Eyman’s Pizza

This place is fantastic. The fact that it looks like a hole in the wall might cause some to disregard it, but it’s truly a hidden gem.
When I was there, it was run by two very nice Vietnamese brothers — they let me make wudu and pray in the back. The meat lovers pizza was delicious. If you’re a halal eater in the market for pizza, this place is a no-​brainer. Even if you don’t care about halal, how many places serve gyro on their pizza?
The wifi is just an added bonus. If you want pizza and are nearby, go to Eyman’s!

I enjoyed being able to order food that my Muslim friends and I can enjoy together. Yeay for all halal!!!

LOVE this place. Great pizza. Affordable (I’m looking at you Tuta Bella!) and the guys that work there are incredibly nice. I’ve never eaten there (we’re a take out kind of family) but sometimes I’ll bring my slices next door to Union Bar.

Their pepperoni pizza looks exactly like the pizza emoji and tastes exactly like how you’d think the pizza emoji would taste. If you’re not looking for anything fancy, it’ll get the job done.

This from a customer service perspective, not their food. Customer service is Terrible. Ordered delivery from them and this place told us that it does not deliver to our place. We live 10 minutes away. They have delivered to us before. There was no reason for that, and to top it off we received a few different stories for why they couldn’t deliver ten minutes away. Besides me being «too far» another employee told us they were out of drivers. They informed us 30 minutes after we placed the order, and they charged the order anyway. They refunded but now money is pending to be returned to the account. The whole process was ridiculous.

Delicious veggie lover’s pizza! Even has pineapple on it. Excellent crust for west coast pizza! They have great prices too!

Good pies at affordable prices. The Gyro Pizza is the bomb!!! Conveniently located right next to Union Bar. Also do delivery throughout the hood. Super nice guys too

Restaurant is really clean. Pizzas are yum, burgers are great too. If u need your halal fix, this one definitely satisfies.

Its a small place with simple seating.
But their pizza is really good .
I had their chicken pizza with all the veges and pepperoni pizza
Both were really good.

A solid choice for party pizza i.e. ordering for a lot of people and needing something affordable. Though not as good as tutta Bella’s it provides a good alternative price wise. The pizza itself is a mix between thin crust and thick. Will definitely order from here again.

Damn, that really hit the spot. Fresh ingredients, hot, generously sized, good crust, delivered to our Columbia City house. A real pizza, nothing fancy, just good. And with 1999 prices.
It’s about time someone in Seattle did something good with the name «Eyman.»

We’re originally East Coasters, well versed in NYC and New Haven pies, and have mostly been disappointed with our experiences here in Seattle. Tonight we were pleasantly surprised with our Eyman’s takeout pizzas. They were unpretentious and classic. The crust was a little on the doughy side but tasted good. We got a large pepperoni (made with halal beef) and a large gyro w/​herb seasonings and black olives. I have to say my gyro pizza was delicious. Crisped up in the oven for a few minutes, these pies brought back the simple satisfaction of our East Coast pizzas — minus the dripping grease. And the total? About $ 25. No foofy, vegan, odd combinations with equally odd high prices. Two young men watching TV immediately leapt into action as soon as we walked in, ready to serve. We called in our order about 20 minutes beforehand and the pizzas were ready and waiting. One of the men rung us up and courteously thanked us for coming in.
This is a cute little place with a few tables for eat-​in dining. The menu is limited, but they also offer gyro sandwiches and other blackboard specials in addition to pizza. No salads. They don’t have a website but I found their menu here:
Definitely check them out if you’re a local and want a very good, no-​nonsense pizza at a normal price.

In the Columbia City area Eyman’s is as good as it gets. We’ve been in the neighborhood since the only pizza place in the South end was Dominoes (as if that was pizza). Now there are a number of places but they have all let us down in various ways (quality, price, service). Eyman’s has been the most consistent and is now the only pizza we order. We get two large pizzas for about the same price as one Padrino’s (which we’ve tossed in the trash before). Honest pizza (not for the wood oven burned art cracker crowd), good crust, consistent quality, great price, and hey, it’s all Halal. I do wish they had delivery but it’s always hotter if you pick it up yourself anyway.

