Marcello’s Pizza

So close & so good. nice restaurant with great staff. Tried the Jamaican Jerk wings today along with our usual large takeout pizza xtra cheese, pepperoni & mushrooms.
Their pizzas are nice, wings were delicious, used the pickup window too.

I was visiting from Chicago and this place was right across the street from my hotel. I’m used to good pizza back home so I decided to try this place. It was surprisingly pretty good. I’d recommend this place to anyone.

Unbelievably amateur. New location with a bunch of idiots working there. Lunchtime Monday, the place is empty, it takes 35min for 2 salads and 2 slices of pizza. They register person claimed it was because lunch special orders don’t print in the back. But we were the only people there. When I asked where our food was at the 30min mark the register guy was sitting on the food prep counter having a snack. A delivery person had what looked like a comp meal and left a mess under the table. No one cleaned it up. Food preparers don’t wear hats or hair nets. We called the main location at George St but got a cryptic answer.
I put one star but I wish there was a no stars category.
The pizza was okay. Best to order take out.

It’s Monday… just shy of noon…
One table has 4 customers well into their meal… no one else stands waiting and we step right up to order. A friendly kid takes our order… two lunch specials (drink, salad and a slice)…it’s 1155…
At 1225. no food… no one has come in after us… one of the employees comes out of the kitchen to sit down at eat lunch… where are our salads our slices???
We go knock on the kitchen door because there isn’t an employee to be seen except the one that’s eating…
We see a kid siting on the counter top on the kitchen eating a slice… the kid who took our order said that the ticket didn’t print in the kitchen… hmmmmmm…the slices and ovens are out front…1230…salad!!! The kid (the who took our order) puts the slices in the oven…
1240…the slices come out… perfect!!!
But seriously 45 minutes for a salad and a slice x2…
It’s gets a star because the slice was AWSOME!!!

I dont know what it is about this location, but they have sincerely put the Marcello’s name to shame. Having grown up in Dallastown and ordered from the Windsor Commons location for over 10 years, after moving to Hellam — was thrilled when they opened a closer location. This location does not honor the same cheap reasonable lunch specials as the other locations, let alone they have messed up my orders on multiple occassions. At one point as I was looking to pick up a pizza on my way home from work for my family, I ended up sitting in the drive thru waiting because they gave my order away to the wrong customer so they had to make me a whole new one! Want to know how they tried to compensate their idiocy? They tried to offer me the other customer’s order! Let alone, now with delivery services, apparantly they also have a $ 2 delivery charge just for the sake that they have to bring it to you? I feel bad for those delivery drivers because that certainly lessens the tip for them! Get on the same page as your other locations, Cinema Drive. I highly recommend Jim&Nina’s, Boardwalks and Marino’s all within a 1 mile radius from this location!

We ordered delivery only to be disappointed again. Once again (we’ve given them a couple tries now) our order was wrong. Wings were not well done again, the ham boat ended up being a cold sub instead, and the grilled buffalo chicken wrap was less than desirable. On the up side the Stromboli was good. Unfortunately we have just had too many orders not turn out well so we will not be ordering again.

Great new restaurant in the east end. Great pizza and wraps. Very friendly service. Dining area is good for small or large groups.

Great food wonderful family owned business. Beautifully decorated, very reasonably priced. We will be back again