My Pizzeria

Only been here once but the pizza was great. Fresh ingredients and prepared by someone who obviously knew what they were doing, cooked just right.
People were friendly and warmly greeted their customers which must have all been, but me, regulars.
Prices were very reasonable especially for work week lunch.

This is by far on my favorite Italian restaurants list! So delicious! Love getting half and half pizza, Sweet Hawaii and Dominics. It is BYOB, which I love; pizza and a glass a wine here cannot be beat.

Love the pizza. Mozza sticks are our favourite.

I was in the mood for pizza the other night and didn’t want the traditional «pizza hut/​dominos» pizzas. My Pizzeria’s pizzas are kind of like NY style. Slightly more greasy big slices. The marinara/​pizza sauce is to die for! It’s by far my favorite pizza sauce I’ve ever had. I also had a pizza with white sauce (alfredo). The alfredo was a little on the sweet side but it was still delicious. I wasn’t a big fan of their italian bread which was bread with cheese and a slice of tomato on it. Other than that the pizza was delicious. One of my friends suggested we try the Philly pizza there so that’s next on my list to order!

My buddy and I stopped by their today for a late lunch. The place does not seem to be well kept. We ordered two pizzas, they were better than we expected and made up for the no table service, no gratitude for our custom or our 20% tip. We won’t be in any hurry back. One or two of the owners /​managers seemed to be there but the lady took no notice of us. Given what we assumed were a manager /​owner present we expected some kind of interaction. The place was not busy, we left understanding why that was the case. Reading other reviewers of this place, I am dismayed. It pretends to be a Christian welcoming restaurant, they need to take a leaf out of the Mormon playbook.

My favorite Saturday night spot. The pizza is really good and the atmosphere is perfect. Fabio the manager is one of the reasons my family comes back. Great person!!!
It’s BYOW and some weekend nights they have live music. Family environment.
The bruschetta is delicious.

This place doesn’t even deserve 1 star! Their menu list a Stromboli and it includes a great list of the usual ingredients to be found in a Stromboli and yet mine came with just cheese. When I called they claimed I must have seen an old menu, excuse me I used the one that is on Unilocal,if they have made changes they need to let people know when they call, especially if they order a Stromboli but don’t attempt to add ingredients. Besides all of that, the Stromboli was slightly burnt and so was the calzone. We ordered a cypress delight which is supposed to be a «GREEK» salad with chicken, I guess the part of Greece they frequent has a thing for RANCH dressing! WTF??? When I called not one apology only accusations of me ordering from an old menu.

The only reason they get 2 stars is because they delivered sooner than the hour long estimate they provided, but the food was terrible! The garlic bread and the sandwich bread were burned, as well as the pizza crust. The meatballs were slightly overdone on the outside, but mushy on the inside, and tasted like they came from a bag in the freezer. The cheese on the pizza was rubbery and tasteless, and the kids spaghetti was too spicy for my son to eat! Will not be ordering from there again.

We just moved in right behind it, so we decided to try it out after numerous recommendations from the previous homeowner and title company guy. It was beyond what we expected, and we even went back two days later! The pizza was phenomenal. I don’t normally eat pizza due to not liking the pizza sauce, but theirs is homemade and you can really taste the difference! We now have a new favorite pizza place and will be returning customers for many years to come!

The best Italian food I have had in a very long time! We started with some mozzarella sticks & garlic bread. I could’ve made the garlic bread my dinner, it was so yummy! I had to stop myself from overdoing it on the appetizers. I ordered a pepperoni pizza, my husband ordered the lasagna, and our two kiddos ordered the spaghetti w/​meatball & chicken fettuccine Alfredo. Everything was so very delicious and authentic tasting. You could definitely tell that it was all made from scratch with fresh ingredients! I ended up buying a jar of their marinara because it was just so darn tasty! I also ordered some hot wings, and let me tell you, these are some of the biggest wings I have ever seen! They were very juicy & full of flavor!
The ambiance of the restaurant isn’t fancy by any means. But the food makes up for the somewhat lacking décor. You seat yourself, and you go up to the counter to order. There are no waiters, only the servers who bring your food. Like I said, no frills. BUT… The staff was super friendly, and an older gentleman, whom I could only assume was the owner, was walking by to greet each table and make sure that everything was up to par. I will always take my business to places like this!!! We will most certainly be back in the near future to try more of their delicious food!!!

