Pizza Makers

Great pizza. I live in East Longmeadow and usually get it delivered, Always gets to my house still hot. Ordered from here at least 20 times and happy every time. I’ve ordered plain, pepperoni, and many other combos and was satisfied with them all.
I would sit down at the place but I don’t think they have beer.
And if you like spicy buffalo wings… Try the «death wish wings» if you like something that is actually spicy and not just rated G spicy. Reminds me of the old Quicky’s «Dead on Arrival» wings back when they were in EL (maybe not quite that hot but fairly close). Also if you don’t like extreme spicy, Pizza Makers have good regular hot wings too. They are the smaller type of wings perfect for watching the game. To be honest, if Wings over Springfield delivered to EL I would order from there, but they’ve stopped doing that so… Pizza Makers can get me those actually spicy «Death Wish» wings which fixes that problem!

I love the pizza but ordering on the phone here has to be one of the worst experiences. You have to repeat yourself constantly or yell into the phone. If you cannot hear do your customers a favor and move away from the noise. This happens every time I call, but I never have this problem with anywhere else

I grew up in Jersey on some of the best $ 1.00 slices on the planet, and now in 2015 I finally found a great $ 2.00 slice in Springfield/​East Longmeadow. All I can say is thanks Pizza Makers, I really haven’t had a really great slice of plain old cheese pizza since I have moved up here.
Wife and I also split an order of wings and they were also great.
I (we) will definitely be back.

My BF has been coming here since hs, since it’s down the street from his family’s house. We ordered a medium pizza for 12 (+2.50 for toppings). We called in to pick up and when we got there, 20 min later, they had just stuck the pizza in the oven and said it would be a few min. I thought that was the reason people called ahead? So that it would be ready at the allotted time they’ve said? The pizza was really good — very cheesy! And it’s a value. The size of their medium, is equal to an extra large Pizza Hut pizza. I would order from them again, but they should have the food ready when they say it’s ready to be picked up.

One of the best pizza places in the area, although the prices are higher than the other places we get pizza.
We first gave them a try three years ago. At that time, there were a bunch of reviews online (not from Unilocal) — most were glowing, but there were a few that referred to a rude female manager and bad customer service related to her. Decided to give them a shot anyhow.
So far, we’ve only had one problem, and there was no rude service involved. An order of fries was left out of a delivery. We called & they were supposed to bring the missing fries, but they never came back.
Every other order had been tasty, fresh, & well-​done. The flavors of their pizza far outshine their competition.
The only negative I can think of was their Pasta Faggiole soup. Didn’t care for it. All the other places I’ve gotten this soup have just a hint of tomato in it and are loaded with cannellini beans. Theirs had a thick & heavy tomato base and few beans. I was sure they’d given me Minestrone soup by mistake. Perhaps there’s more than one way this soup is typically made.

These folks do a pretty darn good job for take out pizza and wings. The pizza has always been very good and the individual slices are large so they will do quite nicely for lunch. The Buffalo Hot Wings are a clear winner, spice level is dead on and the price is less than the other local competitors. So far I am quite satisfied and will continue to go back to try other items on the menu.

Solid
Can’t say to much. Middle of the road, nothing really stands out anymore. I used to really enjoy this place, but now I’d have to be driving by to order from them again, even then not sure I would.

I’ve been going to Pizza Makers for 25+ years. When I was a kid it was the only place my parents would order from. For many years I would have said its the best pizza in the world! Within the last year or two it seems like they’ve gone down hill. The pizza isn’t as consistent as it used to be and the service isn’t very good at all (we got a party cheese recently that was worse than a frozen grocery store pizza!). The pizza is still good, but not the friendly/​consistent experience that it used to be.
Lastly, they need to upgrade their exhaust fans, the place is always smoky enough to make your eyes water!

I love Pizza Makers. I’ve been going here since I was in high school. Best hot wings around. Their pizza slices are huge. The only reason I didn’t rate it 5 stars is because the prices are up there. $ 10 for a small cheese pizza is a bit much in my opinion.