Peppas By The Slice

Oh. My. God.
So, came on a Tuesday to do the All you can eat special. This did NOT bode well for my diet.
Brought a friend.
We got through 4 slices. That was it. (We also got a side of Garlic knots, because… Garlic knots.)
The slices had an amazing variety. As a vegetarian there were several pies I could have, and sadly a few I couldn’t due to bacon. (But they looked amazing, too.) My dinner partner had no such inhibitions and opted for the Mac and Cheese pie with bacon and… Um… Can’t recall the other. But I really wished I could have tried the mac and cheese. I got a Sicilian slice and a slice of tomato and fresh mozzarella pie. (It was supposed to be Margarita, but they had no fresh Basil.)
The Sicilian slice was crisp on the edges, and soft and fluffy inside. the dough had a good taste. The other slice was thin.
The garlic knots were fresh, bready and pull apart. Dripping with infused oil and garlic.
The fountain sodas are not the run of the mill. They had RC cola and flavors. Root beer, orange, etc.
There was a case of other beverages.
I’m excited to try this place in summer and get a beer from the Beer Store next door and have a pizza and beer on the porch.

Food is awful. Just paid $ 20 for soggy fries and overcooked chicken wings. Will never go to this one again.

All you can eat pizza, drink included for about $ 8? How could you go wrong! I love the BBQ chicken pizza, I can’t put my finger on what it is about it that makes it different but it’s much sweeter than other BBQ chicken I’ve had.

The food was amazing, but the staff seemed distracted and rude. I would eat here again, but probably just delivery.

Good food

While the food may be greasy and oily from time to time the service is where they really get you. Upon having several teenage employees, the quality control of their products truly suffers. My wife and I placed a «to go» order bring it home only to realize the order had been ruined do to poor packaging leaving the order’s contents mangled together. Not a big deal, so I call the Peppa’s to inform them of the error and tell them i would like to replace my order with a brand new order or another for of compensation for the foul up. I’m told nothing can be done unless I comeback down, so I asked to speak to the manager, the girl replies with he is to busy to speak with you and disconnects the call. If this is how they treat their customers then they have definitely lost a patron who has been coming for 5+ years.

Like there pizza slices. Also a fan of their steak and cheese sub.

Unquestionably my favorite restaurant in the Springfield area. I go here a few times a month at least. It’s so hard to find a place that sells specialty pizzas by the slice, and Peppa’s slices are amazing. Huge New York style with thin, crispy crust. Their deep-​dish pies are also delicious. Gigantic servings of french fries. If you live in the area and love pizza you owe it to yourself to give Peppa’s a try. They also now have a second location next to Paddy’s Pub on Breckwood Blvd. in Springfield, which I’ve yet to visit.

I admit it, I am a fiend for Peppa’s buffalo chicken pie. It’s a monument of neon orange buffalo chicken and creamy blue cheese flavor atop soft, pillowy dough. Not to detract from their other pies or anything, but the buffalo is my usual purchase.
And they do offer a large selection of other pies. In fact, they seem to be trying for an Antonio’s Pizza by the Slice kind of thing with their «specialty» offerings. And while they don’t offer anywhere near the flavor selection as that venerable Amherst institution, nor do they quite match the quality, they’re certainly appreciated for trying.
They’re also appreciated for being one of the few local pizzerias who not only has their own style but manages to make pizza that’s actually halfway decent. In contradiction of one of the other reviewers, Peppa’s biggest draw for me is their dough. Pizza dough is SUPPOSED to be soft and floury, not hard and corn-​starchy. Unlike most pizzerias in Springfield, Peppa’s gets pizza dough right!
Granted, you might not want to load on the toppings, especially moisture-​soaked veggies, for fear of floppiness. But you should be going for that bright orange buffalo chicken and gooey white blue cheese anyway, not… green…things.
Incidentally, I first experienced Peppa’s several years ago via an «all you can eat» night where I scarfed down several of their cheese and buffalo chicken slices. It seemed popular with college kids and youngsters at the time. If it’s still something they entertain I recommend dropping by for a taste as it’s a great introduction to their pie.

Dude, this place is legit! If you want a nice, thin, delicious slice that totally melts in your mouth, then come here! I’ve been here a few times and have never been disappointed with my pizza.
You get to select a single slice of pizza that varies from sweet and sour chicken to a plain cheese that is rather appetizing. This is my two year olds favorite place to go when it’s his night to select a place. It’s about $ 14 for three specialty slices and two bottles of vitamin water. Pretty good deal for a family dinner!
They also have all you can eat and a fountain drink for (about) $ 7.50 on two weekdays of the week. If you’re hungry for something good and want a sweet deal, go here. They also do delivery and make whole pizzas to go. If your feeling frisky, get a beer next door at the beer shop and a slice of pizza from here and enjoy it on their patio. Talk about a sweet meal!

Delicious pizza. Prices are very good. I have tried 5 or 6 different kinds now, all good. Solid place and right next to the Beer Shop, which is glorious.

