Joe Cristiano’s Pizza

Really good pizza and side! We ordered delivery and it was to us really quickly. The food was on point and better then other places we have tried in the area

Four or five for the food… Two stars for the delivery, the delivery people are great but the time from ordering to delivery is extremely long…
Pizza has always been great, their meatball sliders are tasty & cheap. Their wings are extremely tasty!!!
At times we have not ordered here to to «last minute» decisions to order in & lengthy delivery times…
If we plan ahead & don’t mind waiting/​allow time will order in. The food has always been at acceptable temperature, never cold, always warm enough to enjoy & if just wings hot!!!

Tried a lot of pizza joints around here and found Joe’s to be about the best pizza in the area! Their wings and wraps are great too! If I have any complaint I’d have to say it’s for the mozzarella cheese stix. kinda small n reminded me of frozen from the store. Also, the garlic knots and eggplant could use a lil more flavor and less oil. I’d go more homemade n kick things up a notch with these things, but the pizza etc… kicks butt!

Given that Joe Cristiano’s is a pizza place it is somewhat surprising that the pizza is the worst thing I have had off their menu, it isn’t bad but neither is it particularly good. On the other hand their wings and subs are very good. In fact I think their wings are significantly better than the ones from any of the wing focused restaurants in the area.

Out of 5 other Wappingers falls pizzerias, this place makes the best pizza I like in my opinion, we just ordered a thin crust crispy large, it was perfect and the sauce did not taste like it was straight out of a can, nice seasoned chunky sauce. The garlic butter wings were also beyond good, crispy and meatier than the competition. Def recommend this place!

I can’t begin to say enough great things about Joe Cristiano’s ! They are truly awesome! I am a frequent customer of theirs from ordering take out to stoping in with my 3 little kids. Their salads are great and really inexpensive and very large. Their pizzas are great delicious and always piping hot, and their wings Oh my gosh!

This place is normally pretty good, but I’m really disappointed with my order tonight. I ordered a chicken Caesar salad, pretty basic order. Instead I got what I assume is a house salad covered in about a can of black olives, onions, and cold chicken. No croutons or Parmesan cheese. The dressing tasted like Italian, but who knows.
Like I said, we normally like the food there but tonight not so much.

I have to be honest I have, been going to Cristiano ’ s since they first opened in Hyde Park and have always loved them but tonight I got a plain pie from the wappingers location and it was horrible. It was burnt and somehow cold. Usually they are pretty good but this pie was like they just tried warming up a day old pie. I also got wings which were good but the pizza is leaving us very disappointed. I think this will be the end of my business at this location.

Took over an hour for delivery. Chef salad was minimal. Bad lettuce, a few pieces of ham and cheese and a few olives. Not worth it at all. Won’t go back especially with all the really great places in the area.

The meatball sliders are such a simple idea, I don’t know how I’ve never thought of them before. So good for only a dollar. They have killer wings. They are perfect ans crunchy. They are incredibly reasonable on prices. Yum!

I had never heard of Joe Cristiano’s until they opened up in Wappingers Falls, I have been a customer twice since then and both times I was not disappointed.
The pizza was spectacular, especially their Grandma sicilian with a very heavy but not too overpowering presence of garlic in the sauce, making for a very delicious pie.
The Chicken Bacon Ranch and regular Cheese pie were also very delicious, and I was not expecting Rice Pudding from a pizzeria to be as amazing at it was! They’ll continue to get my patronage for sure!

SWEET JESUS JOE CRISTIANO’S HAS OPENED IN WAPPINGERS!!!
Nothing but EXCELLENT FOOD at this place– from the pizza to the pasta to the homemade rice pudding! A few years ago I moved from Westchester to Hyde Park, and I ate at Joe Cristiano’s at least twice a week, it was the only place to get a good pie up there. Then I moved to Beacon, and although the pizza selection is much better, I still missed Cristiano’s. I was ecstatic when I got an email announcing their opening in Wappingers, and have turned others in the area into believers! Try their meatball sliders– so cheap at $ 1 for one, and they taste absolutely amazing! And their pizza is perfect– get a fancy pie if that’s what you like, but a plain slice will always be the ultimate test, and proof that they know what they’re doing. Besides that, everything on their menu is delicious, EV-​ERY-​THANG.
My only «gripe» is that they run out of the rice pudding way too fast! It was explained to me that they make the pudding at the Hyde Park store and bring it to the Wappingers location so it’s first come, first serve. But the pudding is way too good you guys should def stock up on that! Or teach the new crew the secrets. I mean it’s to the point where I’m ready to give them my number and have them call me when there’s leftovers they can’t get rid of. Definitely try this place, and sign up online to receive coupons and deals!