La Nonna’s Pizzeria

My boyfriend and I always order from here on the weekends. Linguine with clams and mussels in white sauce, wings, spaghetti with meatballs, house salad, chicken bacon ranch slice, white slice, and cannolis are our staples. Never dissatisfied. And the side bread is also awesome.

The salads are delicious! The pizza is good too, but try the spinach salad (and if you’re extra hungry have it with grilled chicken). The staff is wonderful.

In the area a year finally found a pizza joint that I really like. Came in with my son randomly several weeks ago, the owner was extremely nice and the pizza was great. Have since ordered delivery 4 – 5 times and i think its great. Give them a shot.

Standing in there waiting for my pizza obviously looking around. One of the workers went on the floor and his hands literally dragged out dirt. Didn’t think to wash them then decides to stick his hands in the big container of mozzarella and proceeds to put it on dough to create a pizza. So nasty so see that. God knows what is mixed in this pizza we are all eating

Very friendly guys who definitely know how to make good food! They make you feel like family when you go. Their pizzas are scrumptious and the seafood meddley is even more delicious. I adore the garlic nuts as well. Overall, they are excellent. Excellent in service, excellent in food and all in all I will always recommend.

Update– I’ve now tried more than the cheese pizza-​ordered the pasta dish, baked Ziti (whole wheat) and Caesar salad! Both we’re amazing! More food that I could eat in one seating
(I ordered take out). I’m glad this place is so close to home and the food is excellent!

I work right up the street. We get take out at least 2x a week. Never got a bad meal. Vodka sauce is one of the best around. The pizza is very good. Chicken Parm excellent. I strongly recommend this place.

Best pizza!!! Great staff! I couldn’t find a pizza place that I loved… And I LOVE pizza!!! I went to LaNonna’s to try it out and the person behind the counter said «I bet you will be back»… He was 110% correct!!! This is by far my favorite pizza ever. The size of the pie is good and they always have specials. And the staff really genuinely cares that they are delivering the best service. Thank you!

Always a consistent crowd favorite. Good bang for your buck. My personal favorite is the Chicken Parm or the Meatballs. Only con is they have a small seating area so it is mostly a take out place.

Really good pizza and the people that work there are all very friendly. Definitely recommend it to anyone in the area getting pizza or garlic knots

This is our new go-​to pizzeria in the area. The pizza, heroes, & salads are all quite good. A very professional staff rounds them out at 5 stars in my book. Delivery time has always been great too

Great counter person who is outgoing, friendly and fantastic multitasker. Food is solid and better than expected. Delivery is timely and super convenient. Price is right. I’ll keep going to this spot, they just get it right.

We live right down the block from La Nonna’s so this has been our go-​to pizza spot for the last few months. If you go early in the day the pizza is guaranteed to be delicious and fresh– especially the specialty slices. If you visit anytime after 4pm I can’t make any promises. The pizza either tastes reheated or undercooked.
I recently decided to branch out and order a salad, which was actually pretty good. I had the gorgonzola salad that had delicious candied walnuts and I had them add grilled chicken. What I didn’t realize was that this salad was going to be a whopping $ 16. No wonder the website doesn’t list prices. I mean I expect that in the city— but this is Huntington Station!

Easily one of the best pizzerias in the area. Blows away the vastly overrated Little Vincent’s in Huntington Village. Their crust is unique and a little flaky. They are about as good as Victor’s Pizza and pasta house on route 110. The folks behind the counter are all very friendly and very engaging. The service is wonderful, the food is perfect, the prices are just right. I am there constantly.

I will tell you this pizzeria has bad food. The pizza taste funny like a strange aftertaste. The sauce is no good, and that use it on everything. If you think this place deserves more than one star– thAt is your problem. Owner is laughing all the way to the bank off of you people who are regular customers. Victors blows this shithole away.

Business traveller here with some time between meetings… thankful I found this place! Buffalo Chicken pizza was delicious! Cool guys working too. Nice spot to grab a slice!

Short of Little Vincent’s in the village (which is a different style of pizza anyway) this is the best pizza in the area.

Had La Nonna for the first time the other night and it was decent. I had heard about this place from a friend of mine who said the pizza was the best he had ever had. I wouldn’t say that, I definitely wouldn’t say that but it was alright. Came in around 8 pm and was eager to try out some slices in the window but none of them really looked too appetizing. I don’t know if it was because they were really busy earlier and didn’t have many slices left to offer but 8 am on a weekend, the night is young, thought there should be have been more on display. Went with a regular slice and a sicilian and they were just okay. Thin crust, average slice of pizza. For entrees we had a pasta dish with diced chicken in an olive oil and garlic sauce which wasn’t spectacular. I got the Caprese Salad, creamy fresh house made mozzarella, roasted peppers, tomatoes, lettuce, basil and marinated grilled chicken. I LOVED IT. It was so delicious and the dressing was perfection. The menu has lots of options so I may come back to try others however I wish the pizza hooked me and it just fell short of my expectations.

Back to NY to see family (and to eat!!) and this newer place has been sending Groupon/​Living Social offers (yes, I «split loyalties» between NY and Ohio… Don’t judge!!) so when in the area last weekend, my mom and I decided to give it a try. To paraphrase Dorothy, «there’s no place like home… PIZZA!!»
Pretty busy for «off-​hours» (2:30−3pm… YES, my «adopted neighbors» in Ohio, lunch CAN and DOES happen after 12pm!!) There were plenty of individual slice options, including white, Sicilian, Buffalo chicken (?!), a salad slice that looked soooo beautiful I wanted to take a picture of it, pasta (who first though of topping a pizza w/​ziti?!?) but we went ahead and just ordered two plain cheese slices with a shared small (but HUGE!) gorgonzola salad. There’s something for everyone on the menu, and I’m sure this place does mostly take out, as their space doesn’t allow for much more than a half a dozen or so tiny two person tables. Order one of everything on the menu, bring it home, and as you eat it, think of all the pooooooooooor people in Ohioooo who don’t even realize what they’re missing!

I’ve tried almost all of the pizzerias within 10 miles of Dix Hills and this is my go-​to pizzeria. They make a really good pie, though their fault is inconsistency. I’m not a risk-​taker, but I’ll risk it for a La Nonna slice. Sometimes it’s drowned in cheese and almost gross, while other times the cheese is thin as is the sauce, and it has those crispie things (like Little Vincent’s) on its bottom and it’s delicious. +2 stars for those times.
I haven’t tried the entrées here more than twice (unremarkable), but I would suspect the same inconsistency. Also their wait times are seemingly arbitrary. Please, La Nonna, get consistent!
There’s a wine place in the shopping center and a discount beer/​soda place about a two minute walk past the wine place. Recommended.
Also La Nonna runs a coupon in those local Entertainment Today-​esque ad mailings. I’ll post the name when I see it again.