Idaho Pizza Company

Got home to find raw dough in breadsticks. Company refuses to give a refund, instead sending a slightly silly «sorry we goofed» gift certificate. A goof would be getting pepperoni instead of sausage. We won’t be back to risk more raw dough and no chance of refund.
Update: they sent us a refund by mail, a full month after we went there and only after we posted this review. Staying at 1 star because it’s unacceptable that we had to post a review to get a refund 1 month later. I still won’t risk returning.

LUNCH! It’s tasty! We’re fans here. I’m not one to belabor a point. It’s good pizza. Unilocal REQUIRES WAAAAAAY TOO MUCH WRITING, kids. If something is good, it’s good.

Well, I sure expected better. It was our first time at any Idaho Pizza Company and I heard that it was a great place. Well, we ordered the Sawtooth special, was told that it would be about 7 minutes until our Pizza arrived. So we sat down, got our drinks and waited. It took about 12 or so minutes (not to bad really) and when I took my first bite, I wasn’t really impressed. The sauce was good and the crust was airy but when I bit into my second piece, there was a weird texture, it was raw dough! That’s right folks, raw dough. I looked at the other pieces and sure enough, the middle of the pizza dough was raw. To top that off, the pizza we ordered was no the pizza we got. Like I stated above, we ordered the Sawtooth special and got the Idaho supreme.
Another thing, when you place your order, they cashier writes your name on a card that you set on the end of the table. On the back side of this place card is a survey that you can fill out, well, how is one supposed to fill it out when the person who brought out our pizza took it off the table?
I also found it interesting and disturbing that I saw employees restocking the salad bar from plastic containers… is anything on that salad bar not processed? Oh wait, maybe the lettuce.

This was an Sunday brunch time stop for a group of about 20 of us. In our group some wanted pizza but some wanted salad, what did we do? Idaho pizza company of course. Service was great and the place was packed but we were welcomed to sit as a group (just pushed the tables together).
Let’s get to the FOOD!
Salad– I am not a big fan but everyone else who ate it was very happy. By glance I could see a large selection and most importantly it all looked FRESH!
PIZZA– So many varieties to choose from and that is what sets them apart. Other pizza buffets you get like 3 – 6 choices but here they have over 12 I counted.
Eating like a pro here you have to try the white sauce buffalo chicken and jalepeno or with out. The classic pepperoni is meh but wait and they will put out the meat pizza or even better the CINNAMON sticks with icing. (We fought for these)
It’s decent quality and it’s all you can eat If you go during buffet times, they also have a full menu with beer and wine to compliment.

More like 2.5
I was really excited to try this pizza because based on the pictures I thought it would be like my favorite local chain.
I ordered this for carryout. Ended up with a half pepperoni and half cheese and an order of garlic bread with cheese. The pizza itself wasn’t great. I couldn’t finish my half of it because I wasn’t feeling the crust at all. The garlic bread with cheese was really good. The bread tasted great.
Really wanted to like it but will probably go somewhere else next time or just stick with the garlic bread.

First time having the pie frome here tonight. I’m in from out of town so it’s always a crap shoot. thank goodness for Unilocal and the folks who write reviews…
Ordered the Sawtooth Special and holy crap is that a tasty piece of deliciousness… the crust rocks… the toppings are plentiful and the whole damn package is delish!!!
Definitely in the top tier of my goto pizza places when in town !!!

Great food. Great salad bar. Good beer service. What more could you want in a Pizza place?

I ate there today for my first time and was impressed. There was a large variety of pizza out and what I ate was very tasty. The salad bar was fresh and kept clean. Lunch buffet was very reasonably priced. Service was impressive also. The place was quite busy, and I could see it is well liked by many.

Ate at this place the day after customer appreciation day. Pizza was excellent with fresh ingrediants, ordered the supreme pizza and it is always good. They are not the best at cheese only pizza, but who eats that anyway except for kids. This place has come a long way since it opened years ago

Service is always awesome. Food is always delivered quickly, and order is always perfect. Get the Hell’s Canyon with jalapenos and bacon. :)

One the best places that I’ve ever eaten at… a great salad bar, great customer service, great pizza, clean beverages are always cold. They are a consistent for every Idaho Pizza Company restaurant here in Idaho for goodness sakes you can go to any of them and get the same across the board. Love LOVE love.

Seriously one of the worst pizzas I have ever tried. Little ceasers is a step up and a third of the price! I kid u not, I thought I was eating froZen pizza. Crust– chewy old cardboard. Sauce– dried into the cardboard. Cheese– I’m still looking for it… Toppings– not much and the onion, peppers, and such were precut and thawed I suspect. Oh, and the wings were the same ones u get in the freezer section and baked. They Do Not even have wing sauce!!! Their garlic cheese bread was free and worth the price.

Busy lunch with an all you can eat pizza buffet. I like this pizza better than the «mega» pizza chains. The sauce is a nice distinct flavor without being too spicy or too sweet. The crust is not too thick but not too thin with just enough chew to be substantial. A good variety of pizzas to choose from, pepperoni, Canadian bacon, all meat, buffalo chicken, and likely more.
The salad bar offers a decent variety but not too large.
Staff was energetic and quick to take orders and actively keeping the restaurant clean and the buffet well stocked.
If you go often they do have a punch card for frequent diners. I was told it is good at all locations.

I had the lunch special which includes a full salad bar that is filled with fresh veggies and REAL blue cheese! Also they had a variety of different pizzas that came out every five minutes. my favorite was the barbeque pizza — chunks of bbq chicken with fresh green onions on top. Yummm. great selection great service and great location. The place is decorated very nicely as well making it perfect for a family or date night out! Check out the awesome arcade too!