Fast service. Great price. Thanks.

I read all the wonderful reviews of this place. got ready to order and much to my surprise they will only deliver if I order 2 large pizzas. That is not good business practice in Seattle. Dominoes got more than 1 star. At least they gave me the chance to order a pizza.

My girlfriend and I decided to try this out, as it’s near our home.
The food wasn’t bad, but it certainly wasn’t fantastic. The waiter, some kid barely out of high school, came off as offended that a couple of white Americans would have the audacity to come into his restaurant and expect service. When we entered and sat, he rolled his eyes as if to say, «Ah, damn it.»
He barely acknowledge our presence and hardly spoke to us except to take our order. When we paid and left, we didn’t even receive an acknowledgement or thanks for your business. It was more of a, «I’d like you to leave now.»
So we left. I hope the attitude was worth the only $ 16 this restaurant ever get from us. I have better uses for my money than to give it to people who don t want it.

It’s good, cheesy, tasty, fresh pizza. Not gourmet. Not bland. But really good.
Nice service, great prices. I highly recommend.

Mkay, I’m an east coast transplant, and if you’ve been out to the northeast you know that pizza is god out there. It is everywhere and it is good. Out here I’ve had the hardest time finding pizza, much less good pizza, much less good pizza that wouldn’t cost an arm and a leg… much less all of that delivered to beacon hill. I was getting pizza hut delivery before I found these guys **barf noise** and I am so glad I don’t have to resort to that anymore, and whats better…
Eymans is good, really really good, even by my east cost standards. We’re talking fresh pizza, fresh dough, fresh ingredients, it’s everything pizza should be and its not too pricey. I’m a huge fan, these guys totally saved my stomach.

I’m not sure about sara a’s statement that Eyman’s Pizza is the «BEST Gourmet Pizza In Town!» And the overuse of exclamation points isn’t really helping…
Maybe if you have never visited to Flying Squirrel, or Tutta Bella… maybe you could say that… but I really don’t think so.
Eyman’s Pizza is good if: you are in a pinch, live in Hillman City, and need Halal Zabiha ingredients on your pizza. I am two out of three in this list.
I am more along the thoughts of Dashel S.; Eyman’s is quick, affordable, nice people, not mind blowing by any means, just basic & unsophisticated pizza.
It would be good for a kids pizza party, or for your friends who like their pizza simple and familiar.
I hope they continue to stick around for the people in the hood who like/​need Halal (and it is a need around these parts) ingredients on their pizza… but to be honest, it won’t be a go-​to point for me.
btw: This seems to be a family business because the cutest little kids were running around the joint… and the little boy who handed me my pizza… what a cute little fella.

This place is within walking distance of my house in Hillman City, so I was surprised when we walked there the other night to learn that it has been there for over a year! I have driven by dozens of times and didn’t notice it until recently (they just got some new signs). My husband I and walked there on a whim after deciding we didn’t want to cook, and we weren’t sure what to expect from a «Halal» Pizza Place.
When I walked in, I was surprised to see the back half of the restaurant completely blocked off by wooden screens. There are several tables in the front, but I got the sense right away that they mostly prepare take-​out. It doesn’t have a great atmosphere for dining in. The menu is very simple — just the basic, classic pizza types. It’s also incredibly inexpensive — only $ 13.00 for a five-​topping Large. And the night we were there, he had a «buy three get the fourth one free» special.
The person who took our order was very nice (probably the owner). We ordered a large veggie pizza with black olives, onions, green peppers, mushrooms, and tomatoes. He told us he was out of their regular crust but he had thin crust left (it was amazing!) Before he gave it to us, he asked if we wanted to try his special herbs. I said yes.
My husband and I both thoroughly enjoyed every bite of this pizza. The sauce is fantastic, and the herbs sprinkled on top added a tantalizing flavor. The crust is light and flavorful, and the toppings were fresh.
I am so excited to have this awesome pizza place so close to our house. It’s not in a great location, and there aren’t a lot of places to park, but if you’re looking for a delicous pizza to go, you should try this place! He really, really needs the business, and I don’t think you’ll be sorry. Oh yeah — and they deliver!