Pagliacci Pizza

Amazing pizza! We got the spicy salumi pepperoni pizza and minestrone soup. The crust on the pizza is perfectly crisp and has a slightly chewy dough. The parmesan they give you on the side looks like the average pizza parm, but then when it’s added to the top of the pizza it melts beautifully into the other cheese and disappears. So, so good.
The soup was pretty good, a little bland. Great pizza place.

Good pizza, but a bit over-​priced for the quality of the food (in my opinion).

I’ve ordered pizzas from other Pagliacci locations a lot of times both at home and at work which is why I was so so disappointed today. Ordered a half «Fresh Veggie» and a half «Brooklyn Bridge» with a couple of modifications (substituted onion with pineapple, green peppers with jalapeños and pepperoni with spicy pepperoni). I was appalled at how many things were wrong with the pizza.
To start off, it was completely soggy in spite of requesting a well done base. The box was dripping and the slices were near impossible to pick up and eat. It was just a complete mush. The toppings were extremely disproportionate. The fresh veggie half was overloaded with large uneven chunks of partly baked tomatoes and very little of the other veggie. The Brooklyn Bridge had barely any meat on it. The pineapple chunks were large and kept falling off. The jalapeños were these thick giant slices that could not be enjoyed at all. Because of their large size and thick cut, they completely overpowered everything else.
I’m not sure why they would mess up this order so badly but it was thoroughly disappointing. I don’t think I would order from here again if these are the standards. I’d rather get Zeeks the next time.

The pizza here was actually really good. We asked for extra cheese and boy did they deliver! I laugh because when the lady brought it over, she said: «There is over a pound of cheese on this pizza, hope you guys don’t mind.» Nope, not all!
Saw that they had salads and other Italian items but I’d say the pizza is where it’s at here.

I’m not sure how this location manages to be so different from the U-​district location, but it is. Slices aren’t as hot and there isn’t as much variety, servers not as welcoming, tho polite. But hey, the pizza is still good, and they’re open late. Free fountain drink at happy hour, and they have one of those newfangled «eleventy million» flavor options Coke machines (I exaggerate the number slightly), which I imagine are popular with kids – a bit too complicated for me when I’m exhausted and hungry!

Caesars salad good
Lasagna horrible
Pizza good
Would not go back
There are many other places to eat
Sorry

I used to love Pagliacci when I lived in lower Queen Anne. It the perfect place to grab a good quality slice of pizza when you are in a hurry or looking for a respite from the drizzle or just plain hungry. They use quality ingredients and have some delicious tasting seasonal and favorite pies.
Our friends order every Sunday so we decided to jump on the wagon since it had been years since I’d had it. We went with a large South Philly (Italian sausage, mushrooms, and onions) to split between three of us. The crust is thin, but not so thin that the pizza loses its structure. The sauce is a little sweet and brings the delicious tomato flavor you want. The artisanal sausage was good and had a little bit of kick. Everything worked well together, so well in fact, I downed 4 slices in the blink of an eye. #noregrets
They are a bit on the pricey side, but they use quality ingredients so you can’t really be mad about it. If you are looking for a solid thin crust pizza place, look no further!

We arent from around here but man this by the slice type joint is delish! Clean, friendly staff and good local beers on tap.

Pizza is pretty good, their service took awhile but they we did arrive at about 10:10p and they close at 11.
They were nice, the place is very clean and you can get pizza by the slice. Because the service took so long, they gave us two ‘by one get one’ coupons for single slices.

We came here after the Sounders game but before settling in at our hotel because there were a lot of beers drank that evening.
We ordered four slices of pizza one of which was not good & of course it had to be the more expensive slice. Less than 20 seconds through an oven conveyor isn’t long enough for pizza containing a lot of toppings. The cheese & pepperoni slices heated up nicely though & tasted pretty good.
Service was fast, the location was perfect & prices were decent. I was surprised there wasn’t any hot sauce but even so I think this is a good place for pizza without the wait. Just remember to bring the Sriracha.

I know it’s such a minor part of the pizza slice, but when a place can make a darn good crust, it’s a great pizza place. Shared 3 large and a small pizza with my party of 17? Ate a couple slices of pizza, crust included!
Kids LOVE the Coke machine — I mean, there’s a hundred flavors in that machine.
Service was pretty good. Takes card.

