Broiler Bay

Solid burger, great onion rings, decent shakes, and incredibly friendly service. Lots of places to sit. Fries were a bit boring but that’s our only nitpick.
Love how laid back Shoreline eateries are compared to uptight Seattle hipster joints that charge arm and leg.

This place is fantastic. Everything is freshly made in house and cooked to order. You can tell everyone that works there really puts their heart into the food. I love the light style batter on the onion rings and the burgers are delicious. Plus I mean, peanut butter milkshakes! We love coming here!

Come see my friend Jordan here for a great burger and some old school video games (miss pacman). Super friendly and fast service.

Just when I thought I wouldn’t be able to find a decent burger place in Seattle, this place blew my mind. Out of this world burgers, perfect fries and delish milkshakes. Not to mention the FRY SAUCE wow that stuff is bangin. Def recommend. My daughter would also like to add that the guys that work there are hot… Bonus

Food was actually good. I love that the guys working there can do custom orders too and even tell you about their favorites. If I’m in the mood for some burgers and on a budget, I will come back so glad my buddy recommend them to me. Fries also are crispy and soft not soggy.

Stopped by for a pastrami burger, interestingly good. Could have had another slice of pastrami, but still good.

Love this place! Awesome burgers and shakes!!! Really good dipping sauces which is a must have. The guys that work there are always super friendly too!

Great classic burger. I’ve been enjoying their bellevue location since it opened and I’m glad they have a Westside location. You need to check this place out. A qaulity family run burger spot in a sea of fast corporate crap.

Decent food here, my double cheese was good, although I kinda like it when they season the meat pre-​cook, but all in all a decent burger. Fries… meh. Rings… good. I did like the dipping sauce they provide.
But if you’re looking for clean. upscale…organized restaurant fogetaboutit. The place is kinda ghetto. They didn’t match the floor after taking over from the last place that went broke there. Kinda dirty dining room. Cheap chairs and tables. But the kicker for me was the bathroom. A bit smelly, looked unsanitary although it was tidy’d up, I just hate opening the door in a dingy bathroom when all they have to dry your hands is one of those electric hand dryers. That gets me…
Always order to go.

Mm mm COFFEE! They starting serving coffee in the mornings! The girl who was at the window to assist me when I drove up was excited and knowledgeable when I asked her what kind of coffee they served. I ordered an iced white coffee with white mocha and she made it perfect! And for $ 3.34, I pay almost $ 6 in Fremont. Good prices, great coffee and the best burgers.

2 Stars. Went to drive through, great menu, lots of choices, food is cooked to order.
Very sad that there is NO veggie burger option?! What the wha?!

Stopped to grab burgers in the drive thru. Prompt and friendly service from Jordan. It took about 5 or 6 minutes to get the food, but it was well worth the wait. The onion rings are freshly made and amazing! Burgers are are also right off the grill, juicy and full of flavor. I would definitely recommend giving this place a try. I know I’ll be back anytime I need a good burger.

I ordered from this place when my hubby and I were hung over… I mean, the kind of hung over that only a greasy cheeseburger can fix. I called ahead, as I was in no shape to order and then wait. I felt kinda weird about calling (like I was being lazy) but the guy was super nice. I was able to order and pick up in 15 minutes. The restaurant was clean and the workers were friendly and the food really hit the spot.

Don’t waste your time going anywhere else. I regularly drive from Edmonds, Lynnwood or Everett to Shoreline just for this place. Their shakes are remarkable, you can mix the flavors (which I highly recommend) and their burgers and fries are the best you’ll ever find! Also, they have fry sauce that I dip my burger and fries into, it’s just an unsurpassed place.

THE BEST BURGERS I have had around Seattle!!! I love pretty much everything on the menu. It’s a go to if you live around them for lunch and dinner that’s fast and delicious! And the milk shakes are to die for!
The staff is super friendly as well and will always accommodate orders if you ask!
The also have old school video games inside which is really cool and unique.

SOOOOO GOOD. The swiss and avocado burger was amazing! The Big Bay Burger is a homage to McDonald’s Big Mac — except BB does it a lot better. The quality of the meat is definitely a step above average and the onion rings reminds me of the infamous blooming onions. The price is very fair and I love their BBQ sauce. I live nearby and I will be back! Just wish I gave it more of a chance before: D
Service is quick & they are run by a band of younger teenage aged kids — kind of a throwback feeling you know? The neighborhood burger joint and arcade.
On site eating their onion rings… rainy cold Seattle day… omfgggggg it’s so good. They’re just out lol so I got the last batch.
Always made fresh and they have a nice drive thru.

I first tried Broiler Bay about 9 months ago. I have since become addicted. I fell in love with their fry sauce, their burgers taste great, I could drink their shakes all day, and their onion rings are to die for. The employees are always funny and friendly. I visit both locations, and am very impressed.
I took my brother to get some dinner today and he couldn’t stop eating the fry sauce.
Love at first bite?
I’d say so.

Truly amazing onion rings and milkshakes, and all the burgers I’ve had have been good. Fry sauce goes well on everything. The staff are fun to talk to.
Try a mixed marshmallow and Oreo malt!

You know how it goes… You’re tired from a long day at work and refuse to cook, but you’re too cold to get out of the car. And you don’t want to stoop too low, a la McDonald’s or Taco Bell (… at least temporarily), so you look for an acceptable option. Luckily, there’s Broiler Bay which has a drive-​thru, but is not McDonald’s.
I ordered the Grilled Onion burger with half onion rings and half fries (excellent idea, btw). The employee told me that since the burgers are made-​to-​order, it might take a while. It was a little awkward since I’m not used to sitting in the drive-​thru for that long, but a drive-​thru is a drive-​thru.
The onion rings were delicious and apparently are house-​made. Fries were thick cut and did the job. Sadly the burger was rather average since it was a little bland, but that probably could have been easily fixed if I had bothered to get up and grab more sauce while chowing down. Meh. You win some, you lose some.

Broiler Bay has been around for a year and a half or so. The location has been difficult one for businesses since the old Wendy’s shut down years ago but Broiler Bay seems to be doing okay. They operate a drive through window and have tons of space for tables. The décor is rather plain but there are two video games to play. Parking is plentiful.
The onion rings are fried crisp, house made, and flavorful. It has just a bit too much oil but hey now, it’s fried food so that’s to be expected. The fries are okay but not nearly as good as the onion rings.
Monday — Thursday you can get a ¼ pound cheeseburger for $ 2. At that price, it’s a heck of a deal. The meat is of good quality, buns toasted warm, and ingredients fresh. With a lean meat, it can get slightly dry but it’s a great deal overall. The mushroom swiss burger is good. I don’t believe the swiss cheese is real cheese but rather cheese product. I don’t mind that but it’s worth noting.
The tables are clean and in good condition, which I really appreciate. The staff members were super friendly and happy to share a bit about the business and their perspective on food. For two of us, we had two burgers, an order of onion rings, a half and half order of fries and onion rings, and a drink for around $ 11.50 before tip. That’s not a bad deal at all.