Angelina’s Pizzeria

We got white pizza, steak hoagie and Italian hoagie. Everything was delicious! Will def get again

They always mess up my delivery order. Then they are reluctant to fix it, and have never offered any type of compensation. They act like they’re doing me a favor by completing our original agreement for which I’ve already paid.
Sorry but I expect competent service when I pay ridiculous prices.
Where will I ever find another pizza, sub or wing shop that delivers in Pittsburgh?

Best pizzeria in Brookline, hands down. Friendly service and always prompt delivery. Great menu selection too.

There are many great pizza shops in Pittsburgh ! But this is not one of them. The crust was soft, cheese very greasy and the sauce is as good as Vinny’s which is rubbish ! We got a pepperoni pizza didn’t like it could not eat it. I will not be ordering from here again !

Ordered for the first time off of Grub Hub. Portions were very large and the order came early!

Worst experience ever. Food late, took over an hour and cold. All toppings for pizza slid off the pizza into the box. Hoagie said it wabs to have American cheese mushrooms and onions and had none of the above. We did try to fix the hoagie but it was inedible. When we called about it they were rude. Waste of 50.00…but guaranteed they will never get another penny from me.

I ordered delivery from Angelina’s off of GrubHub and was overall pleased with what I got. I ordered buffalo fries which came with «home made ranch» and a white pizza with tomatoes, mozzarella, and kalamata olives. The fries were a little on the limp side and the dressing was pretty bland. The fries were better off eaten by themselves, I did however, use the ranch to dip my crust in :) The pizza was really good! It had a crispy crust seasoned nicely with garlic and there were spots of delicious baked cheese… you know the kind I’m talking about, delicately encrusted, on the verge of browning. The olives lent a nice salty element o the pie. I would certainly order from Angelina’s again, delivery time was reasonable for a Saturday night and prices, as well as the quality were A-​OK.

Oh, Angelina’s.
We tried. We tried for so long to accept your downfalls so that we would continue to order your delicious artery clogging food, but no more.
When we first started ordering from Angelina’s, I thought: uh-​oh. Look at this menu. We are going to be in so much trouble. Such a selection! So many things you can’t find at other places! Zucchini fries – delicious. The cigar rolls? I could make a meal just out of these amazing bits of filo covered fried feta. The burgers? Huge, tasty, unique, and varied.
But the service… Angelina’s ALWAYS takes over an hour for delivery. Always. The food is frequently cold by the time it arrives. The first time we ordered, they said it took so long because we had put one number in incorrectly in our address when we ordered online and they couldn’t find our house. Ok, fair enough. The second time I paid extra close attention to make sure the number was, in fact, a 9 and not an 8, but they still tried pulling the same thing when it took them forever for time #2 and blaming it on us putting the address in wrong. Not cool, guys.
The last time we ordered from them, it took over 2.5 hours to get our order on a Sunday afternoon around 5pm. When we called after an hour and a half, they claimed they never received it – though we had the online receipt. Uh huh.
We have to order from their website, which apparently has some glitches in that system, because even though they ARE on grubhub, grubhub says we are outside their delivery area, though the website clearly says differently.
I’ve tried a couple of the pastas and though they sound delicious – mediterranean pasta with tomatoes, artichoke hearts, olives and feta – they are overloaded with the amount of grease. I should know by now not to order any pasta with «garlic sauce» from a pizza place because its always just drowning in it, but Angelina’s was the worst offender. I had to put the dish in the strainer and rinse it with water for a minute or two just to make it edible. (I was STARVING and DESPERATE, you guys.)
We’ve never tried the pizza, and to be honest, I’m a little bummed that we won’t be. But Angelina’s is just not worth the hassle.

Its not common knowledge but I have a serious addiction to wings. Every restaurant I go to I check their menu for them and 50% of the I get them. No place has lived up to the wings I get delivered from Angelina’s in Brookline though. Absolutely love their spicy garlic and Buffalo wings and their pizza is one of my favorites in the burgh. They are delivering or pick up only and their specials are very well priced. Been in the area for 12 years and this is the only place we order pizza and wings for delivery now…

I don’t see the rage. The pizza sauce had a bitter parmesan taste, While I can appreciate trying to do something different with pizza sauce it just didn’t work for me. and to be honest my Italian hoagie was very light on meat. for 10 bucks you think an Italian would be loaded with meat and cheese.

One problem with pizza is that a lot of pizza doesn’t have much flavor on its own. This place brings the flavor. Went there last night and picked up an authentic white pizza and was pleasantly surprised with good flavors. Not overloaded with toppings and the cheese tastes really fresh. Thin crust with just the right amount of crispy. Will definitely be going back and trying some other selections in the future.

This place seems to have a little bit of everything. Who knew you could get a take out order of hummus along side of your pizza! Small place, great for takeout.
The white pizza was delicious and full of flavor. The hummus was also surprisingly good. While it’s not the best hummus I have had, I would certainly get it again if I’m here and in the mood.
Looking forward to trying other types of pizza!