I ate here with my family and thought the pizza was very good but the meatballs were to die for. They were fresh, juicy, delicious and very very yummy. I could make a whole dinner out of that… i think this is a very nice little Italian joint and as I said the pizzas were good and the meatballs were great.

The pizza was really tasty. The crust is good; thin and crispy. Both the pepperoni and Canadian bacon were flavorful and not over salted.
Unfortunately it’s was kind of overpriced, especially with all of the pizza choices in the area. Also, I ordered delivery on a Saturday evening and it took almost an hour and a half to receive it. So, plan ahead!

Truly the best Spaghetti and Meatballs I have had on the Northside of town they meatballs are definitely made from scratch. My Pizzeria has fantastic hand tossed pizzas too. Also it’s BYOB! We have been several times and the food is always hot and fresh. The owner Fabio is always very gratuitous to us.

Best pizza place I’ve ever been to. The pasta with meatballs taste refreshing compared to the bland standard pasta taste from major restaurants. Customer service is amazing. Would recommend to anyone who wants that homemade pasta taste. Go here you won’t regret it.

When we walked in I knew this place was going to be good. The smell was incredible it made my mouth water. We were there on a Monday for a late lunch it was fairly empty which can was disappointing. They have a nice lunch menu with pepperoni pizza, spaghetti and meatballs you know all the usual Italian stuff. The prices on the lunch menu seemed very good something like $ 8 or so. We ordered a margarita pizza which they make in there in house pizza oven. It was great for a summer afternoon very fresh and tasty. The owner and his wife were both there they have an interesting story so ask them about it when you go. I can’t wait to go back for more!

Absolutely love this place. We have to drive very far, but definitely worth it. The pizzas and calzones are Awesome. The owner always make us feel at home. Highly recommended.

Best pizza in town! Absolutely love the pizza and Italian bread. Their Caesar salad is great too. Everything is super fresh and delicious.
Every time we have been the owner has been there with a smile on his face and offering the best service around.
I haven’t tried the spaghetti and meatballs yet but have seen others enjoying it so will return to have my share. :-)

In from out of town and wanted good pizza. Was not disappointed with a great local place.
Had a My Special pizza, a Greek salad and zeppolies.
Thanks for a great meal

Well I’m still waiting to see how good the food may be but what I’m reviewing right now is the atmosphere of this place. They are apparently Christian here and that is fine with me but their sign says «Halal». I would understand «kosher».
The meals were ok to good between the three of us. Better pizza to be had at Tony’s NY Pizza and Drew’s Bakery.
The desserts are about $ 5 each but were absolutely horrible. The tiramisu got returned and the canolis were two small ones and were maybe from Costco or something?
The service was really bad. It was half waitstaff and half get it your damn self. And I think out server was mute. Never said a word. I felt like at Sonic where you’re not sure whether to give a tip or not.
It’s definitely not My Pizzeria! Never going back.

A tragedy has occurred.
I returned to My Pizzeria and my originally high opinions were shattered. I ordered spaghetti and meatballs, and shared a few slices of my friend’s vegetarian pizza.
The sauce on the spaghetti lacked flavor and complexity, while being too «tomatoey.» I know that marinara is supposed to taste like tomatoes, but this was just acidic and plain tasting.
As for the pizza, I was shocked by how thick the onion and pepper slices were cut. The onion slices were about as thick as a Big Mac. I couldn’t even figure out how to bite into the slices at first because of how awkwardly the vegetables were arranged.
The complimentary bread served with marinara, which was excellent the last time I was there, was BATHED in oil.
I’m so confused as to what went wrong. Last time I was here, I confused this place with heaven. This time, I think I went to purgatory?