types.
Food is delicious.

Love this place !!! The food is great ! The only drawback is there is not enough seating and the seating is not comfortable at all. I love their food and they really are some of the friendliest service in the cape. They have earned the five stars. I wish they would open in a larger location or utilize the pinball room as additional seating. Still this place is hidden gem in the cape. Please don’t bring your kids here.

Gourmet pizza and craft beers… I felt like I was back in Chicago. Only I was able to sit outside and enjoy sunshine and pizza in March. If you want sausage pizza or cheese pizza, this isn’t really going to be for you. You’ve got to be ready to embrace the flavors and fun!
I had the Black Gold pizza with mozerrela, cantaloupe, black garlic, evoo, etc. My husband and Dad had the General Tso with fried chicken, pineapple, broccoli and hot sauce. We loved the flavors and the doughy crust. We had the Resin IPA… awesome! 10%ABV and super hoppy.
Jimmy our bartender/​server was fun and everything came out pretty fast. No highchairs, but outdoor seating was family friendly. Inside was more of a bar vibe.

We went here for my husband’s birthday since he is a pizza fan. This tiny hipster restaurant has a large selection of beers. Im giving four stars because we are a house divided. My husband loved the food but I was not a fan. We ordered hummus which was freshly made but lacked salt. We also ordered the truffle pizza. It had too many onions and grease for my taste but once again my husband loved it. Finally we ordered the regular fries. They had no salt and way too rich. All in all i would give 3 stars because with added salt i think the food would be much better. My husband gave 5. So ill probably be back to give it one more chance.

Hipster Paradise! On our first trip to Nice Guys we went to the bar because there was no where else to sit. We were informed by the bartender that those spots were reserved. Who saves bar spots? So we decided to go some where else.
The next night we got take out to avoid the previous said situation. The pizzas were ok. The prices were ok.

A week night in Cape Coral doesn’t offer very much… and we were meeting old friends in a former home town. After waiting for at least 30 minutes on the «other half» of the pizza place, we were permitted to move on over to the side where we could order a pie. The place is tiny and cramped. The waiter who assisted us was quite friendly and took the order of one pie with two toppings (Oh, and can you please leave one piece PLAIN? Just nothing but the cheese, please?) Order came out, pizza was decent.
Based upon the wait, it must be a Cape Coral place to grab a slice of pie, but, keep in mind the place is also very small.
I do think that if they opened the other half up to pizza ordering /​dining in people, then more people could dine in and their business could see an increase.
Wait time: too long
Inability to order on (what do they do with this half of the place anyway?): not good
Pizza: decent
Parking: poor — street parking only — or somewhere in the back, in the corner, in the dark…
Waiter: nice guy. Not his fault we couldn’t order while on the empty other side.

What to get:
–Banana Bread Wells Beer
–Garlic knots
–Hot & Honey Pizza
-**But the absolute STAR of this place is the Washington Carver pizza. It absolutely sets it apart from any other pizza place! Don’t miss out!!**

I really wanted to love Nice Guys. We arrived into town after a 12 hour drive up from Nashville to stay at my parents place down here. We didn’t want to mess with cooking or eating out somewhere so we decided on pizza. Pizza is probably one of my favorite food groups, if not favorite. We usually get pizza from Paradise Pizza, but we were looking to try something new, so we deciding on Nice Guys.
We skimmed the menu & picked the ‘carnivore’ pizza, a medium for $ 15 & ordered a side of the cheese sticks. The girl on the phone was very short while taking our order on the phone, almost like it was a nuisance for taking a phone order. She told us it would be ready in about 30 minutes. We set off for Nice Guys about 25 minutes after ordering & arrived when it should be ready. It was a Friday night & the place was busy. The bartender said it would be a few minutes for the order & if we wanted a drink. A few minutes turned into about 25 minutes, nearly an hour after calling in the order. I’m not sure if they forgot about it or if they were just really busy.
We got home & were so excited. We opened the cheese sticks & tried them. They were okay, tasted a little overdone. There were 5 sticks in the order for $ 7. Onto the pizza. It was nice sized for a medium, a nice amount of toppings, but nothing had any flavor. The crust tasted like bread & flour, the meat didn’t have any seasoning. It as was very basic. Was it bad pizza, no. Was it great pizza, no. It was a just very mediocre. Like I said, I wanted to love this place, but after my first experience, I’ll stick with my usual place.