I went to Peppa’s on Saturday night to order some food with my girlfriend. I only planned on getting two subs but when I saw their selection of specialty pizzas I had to indulge. I got a roast beef sub with american cheese, lettuce, tomato, grilled onions, and mayo. All of the ingredients were extremely fresh I had a hard time putting the sandwich down. My girlfriend ordered a chicken parm grinder with sauce on the side because she doesn’t like when it gets soggy. It was absolutely perfect. The sauce was DELICIOUS. You could tell that they were fresh breaded chicken tenders and not the frozen pre-​packaged ones. My girl got a slice of buffalo chicken pizza which was amazing, and I’m not normally big into buffalo. I got the spinach, eggplant and ricotta slice which honestly I don’t have words for. If you like eggplant and spinach you need to try this pizza. Last, in our moment of gluttony, we ordered cheese fries. All I can say is wow. They were seasoned potato wedges with mozzarella, cheddar, and bacon. They were similar to potato skins. I will definitely order from here more often, because other pizza places in this area are mediocre and fall short in comparison to the quality of food I received the other night.
I have worked in a pizzeria for four years so I like to be very analytical of the service when I order out. There were many people working in the kitchen together, making our time spent waiting significantly shorter than I expected. The girls working behind the counter were friendly and kept themselves busy. We decided to stay and eat at one of the booths in the far corner. One of the girls walked around, sanitizing the tables. She asked us how everything was and told us to ask her if we needed anything. Literally five minutes later a different girl walked around cleaning the tables again. She even was courteous enough to ask if we minded that she cleaned the table next to us. I would definitely recommend this place not only for the delicious food, but for the great customer service.

Variety of ingredients and style pizzas, they make their own soup and shred their own cheese. With a town full of pizza places they still managed to stand out from the rest! The counter girl that’s usually working I think her name is Miranda is really sincere and always helped me leave happy. Good job guys!

Live so close I can walk there so we order from here a lot. I love the BBQ chicken salad filled with lots of chicken, onions and peppers smothered in BBQ sauce. They give you a garlic knot to go with it, yum! I recommend the Greek dressing on it. I love all their grinders too, usually order the eggplant parm or chicken bomb, both taste fresh and delicious! BBQ chicken pizza is yummy too. Favorite pizza they have is the chicken and broccoli, it’s a white pizza with garlic, olive oil, ricotta, broccoli, chicken and mozzarella. Love it!
The only complaint I have is sometimes you order things and they aren’t as good as they usually are. Not sure if it’s a different employee making it different or sometimes if you order late, Peppas express makes and delivers it to you instead. Still good just sometimes not as good. Definitely order from here on the regular!

It’s OK. I’ve been here a few times in the past but would rather not return. I’m not a big fan of their pizza. Let me clear that up. I’m not a big fan of any kind of pizza they make here. The regular cheese is awful. It’s hard to make a terrible cheese pizza unless your trying at home and have no idea what to do. The other specialty pizzas are edible but not something I would ever be craving for. I say give it a shot if you want to try pizza with some creativity. I mean that in a good way. They have some very interesting combos of pizzas they come up with. It wasn’t for me, but I would still recommend it to anyone looking to try out something different.

Ordered a pizza tonight, delivery was promised within an hour, a bit long since the place is barely 10 minutes from my house. Ended up ordering anyways. It took over 1 hr 40 mins for the driver to get here and the pizza was completely cold of course. The store manager gave me an attitude over the phone rather than make things right. I’ve ordered from this place several times before but doubt that I’ll do so again. The pizza isn’t bad which is why they get 2 stars but the awful service just ruins it.

Creative slices, but mediocre taste. Crust and slices in general were very very dry and almost inedible, especially the French fry slice. I didn’t eat the crust because of the flour-​like powdery dryness. The slices are kept cold and reheated upon ordering. Maybe they should be kept warm to avoid drying out. The slices were priced pretty good with four costing around $ 12. This is like the third time I’ve been there with always the same result, dry pizza.

I am torn. I love this place but my most recent visit has me disappointing.
since moving here, been on the search for best pizza.
Peppa’s is really good. my fave is Rosemary’s Potato bliss, its not listed on their print menu but it is online.
Their french fry pizza is also great. For the plain janes, pepperoni is yum.
so, since i have been talking this up to friends, we decided to go for lunch. There was 7 of us and we ordered 2 large pizzas.
as I am eating, i notice hair on it and thinking it was one of the girls we were with. NBD tll i started to pull it off. nope, it was baked into the crust!
i went up to the counter to tell them about this and all the girl could do/​say was give me a grossed out look and offer to throw it away. it was pretty busy that day, so i waited til the crowd died down since i didn’t want to gross out the other patrons.
so, you are not even going to inform the cook? I was about to make a scene but figured if this was how they handled these kinds of situations, then I am better off going elsewhere for pizza. I guess i should have done it when it was busy! Let the others see how they aren’t really concerned about sanity here.
so, look out for hairs. it was pretty long too.
I doubt I will come back anytime soon. Its a shame because Peppa’s was delicious.

Like a magnet every time I am in the area… i am drawn to peppa’s for some delicious pizza. i have never been disappointed. their selection and variety is off the charts… but i’m strictly a pepperoni, sausage and hamburger topping sort of guy. the ingredients always seem high quality… and the way they bake the pie=no grease! staff seems friendly enough. its always ready when they say… and it is definetely 4 star quality. what more do you want? enjoy!

My New Years resolution is to not over-​rate businesses on Unilocal.It’s hard not to over-​rate Peppa’s as long as you rate them solely on their pizza. Every time I’ve been there it’s been with a group of at least 5 people. Conveniently we all shared pieces of what we ordered in the spirit of «OMG you have to try this». Arguably the favorite of both visits was the «BBQ Chicken» pie.
Regardless of your taste they have a large/​wide variety of pizzas ready to go at any time. Old world Sicilian, eggplant/​ricotta, meat lovers, etc. They even have a french fry pizza.
If you consider it a down side, it’s a pizza joint. You order and pay at the counter and someone brings your order out. I don’t have anything against pizza joints, just don’t expect ambiance. Frankly ambiance means nothing when you’re enjoying pizza like this.
If you’re in the area it is worth the stop.