Good Guys Pizza

We’ll patron again for their calzones and garlic breadsticks. It would have easily been a 4 if they didn’t botch our order.
Instead of ordering through Unilocal Eat24, I ordered from
because you can choose calzones from there. There are two calzones that have ‘alfredo’ in the name, and we ended up with the chicken instead of the pepperoni, Canadian bacon, salami, etc. The calzone was brushed with the garlic butter which gave the top a satisfying crunch.
I’ll probably call in the order next time, but sometimes I don’t feel like interacting with people, and it’s nice to order on my phone.

*** NEW OWNERS *** NEW OWNERS *** RIPOFF PRICES.
I have to cross Good Guys Pizza off my list. Prices went up about 30% across the board, and for a minute, after viewing the new menu, I thought I was back in Alaska. Alaska prices. Well, pretty close. That’s not going to happen in the middle of the poorest section of town. I expect the old prices, like $ 10 for one large pizza, not $ 22.99.
Of course, if you work at google or Microsoft and have lots of money, then no problem, right?
I just called Domino’s instead and got two medium pan pizzas with two toppings and breadsticks for $ 18. That pretty much narrows down my pizza choices now.
All the old pizza coupons, like the Family Deal, they will not honor.
Bye, old Good Guys Pizza. I’m gonna miss you.

Rubbery cafeteria-​level pizza. Come hammered cuz fairly unpalatable to a sober mouth. Also extra fart-​inducing so beware thy bottom.

First time we ordered, we had some issues because the order reader was a moron. Nonetheless, the staff made up for it, made our pizzas fresh, and even gave us one of the two messed up pizzas to help. Second time, they made it perfectly, no sign of the moron. The Sausage is undeniably fantastic (oddly top 3 I’ve had even having lived in NYC), they cheese it well even when not extra, and they properly salt their dough so the crust is worth eating. Is it NYC pizza? No. Is it delicious pizza with a staff that, while not perfect, makes up for their issues? Yes. Never done delivery, can’t vouch positively or negatively for that, but pickup is great.

We used to LOVE the pizza here, never the best speed of service but always a deal. The crust was always soft and warm with perfect amounts of toppings and cheese. I believe the place is under new management now and although the cashier was so nice when I visited the pizza itself was disgusting. I placed an order for pick up and when I got it home there were layers of thick yellow cheese piled on soggy, uncooked pepperoni. Even the crust is a different recipe. Sadly we won’t come back for more, R.I.P. Good Guys.

Price is reasonable and delivery was prompt. Bottles of Coca Cola are 1L bottles so it’s a reasonable price for those as well. Pizza was decent size but toppings were scarce. A little over cooked and easily the greasiest pizza I’ve ever eaten. Had to dry it off with a napkin (I never do that) 2 stars for good service and timely delivery, but 1 star as far as the pizza went. If it had been cheaper I would have given a 4 star rating. I have not tried any other items from the menu so this rating only reflects my opinion of the pepperoni pizza. I plan to try other items from the menu, but until I do I wouldn’t recommend this place to anyone for pepperoni pizza.

I have to admit. I’m from Chicago and I ordered BBQ wings. Some of the BEST I’ve had in a very long time!!! Try ‘em fo sho!!!

Bread sticks tasted a bit stale, pizza was ok, not too bad, not too good, its good for the price. Service mediocre, when I called in the guy I spoke with sounded like he hated life and didn’t want to answer the phone, the pizza was over 30 mins late, didn’t get sauce for bread sticks, no chili or cheese packet, when I called in to say the pizza was late the response was «ok» followed by silence until I said «hello?!, I need my pizza» his response «call me in ten mins then I’ll call the driver» waited was going to cancel then lady shows up with pizza. I won’t order from here again, just not worth the wait, the price maybe. Only ordered because pagliacci doesn’t deliver until 5.

We live super close to this place, and order from them often, and we haven’t had a bad pizza in the last two years (all the time we’ve been going here). The only reason I give ⁴⁄₅ stars is because sometimes the customer service can be poor, it will be awkward when we go pick up our pizza but never rude to us. They need some friendlier staff. The pizza is SO good. We always get half pepperoni pineapple and olive and the other half bacon, Canadian bacon and pineapples/​pepperoni with extra cheese. The cheesy bread is like a small cheese pizza. So worth it. The salads suck from our experience. Ice burg lettuce, could have made it better myself. Wings and breadsticks are amazing!!!

