Paradise Pizza

Paradise Pizza, Lafayette Ave, Cape Coral, FL,. Here is a bit a chit chat and 2 cents on the food.
Pizza…It is a personal matter. We are fortunate to have a good pizza joints in each quadrant of the Coma.
In this quadrant for me it is Paradise. My go to pizza is mushroom and pepperoni. It must still taste good cold the next morning fridge or not.
This pizza has FRESH mushrooms and fully covered pepperoni slices. Crispy crust with the right amount of sauce.
For me this is a lil bit of paradise. AHHH but lets not forget the red peppers flakes.
I like my pizza the way I like my women, Hot & Spicy.

Torrey was our server — great job taking care of us — drinks kept full. Got Roast Beef sub — good sub, roast beef was really tender. Had cheesesticks, they were thick and tasty. Shrimp Parm sub was delicious per wife, medium size shrimp. A lot of variety on the menu — we will be back.

A couple of northerners who have relocated to the Cape and have been looking for some true NY style pizza. Finally we have found it. After several years of trying all the other pizza in SWFL we now have our pizza place. Paradise is the closest to Brooklyn that we have been able to find. Crust is perfect, just the right amount of sauce and cheese that is browned just right.

Awesome food ! Owner is very friendly as well as staff. It is our go to place. Pizza best in Cape Coral !

We recently moved to Cape Coral from Fort Myers Beach — FINALLY FOUND SOME GREAT PIZZA! Consistently delicious and fresh. We have ordered delivery 3 – 4 times now and Paradise is always friendly and timely. I’m hosting a «Ladies Day Out» soon and can’t wait to introduce my friends to Paradise with some pizza and app delivery! My husband is very picky about pizza and he agrees — Paradise is the best we’ve had in Florida. Nice work!

This is my first visit and I ordered a Capicola and Provolone sub; I won’t be ordering another one. It tastes OK. Actually, it’s pretty bland, all I’m really tasting is the oil & vinegar and the tomatoes. And the tomatoes were the only thing that I specifically requested NOT be put onto my sandwich. But whatever, I pulled them off, but once I had pulled them off I realized that the tomato layer was thicker than my capicola layer. The layer of meat is only one slice thick. What? Is this the norm for this place? If the Capicola and Provolone sub is the same price as the Italian Combo (sporting ham, salami, capicola, and provolone) I expect to have the same amount of meat just all capicola. I am very unimpressed.
I might try them again for their pizza but I certainly won’t be getting a sub again.

Very good NY style pizza. We usually call them for delivery. It has become a friday evening tradition at our home!

I wouldn’t think of ordering my pizza anywhere else. they get 5 stars, 4 forks, and a high five. The staff is friendly, welcoming, and accommodating. The restaurant is clean and comfortable. The pizza is off the charts with its thin crispy crust. There is no skimping on the topping. My family generally orders pizza but on occasion have order the entrees which are equally delicious. The lasagna has just the right amount of sauce cheese ratio and the eggplant is my favorite. Prices are great.

I was very impressed with the pizza and service here… still wondering why it’s such a secret… makes it even better… family owned and operated which I really like. so much better that way… :)

Ordered delivery on 4^th of July, they said they weren’t busy. 50 minutes later I called and they had the wrong address, and were another 20 minutes. Soggy pizza and «steamed» appetizers. Not good.

Ordered delivery, pizza was hot and delicious. Thin crust, cheesy, wonderful. Will order again!

We’ve been regular customers of Paradise Pizza for YEARS! The food is fantastic; the pizza is thin and crispy, and they never have a problem specializing certain things for us. My favorite pasta dish is Ziti with Broccoli and Chicken, the lunch serving is easily enough to feed two people. I’ve never had a bad meal at Paradise. The staff (mostly family) are all great… super friendly and completely accommodating! Paradise Pizza comes HIGHLY recommended.

To be fair, we aren’t from the area and we ordered on super bowl Sunday, so I can’t speak to the consistency of their product. They delivered to our hotel fairly quickly during the game so I’ll give them an extra star for that. But the wings were undercooked and low quality, I’ve had better from the chain pizzerias and those are at the very least an insult to the culinary world.
Pizza was bland, but again it’s possible being on super bowl Sunday they were just overwhelmed and couldn’t produce a better product. But of that’s indeed their normal product, it’s a 2 star at best rating if I had ordered any other night…

Whenever I’m in town visiting my parents, we always seem to order a pizza from Paradise Pizza at least for one night of my stay. It’s a no brainier. The pizza is always fresh & the prices are reasonable for a local pizza shop.
We ordered the supreme pizza & changed black olives to green olives. The green olives add a bit of a kick as where the black olives don’t have much of a flavor. We live near Paradise so we call it in & go pick it up. The ready time is 25 minutes, a little long but I guess they were busy that night. We run to the grocery store & then to Paradise. The pizza should be done by my estimates but the young lady at the counter said «It’ll be a few more minutes because it’s crisping up». We wait about 5 minutes & it’s ready. It’s about 24 bucks for a large pizza, it’s quality but still a little pricy I think.
We get home & dive into the huge pizza. It’s seriously a large pizza. On the drive home I rode in the passengers seat with the pizza pushing me to the back of the seat because it was touching the dashboard.
As always, the pizza was great, the toppings are plentiful & always taste fresh.
Why the 4 star? During the «crisping» time our pizza’s crust got burnt on the end. Burnt so much that we had to cut it off around the whole thing. This wouldn’t be a big issue to some but I LOVE CRUST. I eat the crust first, weird I know. I’m not sure if it’s because the pizza is so large that it gets too close to the side of the brick oven or what, but next time we might get two smaller pizzas & see how it goes.

I hate to give a bad review to a good place but don’t order when they are very busy. This is the second burned pizza I’ve gotten. When cooked right they have the best pizza in town. Get a timer or something. I took a pic but it’s not going to let me post it here. Maybe if they really do read this, they will correct this problem.

Hands down, best pizza in the Cape! All their menu items are delicious! Fast delivery and they even deliver beer. Great service when dining in too.

Pretty good meatball sub. Frozen fries but it’s all good. Cheaper to just cut potatoes fresh.

Pretty darn good pizza, especially for the Cape which is notorious for bland and uninspired. I would rank Paradise right up there with Grimaldi’s and Pizza Fusion.
I called in an order for delivery and my food was delivered hot, fresh and correct in just under 40 minutes. So far, so good!
The pizza was great — really good crust and lots of toppings. I got baked ham and pineapple with added jalapeños in a large size for about $ 10. This may sound like a dumb comment but beware that their jalapeños are hot! They use pickled ones as opposed to fresh ones and I thought they were über spicy. Anyway, the pizza was just as delicious served cold for lunch the next day, which is always a plus.
I also ordered an antipasto salad which I really enjoyed. For $ 7, it was huge! Definitely big enough to share or divide in to two portions and save some for later. The dressing was nice and tangy, and I enjoyed the pickled veggies (carrots and cauliflower) in addition to the traditional Italian meats and cheese.
I will definitely be ordering from Paradise again. Their menu is gigantic and also includes hot and cold sandwiches, strombolis and traditional Italian specialties.

Very good veggie pizza! Asked for extra crispy crust and it came out great.
Also had the eggplant rollatini for an appetizer, it was so big it could be an entrée itself.

We were visiting family in Cape Coral and picked up Paradise Pizza for take out while we were there…
Great, friendly service! And of course, DELICIOUS New York style pizza! The «Paradise Deluxe» was amazing. Love the thin, crispy crust and the heaps of toppings. We will definitely visit again when we’re in town!