After a long bike ride we decided to stop in for a bite. Previously I had only ever called in for delivery, so the brick and mortar restaurant was new to me. The ladies behind the counter didn’t not greet me upon walking in. There were no signs directing me to anything, so I was unsure whether or not I should sit down or wait for someone.
Finally one of the girls looked at me and I asked them what to do. Rudely they said that I needed to order at the counter and then pay «they are not a full service restaurant»
The pizza was OK, but lacked in flavor. I would not recommend the Hawaiian pizza. The crust is too thin and very bland.

We ordered 15 pizzas for an office lunch and it was pretty good… cant complain when you get a free lunch, right?
Especially when they are making such a huge order for us, it was still quite tasty, thin, cheesy, just greasy enough, and the toppings weren’t too bad. Everyone in the office seemed to like it without any complaints. Nice that they give you a container for the parmesan cheese and included the chili flakes.
(my photo of the pizza looks kinda sad, dang… got my parmesan all piled up on one side)

Good pizza and nice employees. Music was a bit loud and obnoxious today around pregame, but other than that, lovely slice.
Different vibe from the other Pagliacci I’ve been to.

We came here after a Phish show at the Key Arena, they clearly weren’t prepared for the massive crowd. The line was long and stagnant, with only about 10 people in front of us, we waited at least 20 minutes. When we got up there to place our order it was too late to order a whole pie, not a huge deal, but we were hungry! We bought 6 slices — all of the slices they had out. Seeing that you have a line out the door should perhaps lead you to throw a couple of pies in the oven, but they didn’t seem to be that quick on the uptake.
Bottom line: Pagliacci pizza is yummy, especially the crust. Come here for a slice, but don’t come here after a crowded event at the Key hoping for more than a slice or two.

After living in Seattle for a few years now, I can easily say Pagliacci is my favorite pizza place. Moving from Iowa, we had a great little spot called Zoey’s, which is hard to compete with (Zookie, anyone?).
While Pagliacci is a little more expensive, you’re paying for great quality and taste. The crust is perfect and there are always many different options to choose from! Also, try the breadsticks sometime. You can thank me now.

Always enjoy coming back here every time I’m in Seattle. IMO it’s the closest NY style pizza you will find in Seattle. The dough is light & crunchy & I enjoy their interesting combinations. The other day I got a great slice that had figs, prosciutto & basil on a white pizza. It was really yummy.
I also love that they have the huge Coca-​cola freestyle 101. If you’ve never had a fountain drink from one of these puppies, you don’t know what you’re missing. They even make club soda taste amazing. :-)))
This is a nice location with plenty of seating & the folks have always been nice to me. Don’t get those reviews saying that the folks here are rude but I guess you might have to take this with a grain of salt because being from NY, if any one just smiles at me they become Mary freakin’ Poppins. But seriously, these folks are nice & quick. Just how I like it.

Coming from NYC and having visited Italy I have tasted some amazing pizza and am accustomed to it. that being said this is the closet pizza I have tasted in Seattle that somewhat reminds me of NYC pizza. It is descent (not bad but not great) and my go to place when I don’t feel like cooking and want to order something quick and easy. The customer service is great and it is nice that they have your information stored by the phone number you dial in from.
Def. recommend this place and would probably rate it higher if it wasn’t that I cam from NYC

I was desperately hungry and stopped here for a couple slices just before leaving Seattle to go back to Phoenix! I was satisfied with my meal here. Wish I would have tried the salad or breadsticks, but I just had pizza on the mind haha.
Only got pizza by the slice, but in comparison to other places where you can get pizza by the slice, this place was pretty dang good. I got one slice of vegetable pizza, one slice of cheese pizza. I gobbled them both up in record time. The service was excellent as well. Great place to go for a quick, tasty, inexpensive meal.

I spent a great deal of time around Seattle Center. Pagliacci is perfect for those times when I want just a snack on the go. It’s reasonably priced and you can eat just a little or a lot.
There’s usually about 4 pizzas available by the slice. They rotate fairly consistently so they always taste fresh. I had the spring sausage pizza the other day and it was tasty! Grabbing a salad or pasta is quick and easy when you first come in. Whole pies are always an available option.
The space is clean and the bathroom is pretty close to immaculate. Staff members are friendly and responsive.
Overall, a nice, reasonably priced option to grab a bite.