Goodfella’s Woodfired Pizza

Hot waiter, and food is Delicious! !!! Definitely, coming back. Very, cool atmosphere..

So good! This was our first time here and we tried the margherita pizza. We’re garlic lovers and this was spot on. Louie took great care of us too! He picked out the perfect wine and always made sure we had everything we needed. Highly recommend y’all should check them out!

Awesome atmosphere… amazing service and incredible pizza! The owner came to our table and described the kid friendly birthday party adventures and special occasions they have planned for patrons. We will most definitely be returning guests! You’re great Louie!

Best neighborhood restaurant ever! We had a group of 12 for dinner and the food and service was outstanding. Sal, the General Manager, made sure we were all satisfied and never without drinks. We watched him entertain the kids tossing pizza dough in the main dinning area. This place is a rare find. Thank you Sal for making Goodfellas what it is. You are the heart and soul of the place!

Wow, I couldn’t believe the service that was provided here tonight. Came in with my family around 8:00 pm on a Saturday night. Not busy at all. Glad to be seated immediately because we were starving.
Out waiter comes to get our drink order and we went ahead and ordered some fried ravioli for an appetizer. so we waited, and waited. and waited way too long… not once did he stop by to refill our drinks. Then, I glance over (we were sitting at the table right next to the fire where they were making our pizza) and there are our 2 pizzas… just sitting there getting cold. So, our waiter walks by and sees them then grabs our appetizer puts it on the table, then turns around grabs the pizzas and says here you go! My husband said, hey buddy, you can keep the ravioli, we wanted that as an appetizer, not with our dinner. Then he looked at us like we were assholes bc we didn’t want them anymore.
The food wasn’t good, the service was horrible — needless to say, we won’t be back here.

I love this place. The atmosphere is great, the service, and the food. I could not say enough about this place!!! If you don’t try this place… YOUR MISSING OUT!!!

Catered Goodfellas for a family baby shower. The food was excellent!!! We had so many compliments on the Spicy Rigatoni a la Vodka and meat lasagna. Good portions of food and was more than enough for our party of 30. Everything was great, we will definitely order from Goodfellas again!

The wife and I have been twice and we love it. The food is delicious and the happy hour drink prices are great. There’s also free delicious pasta for happy hour. We don’t normally do dessert when we eat out but the one thing we find incredibly hard to resist is an order of Zeppolis. Those things are evil.
What we’ve enjoyed the most is the service. The bartenders and wait staff are friendly creating a warm and kind of fun environment. We’re looking forward to our next visits.

The food is okay, however they have one of the worst staff and service I have ever had. We went to this location twice already and both times we had the worst time ever. We had a Groupon but we ordered extra food so the remaining balance was $ 7. We give the waitress our card and she said we had to pay for the whole food without the Groupon because we ordered extra. We asked to talk to the manager but the manager was even worse than the waitress. Absolutely horrible.

Amazing pizza and good beers. They are open late. I can walk in at 11 pm and get an amazing Alfredo pizza with pepperoni.

Goodfellas reminds me of an old style New York City pizza parlor! Their fried calamari is exquisite and their pizzas are inspiring. I recommend this to anyone looking for a romantic/​family/​New York style joint!

My husband and I went to goodfellas in the summer and the pizza was great! We’ve been meaning to go back for a while and he finally went and picked up some pizzas. He ordered a margherita pizza and a four cheese. We both are so dissatisfied, every bite is a disappointment. I’m really sad because the pizza was perfect the first time, and we’re hoping it would be the same. Im sad to say we won’t be going back.

Very friendly service and the food tasted great! Highly recommend the Rigatoni al la Vodka and Spicy Angel Hair Pasta.

I wanted to give this place another try after seeing all the advertising for the great happy hour specials. Upon entering our bartender was very carefree and casual. Drink specials and food specials are a great price! I’ll give them that.
The $ 4 bruschetta was very poorly done. Not only did they bring it out half assed with cheese sprinkled on only 1 of the 3. It was literally like eating a croûton the bread was so hard and crunchy. Tasted like old bread.
I mean just look at it! So sloppy there’s balsamic just carelessly splashed all over it. What an embarrassment to bruschetta, which is one of my favorite things. It’s the easiest dish to not eff up. Come on now.
The personal specialty pizza on happy hour for $ 6 was also a good deal. However our supreme pizza was so meager on the cheese all the toppings kept falling off because there was no cheese to hold it together!
I will say the live «Sinatra» style singer was nice to listen to.