I can’t possibly sing their praises loudly enough. Their pizza is a divine gift – doughy, a little crunch, flavorful, medium thickness. (Get the double thick sometimes – for your average pizza, it’s good; but with a chicken & white sauce pizza, the double thick crust is to die for.)
Their breadsticks are made from the cuttings of pizza dough, dipped in Ambrosia Falls and baked until the outside is crispy while the inside is still soft and chewy. Okay sometimes they’re too crunchy and you can’t reheat them which is a shame, but when they’re right they are seriously heaven.
Good coupon options mean you definitely know you’re getting a good deal.
The perfectly dippable ranch that they don’t make fun of me for ordering extra.
Even the salads and sandwiches are really good. I haven’t tried their wings but I’m starting to think I should, seeing some of these reviews.
The late night option is fantastic, too! Thanks so much for catering to the late night munchies, the drunk girls coming home late from the bar, and the restaurant workers coming off a double shift who just want to eat some dinner without standing in the kitchen for one more second. YOU ROCK.

Got a long gross hair in my pizza. And was refused a refund. Will never order from them again.

Total one man show here at 2am. Did not hold back on the toppings which I appreciate. Really good pizza!

This is the place I order from when I want fairly cheap pizza without sacrificing too much on taste. They have pretty good deals. And the garlic butter for the breadsticks is delicious!

This place is very famous when it comes to their pizza and wings. Well, i find their pizza and wings quite tasty so here I am bragging that I taste some delicious food. They have this large list of pizzas that you can also make your own pizza. But the best of them all for me was ALl Meat pizza. I do love meat so I guess thats the explanation.
Nice play, cleaned well. I guess they are folowing standard cleaning prodecures because the place was really clean.

Not happy with «Good Guys Pizza». My husband and I called last night to order one pizza, one dinner salad, and a soda. The total was $ 42. (and some change) After he hung up he looked at me and said «that’s not right, what did he charge me for»? My husband doesn’t like to question people, or cause any waves. So I called back and explained that we had just called and ordered and was given a odd price for what we wanted. He must have been extremely busy because he barked out 2 topping pizza, saled, and a pepsi, That’s $ 42. something. I had brought up their website and prices on my laptop when I called them back to ask about my concerns. I was shocked to see that what I ordered was actually even less then what I thought it would be. We unknowingly ordered the two topping special that was under $ 10. including tax and delivery. I tried to point out that they might have over charged us because we ordered the special without knowing it. His reaction was not pleasant. He told me that people like me feel that they should not have to pay full price like everyone else. WHAT? Ok, that is not what I said, nor what I was asking. You seem to be charging me around double from the menu and… He interrupted with «Do you want it or not ma’am.»?
After the sweet gentleman hung up without my answer, pagliacci pizza was my next call. (It should have been my first call.) They were friendly, informative and honest. So in the end, I had much better pizza, fresher salad, and a soda to wash it down for a fair price.
I don’t know for sure if he was trying to rip us off, but the way he treated me was not acceptable.
Go to pagliacci, better all the way around.

