Three Tarts at the Plaza Food Hall

Cute options, some marshmallows, tarts, lots of cookies, biscuits, tiny cakes. I tried some of their marshmallows, cookies, and tarts and they were all good, but a bit underwhelming for the price. The marshmallows were about $ 1 each for a 1“x1″ square (I expected more for the price, best marshmallow I’ve ever tasted but not worth the $ 1), tarts were about an inch wide (flavorful but a bit too sweet), cookies/​biscuits varied in size (I liked them most, tried a few random ones).
I’d come again just because I had the great service. The girl on staff who helped me was extremely kind and polite.

Three Tarts is a hidden gem at the Plaza Food Hall. Homemade marshmallows are one of the exquisite treats you’ll find here. I took home mini tarts (filled with nuts, chocolate, caramel), assorted herb flavored marshmallows, yumballs and heart-​shaped cookies for my nephews. All these treats were made with love. I even shipped s’mores back home.

Decided to try this after purchasing a groupon deal for $ 12. By buying the groupon deal, groupon will donate a meal for city harvest. For the value of $ 20, I was able to purchase 5 yumballs, 6 hazelnut praline crunch, and five marshmallows (chocolate rosemary, mango, vanilla and espresso). This makes the perfect gift for the holidays as the bites are tiny and unique. The service at Three Tarts was not rushed and polite. She even gave me a 10% coupon in return.

I thought — it’s a marshmallow. How good could a flavored marshmallow be? Well it was… very good! (Mango and passion fruit)

Best marshmallows I’ve ever had! Truly. I’ve heard a lot of good things about Three Tarts even when they were still located in Chelsea so when I saw a groupon I thought its a great chance to try them out. I bought marshmallows of course, as well as some mini tarts, brownies, and some other confections. My favorite was definitely the marshmallows and the yumballs! The marshmallows were perfect in its fluffy softness and the subtle and unique flavors. I want more!

The flavored marshmallows were super yummy, but it was the petit fours that I ate up within seconds. We got a Groupon and picked up a great assortment of goodies. Everything tasted amazing and stayed fresh for two to three days. So delicious! Great staff too!

Tried their passion fruit marshmallow and I thoroughly enjoyed it. The other nibbles they had on display looked pretty good too such as the dough balls but it was pretty darn pricy for just nibbles. The cookies did not look appetizing to me at all since they were so flat and small. I’d probably just come back for their passion fruit marshmallows again next time.

I had a mango marshmallow and a passion fruit marshmallow. The mango could have had a more mango-​ey taste but the passion fruit was perfect. Definitely the priciest marshmallow I ever had, but good fun.

I think this vendor does a great job of displaying and packaging their products. Everything always is tasty. The set up is really inviting and cute.
I got a bunch of marshmallows, and will suffice to say that they are yummy. (Disclosure: I am one of the very few other marshmallow confectioners in the city and visited to maintain awareness of the others in my field… while my comments are almost all positive, the fact is that I do not want to be seen as disingenuous or with questionable motives… although let me reiterate, almost all I would have to say is positive and I wish them nothing but the best.)
I did have the peanut butter hot chocolate and while it was yummy, I couldn’t detect even a hint of the PB. But I still drank that whole cup!

I paid 12 dollars for two ice café latte. It was not a coffee but milk.
It was a cup of milk with coffee taste. I went back to ask more coffee and the server pour more coffee, but still the same. No taste.
I wanted to get back my money back they didn’t do any refund.
I think they should improve there coffee or at least they should refund when someone claim about their stuff.

I live right next door to The Plaza Hotel, which is both a blessing and a curse because there are so many delicious food counters in the basement! This place is one of my faves. They have great cookies, coffee, chai and reasonably good hot chocolate. But the real draw for me is their homemade marshmallows (6 for $ 5, I recall). They come in all sorts of flavors, including chocolate-​rosemary, raspberry, mango, cinnamon, vanilla, cappucino and yuzu. I am also obsessed with their chocolate praline pastries, which at $ 1.25 each are an amazingly delicious (and affordable) treat.

I’m only ever in NYC a few days at a time, so when deciding where to eat, I ask myself two things: 1) Will it be tasty? and 2) Is it something I won’t be able to find back home?
Three Tarts was yes and yes for me. Where else can I possibly find a chocolate-​covered passionfruit marshmallow, and a really delicious one at that? They also had other flavored marshmallows — the yuzu is another favorite.

Decent selection of cookies/​pastries but honestly does not stand out that much from the rest of what is on offer in the food hall beneath the Plaza. The competition is FP Patisserie as well as La Maison du Chocolat.