Return visit after many many months. Last time here was before their fire in Dec 2014. After the remodeling and repairs it looks even better now. Five TVs to watch the games (biggest one over the bar). Prompt seating and service during Sun lunch Nov 2015. We got side salads and one Mediterranean pie and took home two slices for leftovers. And we used Groupon coupons which made the meal even cheaper.

Came here for lunch today. The pizza was alright. Not the greatest I’ve had. We had the veggie pizza, and it was just decent. Honestly my favorite part of the meal was the side salad. Super fresh, great portion and went well for the meal.
When we came in there were five or six other tables seated and one server, who I think was also working ad the bartender. (Never got her name) She was clearly stretched thin but never let the smile leave her face. She was great and the only reason I’m giving it a full five stars. Even though service was slower then expected considering how empty the place was and time of day, you could tell she was doing her best that was greatly appreciated.

The first time my wife and I came here it was great, we ordered a 4 cheese pizza and it was generous on the toppings and sauce.
We live close and have been back many times and tried more pies and pasta dishes, the pasta dishes rarely dissapoint; the sauces have great flavor and hefty portions.
However the pizzas, which is my drive for coming, are very inconsistent and in some cases downright poor. Lately it has been subpar; lacking flavor and quality. Most recently I ordered that 4 cheese pizza again, i have ordered it again other times but this one stood out. It came out looking like bread with a piece or two of cheese on it and a couple of squeezes of sauce. It looks to me like they hired a new kitchen manager and they stress food cost over quality or customer satisfaction.
We expressed our disappointment to the bartender and were presented with another pizza, it was a step up from the previous one but still underwhelming and not at all reminiscent of my initial visits.
They try hard, appear overworked and understaffed, and it culminates in less than what I expect for the price.
Though it wasn’t service with a smile, the staff was stressed and dealt with our complaint well enough. That and the great Chicken Goodfella bumped this lengthy review from 2 to 3 stars.
TL:DR — Inconsistent food, decent (albeit flustered) service. There is better food elsewhere for the experience. Try Fireside Pies at the Shops at Legacy, haven’t had a bad experience yet.

I ate at this location for the first time tonight and have also eaten at the Tollway location. Having now been to both locations, I have to say I am disappointed and will not be returning.
Our server was nice and fairly attentive. However, there were a few service issues. One person in our party ordered an iced tea unsweetened, they brought out sweet tea. Another in our party ordered Diet Coke, but waiter did not tell him restaurant serves Diet Pepsi. Had to ask for another glass because the syrup needed to be changed.
My big issue I noticed at both locations is the taste of the pizza. It tastes worse than Papa John’s or Pizza Hut. I’m baffled by this, because they do appear to have a wood oven, which generally produces good pizza, but definitely not here.
Both times I’ve been, the pizza has tasted almost undercooked. The crust tasted odd, almost no flavor. There was zero flavor in the sauce, cheese, toppings. Due to being undercooked, the crust did not have any crunch whatsoever. It’s hard to totally describe, but this pizza is just not good! I don’t see why anyone would eat here when the pizzas at Fireside, Grimaldi’s etc tastes so good! I have honestly had better frozen pizza than what they serve here.
I’d say this is an avoid, there are better options.

The foods good however the wait staff can use some work. Specifically your lunch Bartender.
We used a Groupon today and she didn’t want to take our Credit Card cause the remaining balance was less than $ 5.
The other problem I have is how she interacted with customers who didn’t want to sit in the already cramped bar area.

Our server was a delight. I find it concerning that the only person that acknowledged our presence was our server. I am aware that I didn’t walk into CiCis, but at least you feel welcomed when you do walk into CiCis.
For that reason I give them a 3. The food was ok and our service impeccable, but having the manager and bar guy less than 10 feet away and they not acknowledge us, with a simple hello, is a real problem for me.