Fudge Buckets

The fudge here is pretty good, but it’s not the best I’ve ever had. I do have to say I prefer Kilwin’s. I do think it’s really cute that their fudge comes in little «buckets» with a spoon. It’s quite convenient.
I got peanut butter fudge from here on my first visit without trying it. Opened it up when I got home and it tasted pretty much like peanut butter straight from a jar only a bit sweeter. Just not very good at all and a flavour I would never get again from here.
Since that first visit, I’ve become smarter and now I try the fudge before I purchase. They do allow you to try as much as you like.
My favourite flavour from here is the chocolate peanut butter and I have bought quite a few of those little «buckets.»
I haven’t tried it, but they do offer hand-​scooped ice cream here in waffle cones. They do have a good variety of ice cream flavours.
The shop is pretty small and is NOT wheelchair accessible. This is not uncommon in the historic part of St. Augustine because the streets and buildings are so old. It is necessary to preserve these beautiful old buildings, so they won’t be making them accessible.
Customer service is hit or miss. I’ve only ever seen young people working here and sometimes they are really friendly… other times, not so much so. They aren’t rude, they can just act as though they’d be somewhere else rather than assisting you, the customer. Can’t say I’m surprised because we are talking about young «adults.»
They also have hot chocolate. It’s nothing fancy or exceptional (it comes from a machine), but it is good and warming on a cold winter’s evening.

The ice cream was great. The selection was just right. To make things even better, they had a slew of styles of waffle cones.
The flavors of fudge looked great. I am thinking I’ll pick some cookies n cream up on our next visit to St. George street.
It’s a small place with a couple of tables, but there are plenty of benches just outside.
The only downside was that they wouldn’t give me a glass of ice water, I had to buy a bottle.

Zach was awesome, the fudge was awesome… in that order. A great place for a snack when browsing St George street.

Delicious fudge. Must try the amaretto or frisky whisky. The location may have changed but it’s still tasty.