I used to be an avid customer of this place. Heck one of the delivery guys even lives next door and I see his red truck all the time.
I called today and was greeted by some rude gentlemen” KEVIN” who left me on hold for 4 min then proceeded to take my call and just be plain uncurteous in every manner possible. I tried to finish the order with the gentlemen but decided to do business elsewhere to (Gojo Ethiopian) because unprofessionalism is something I refuse to tolerate when doing business (Especially when your talking about the food that your trusting people to make to put in your body).
I am an avid tipper and ordered from this place a 4 – 6 times a month over the past 4 months
I highly suggest that this place improve customer service at every level because customer service will save or sink your business. Looks like the Everett «Good Guys» Branch has better customer service from the reviews. Fiends told me the customer service here is sub par as well.
Your food is good
Your customer service is below sewer trash sea level
(Nobody wants to eat a $ 175 Fillet Mignon in a Batcave with «Swamp Thing»)
Thanks to the «Great» and «Excellent» customer service I have physiologically branded your business with the mental terms like «Trash», «Garbage» an «Dumpster Dive Joints» with dirty kitchens and fat smelly hairy guys with stinking feet all over my food. This is what my mind is telling me thanks to «Kevin»
I am not interested in any free pizza offer from management ownership because you have lost my business for good thanks to «Kevin»
Just want to advise my fellow Seattleites know how I feel about your business establishment and to let your management team know where the root of some of your problems lie.
Phone skills are a key necessity to running any business If your people can’t be professional of the phone then fire them or put a apron on them and let the professionals handle the phones.
(You are a pizza delivery service your business lives and dies on the phone.)
Fix this problem immediately or financially suffer the consequences.
It’s already bad enough in any pizza business you got guys stealing pizzas, missing orders, stealing peoples credit card info, and other stuff that happens in the pizza business. But to be losing fish on the hook because your guy answering the phone doesn’t like his pole is plain stupid.
(I also have a background in internet marketing so excuse my business coaching)

I will note that I have not tried their food, but they’ve seriously irked me.
Leaving your advertisements on a door is one thing. Leaving them on a door to private property is another. Another ENTIRELY is to leave one on EVERY SINGLE DOOR all the way around the building at a business! I work at a funeral home for goodness sakes, people are in mourning! The last thing they need to see is pizza advertisements. The ones on the side doors are proof that their employees were trespassing on private property after hours.
Nuh uh. Time and a place, guys.

Good Guys Pizza is a hole in the wall pizza joint next to what appears to be a strip club off near Aurora and 105^th.
I only ordered from them for pick-​up twice because they have pretty good carry-​out specials and they are super close to walk to for the pick-​up.
I’ve had the pizza twice, and didn’t care for it. Not that it is bad, I just have a very strict palette when it comes to pizza and either like the pizza or don’t. Your mileage may vary. Just because I didn’t like the pizza doesn’t mean you won’t.
Part of the reason is even though the crust is actually pretty good, the pizza was just too greasy for me. I also asked for extra sauce on one of my orders, and it looked like they had less sauce on the pizza then when I had ordered regular sauce once on another occasion.
I also had the bread sticks, which I thought here pretty bomb. The marinara sauce was okay as well. I might try some of their other things like sandwiches or wings later.
In any event, to summarize, if you want an okay pizza from a local establishment vs. the big name chains, or want a pizza at a decent price– they will be a good choice.
If you are wanting a bomb pizza or sides, I suggest trying other local pizza and pasta options as Good Guy’s might leave you wanting for more. They are adequate and possibly ‘good’, but not exceptional.

I’ve ordered numerous pizzas and breadsticks from Good Guys. Some of the best pizza I’ve had compared to Raggazi, Milano, Dominos, Pizza Hut, Pagliacci, Papa Johns, Papa Murphy’s and Little Caesers. I usually order the large two topping carry out special for $ 10.99. The Canadian Bacon and Pineapple (Hawaiian), and pepperoni and sausage are the two I usually get and they’ve always been delicious. The breadsticks are definitely not from a box, you can see them being made and are pretty delicious. I’ve had carry out almost every time and the employees were always nice to me.
This would be a 5 star review, however here are the CONS:
First time I ordered a pizza for delivery I was at the Tim’s Tavern, just up the hill on 105^th. It felt like longer than the 45 minutes quoted but I was very hungry after drinking a few stiff drinks.
One time the breadsticks were a little too crispy. I still ate them because I didn’t want to waste food, and they were still good. But just a little charred.
Still highly recommended. Order a Hawaiian or pepperoni with sausage 2 topping carry out special with some breadsticks. I wouldn’t count on the delivery as some other reviewers received their pizza very late.

I wish Seattle had more late night options but as far as options go, this is perfectly serviceable pizza. They deliver late and use fresh ingredients. The crust is nicely chewy with a crispness. I loved that the pizza wasn’t thick with cheese or overly gloppy with sauce.
Our pizza seemed to go straight from oven, to delivery bag, to our door… a PLUS when the hour is late and you crave decent food for your delivery dollar. We ordered several pizzas and they were consumed readily by the guests at home. I recommend them to anyone who lives within their delivery radius.