I found this little gem through another delivery app and I’m glad that I did! Some of the other pizza delivery options have been hit or miss lately so we ventured out and were very pleased with our decision!
I ordered garlic ranch chicken wings and my fiancé ordered Angelina’s favorite pizza then I got the little one a pizza boat. The wings were big and meaty drenched in some garlicky ranch sauce served with a side of house made ranch sauce. I was in ranch heaven! Angelina’s favorite had banana peppers, pepperoni, onions, sausage, and olives. All of the ingredients were nice and fresh! I really can’t complain about a thing! The delivery guy was super friendly as well. I can’t wait to taste their hoagies because that’s what all of the reviews rave about! Oh and they have FREE delivery!

This place thinks outside of the box, and I respect that. Everything about this place is different than the normal everyday pizza place. With offerings like reuben hoagies and beef stroganoff, it might not be what you’re into, but hey, atleast they have the balls to offer it to you.
Personally, this is my All-​Time favorite place to order sandwiches. Pizza is exceptional, but their hoagies are top notch.

I have been looking for a new pizza place and I think I have found my new spot. I was desperate for pizza in the way that only a pregnant woman can be and after Slice let me down and Antonio’s was just awful, I knew I had to search out something new. Angelina’s had good reviews and was close, so it was worth a shot.
I ordered a large with pineapple and bacon. Wow. Real cheese — I think provolone for the bite with a lot of canned pineapple and the piece de resistance — real, crunchy bacon broked into smaller pieces! No bacon bits here. It was awesome. The sauce isn’t too sweet or too spicy, the crust is just spongey enough, but not too chewy. While I do still love me some thin crust, this pizza will do.
I can’t wait to order again and try something on their large, large menu.

What a hidden gem! I’ve been to all the great pizza places in the area… Fiores, Betos, Gennaros and this little place is now on my list as my new favorite First time here and got the Fisherman’s pizza… fantastic. Great sauce, lots of cheese, and plenty of delicious toppings shrimp, onions etc… The tomatoes really made it extra tasty. All toppings were fresh, plentiful, and yummy. The crust is just right not doughy and flavorful. Also got cigar appetizer, very yummy. Can’t wait to try the dessert pizzas.

I ordered several times from them and I was always pleased. They delivered on time, were nice, and the food was good. I was the most impressed, surprisingly, with their burgers. I have always avoided ordering take-​out burgers, especially from a pizza place. But they were GREAT. The next order, another good experience. The hoagies & wings were good. My only suggestion is they need to have a better selection of sodas. Otherwise, I had a good experience and would recommend them!

Pretty good pizza. Fast delivery. This used to be Krazy Brothers and was in Dormont before it burned down. The dessert pizzas are awesome.

In the months since a fire destroyed their previous spot in Dormont (formerly Varrati’s), Angelina’s has finally been reincarnated after a long delay in a small, no-​seating, takeout/​delivery-​only location on the border between West Liberty Avenue and Brookline Boulevard.
While I still sorely miss Krazy Brothers, which once occupied this cramped storefront, Angelina’s food isn’t a bit duff in any sense.
If I had to level one criticism at Angelina’s, it’s that their pizza is yet another spongy, doughy contestant in the forever burning Brookline Pizza Wars. The only thing that really sets this pie apart from its mostly hapless competitors (oh, how Brookline had some serious contenders once…) is that the crust, while typically chewy, sort of pops on your mouth and doesn’t require as much jawpower as it normally would. The sauce and cheese were acceptable, but the crust is definitely a rung above average.
Another weapon this incarnation of Angelina’s has in its arsenal is an uncommon dessert menu. DJ J. mentioned the Banana Cream Pizza, but as tempting a read as it was, Kay and I opted for the gory looking Strawberry Chocolate Delight Pizza. Milk chocolate, cream cheese, fresh strawberry, and shredded coconut top Angelina’s homemade dough, and despite its resemblance to roadkill, this was the highpoint of our delivered meal. The tartness of the plump strawberries and cream cheese bounced off the richness of the chocolate sauce while the coconut provided crisp, textural percussion. It was akin to a supergroup jamming the night away in a small club.
They ain’t Krazy. They’re Angelina’s. And that’s just fine by me.

Stopped by to grab some pizza and some wings. They said it was the Grand Opening week. Enjoyed the «Fresh Wings». Had the hot and would have liked to tried the Wing Dust based on their description. The pizza crust was a medium thickness with a golden brown edge and bottom. We had the Cigar Rolls which are filo (sp, their spelling) triangles filled with feta and some parsley that are deep fried. A little on the greasy side, wish they were baked.
The menu includes Hoagies, Subs, & Grinders. Found out later that you can actually choose your crust — thick or thin. Check out the website for some interesting options including hummus or how about a Banana Cream Pizza!
This is take out or delivery only. Parking is an issue. Room for about 2 cars in the side lot. Street parking is not available in front, it is about 100 yards away so get delivery if you can.