Neighbors Pizza

Just tried neighbors pizza for the first time. I was pleasantly surprised. We got the jumbo pizza that had 32 slices! We had a combo of the New York, Oregon, pepperoni… nailed it. All of us at the office were very happy and would definitely go back for more.

The pizza was gross. The tables were dirty. The bathrooms were discussing. It gave different prices on 2 different menus. I looked on my phone and it was 90 degrees inside! The salad bar was skimpy and my salad tasted sour. The gave us unlimited bread sticks, but they only gave us 2. The thing that really ticked me off, was that one of the workers gave my son attitude and gave us a dirty look while she walked by! I would never go here again or recommend this place!!! DON’T EVER GO HERE

I just moved out to YC in April and have tried out many different pizza places, and neighbors has been by far the best. Ingredients seem to be high quality and the service has been good (they don’t promise a delivery time, but I haven’t had to wait longer than 30 – 40 mins). Definitely try out their speciality pizzas as well

Yum! Great pizza the crust was really good! We ordered the Alaskan not realizing how big it would be. It was huge definitely a crowd pleaser with tons of leftovers. Can’t wait to go back.

It is laid out weird. Couldn’t tell how it worked at first until the guy behind the counter explained it. He was super nice.
I ordered the buffet. Salad bar is skimpy, but it was nice to have a pasta option along with pizza.
Unfortunately, I didn’t get the table close enough to the hot table where the food was. There was a family of locusts who would swoop in on the food so quickly that I couldn’t get any pizza. There were two filthy kids, a fat mom, an ex-​con brother, a chain smoker grandma, and a gang banger boyfriend. I got to hear a smattering of Jerry Springer stories as I ate my pasta and salad.
After I missed two rounds of two large pizzas and cinnamon knots, the counter guy was nice enough to tip me off when the next pizza was coming.
I picked a bad day to go, but the guy at the counter was great.
This place makes homemade bagels and they have designer spreads to put on them. My work crew raves about those.

As a local business located in the same parking lot and now just across the street from the Neighbors Pizza located on Colusa ave. we have tried most of the items on the menu. The staff is always friendly and helpful. The food has been excellent.
The bagels were a welcome addition as now we on occasion eat breakfast there not just lunch and dinner.

Will never go back!!! About two weeks ago we order pizza without bell peppers (I am allergic) it came loaded with bell peppers. We called to let them know and the gentleman we spoke with was apologetic and said we could either come back (we live over 20 minutes away and it was already almost 8 pm) or he would document that we would recieve a complementary pizza next time. We just got off the phone with the manager (we believe) and he was completely rude and told us that the. Best he could do was give us half off, that we should’ve come in that night and returned the pizza. After we explained what happened, he told us that you probably ate it anyways and that he was not going to give us a ‘free pizza’. This guy was beyond rude and nasty and as we were trying to explain further what all transpired he HUNG UP!!! Bad customer service, if they keep this guy, they WILL lose business. We have already been on the phone and Facebook and we are posting reviews and telling ALL along with our friends, associates, and the organizations we belong to in the Yuba Sutter area to NOT go there due to the fact as how we were treated.

Our first time here, ordering delivery, I asked the person taking the order what was the best app, as we knew what pizza we wanted. She recommended the cheesy bread, which we ordered. The wait was an hour, which is normal at dinner time. It arrived on time, the delivery girl apologized that our cheesy bread might be cold because «they left it on the counter» as I’m signing the bill. I told her not to worry. Well the cheesy bread arrived warm, the pizza hot and tastes great! I was pleasantly surprised. I’ve been looking for a great place and I think I found it. They also have good employees who really do care about the food. Any chance you guys could make super thin, one serving, crispy pub style pizza? No one does it. Especially white pizzas. Kudos, nice job.

Placed a delivery order over an Hr ago, and they said it would arrive at 540. It is now 601, so I called them, and they haven’t even made it yet. Will never order here again.

We’ve ordered delivery several times and tried the Ohio, California, Louisiana, baked spaghetti and salads, each order was fast delivered hot and tasty by a polite delivery person. We are impressed with the quality, service and variety of choices on the menu.

I came here for lunch with my husband to try out there new lunch buffet. The ranch is nasty, the salad bar lacks selection, and there were like only 3 options for pizza. Won’t be returning to this location for the lunch option.

I’m updating my previous review to be fair to Neighbors Pizza. Not sure what happened when I visited 8 months ago, it was pretty awful (no flavor, cardboard consistency) but after several people telling me to try it again I decided to give it another shot. Pizza as actually really tasty and so were the mozzarella sticks! Maybe when I first visited they were having an off night and the crappy pizza I received was just a fluke. Whatever is was, I’m glad I tried it again! Will definitely be returning in the future!

Well 3^rd time was the charm I talked with the OWNER Brian and he took good care of us!!! he got us a new pizza and made sure personally it was done right! The food was specially good and we have visited many times since. the food is good everytime. Brian (the owner) assured me he corrected the problem. after all the good service I have had since, I believe him!

The pizza is great! Always enjoy it

I love this place.
If you want toppings that are piled on and falling off, this is the place for you. Their veggie is awesome.

Look at all the specials before ordering. They have great deals. Coming back soon? Ask for a poker chip & collect for a free pizza.

Had lunch here yesterday. Yum. Pizza salad garlic bread popcorn chicken all good. You Gotta try the bagels. Took a bag home. Just like the one from a street cart in New York. And thats next day. They are fresh at 7am according to the sign so will be back for a fresh one someday. For those of us who grew up eating Hal’s Grubsteak the memories are still there just not the sauce. :(Hopefully they will stay open. I’ll do my part. You do yours.

Pizza is good, i have had three or four now, got a chip says redeem chips for pizza, how many chips do i need to get a free one?
Well i have had ten pizzas at Neighbors now, and it will be the last one #10 had very little sauce or cheese and was very dry, guess its time to try a different pizza place.

Favorite pizza place in yuba. Best pizza.
Update to Neighbors Pizza on Colusa Hwy. Pizza was burnt, service was extremely lacking and the «salad» bar had rotted veggies, no veggies or the jar was so empty I cannot see into the bottom of the jar to find any veggies. The girl who worked there was on her cellphone the entire time sitting next to the «salad» bar when I asked if she could fill the bar up and she came back with furry cucumbers and nothing else. GROSS!

finally a really good local pizza place.
good crust, good sauce and good toppings
We’ll be back for more