Broad Street Dough

Not your typical donuts, they have a cake texture. Soft, and fresh to the taste.
Never a dull pickup, they have different specials everyday.
Only gave them 4 stars because the donuts are a bit smaller than most, but the taste make up for that.
The employees are super friendly and helpful on what donuts to pick.

I have hear great reviews about this place… I thought there donut was horrible… If you want a great old fashion donut you have to try «GO NUTS 4 DONUTS» it’s out of this world you will tell the diffence in texture there locate in BAYVILLE NJ

If you go by the old adage that people first «eat with one’s eyes», then Broad Street Dough will have you quite overweight before even taking a bite.
Presented beautifully, these artisanal donuts proved to provide a substantive level of taste to backup those pretty looks.
Trying to control my urges I restrained myself to just three donuts: the Jelly donut, the All-​American, and the Coach K.
Jelly donut was really solid. Donut dough was spot on with a nice moist texture and slightly buttery flavor that overall felt very light and not all that guilt inducing. I didn’t care too much for the jelly which had a slightly gloopy texture. The powdered sugar portion was awesome though with a slightly sweet flavor and none of the chalkiness that you can get in some powdered donuts.
This leads me to think that Broad Street’s regular powdered donut would be awesome.
All-​American was excellent. Nestled between the same slightly buttery light donut dough was a nice creamy peanut butter that gave a nice mild salty contrast. Black raspberry preserve was pleasantly semi-​sweet. A really balanced tasting donut where everything just made sense.
Coach K was excellent too with the same black raspberry preserve placed on top of a really smooth and delicious chocolate glaze and finally dusted with powdered sugar. Again I was happy to taste that the donut was not overly sweet even with the powdered sugar (presumably the same used on the Jelly donut).
Overall I really enjoyed Broad Street’s donuts as they offered both a beautifully crafted donut along with excellent taste.

Great donuts. The staff here is great. Always happy to help and friendly as anything. I’ve never had a bad donut and they’re not badly priced. They’re the perfect size so I don’t feel horrible when I eat one… or five.
Only downside is they can be too sweet sometimes. They have alotttttt of toppings. Sometimes less is more.

I can’t say enough good things about Broad St. Dough Co. The shop is located in a very unassuming Monmouth county strip mall. You feel like you are an extra in a Kevin Smith movie loitering outside. The shop inside has a minimalistic hipster vibe with plenty of warm wood tones and a chalkboard menu. The best part of their layout is you get to see the whole doughnut making process over the counter. When they say made to order, they are not joking.
So onto the stars of the show… the doughnuts! At first look, the doughnut itself is smaller than other regional made to order doughnut shops. Truthfully, in your hand it feels more manageable. Their selections include an old fashioned, apple, blueberry, chocolate, and red velvet. I will tell you the red velvet is super popular so make sure if you stop by early, especially on weekends. They prepare the doughnuts in three styles, stuffed, sandwich, and topped. The topped is a traditional glazed or iced with minimal toppings. The stuffed utilizes the center hole for goodness, such as cream cheese frosting or apple pie filling. They slice the doughnut in half for the sandwich style and then put filling in between the two halves. One of my favorites of this style is the All American. It’s filled with peanut butter and red raspberry preserves.
So in closing, don’t be overwhelmed when you see the options. The staff is great and are always helpful in navigating your choices. Make sure you let them know if you have any dietary needs. They have choices for you, too!

As a student at Monmouth university I’ve watched this place (along with rook) blow up. However in my opinion broad street is extremely overrated and has gained all their hype through their impressive Instagram. On more than one occasion the donuts I received were stale tasting. If you want amazing donuts I’d recommend Duck donuts in middletown. They come out hot, fresh and their batter is SO much better if you want good donuts go there.

BEST DOUGHNUTS IN THE WORLD!!! Must try the fair haven. All are amazing though. Also they are made to order so they are unbelievably fresh.

Amazing doughnuts! Everyone is always so friendly and helpful. The doughnut selection is really creative and of course, delicious! My favorite is the Chai– simple in comparison to all of the others, but so good. The doughnuts are on the smaller side… But then you can justify getting more!

This place is awesome. Great doughnuts. Friendly staff. You just can’t beat doughnuts made to order. Highly recommended.

Heard about this place through Instagram and all I can say is WOW. Happened to pass it one day while driving and stopped in. Definitely the best doughnuts I’ve ever had. They are warm and fresh, and they always have new & different flavors to try.

So the donuts are GREAT! The three star review is more about the service. My fiancé ordered a dozen donuts and it took at least 30 minutes. It was as if someone was making them from scratch. The donuts have a bunch of wonderful flavors but are a bit too small for the price. It was pretty busy there so I recommend going at an off hour if you are short for time. We were unfortunately late to a party due to the extensive waiting. I would definitely try it again on a weekday.

Visited today with my friend who’s been raving about this place for months. So this afternoon we hopped in my car and drove the 40 minutes needed to try a place she said «I just had to taste.» The car ride there was full of fun and laughter but the real highlight of this trip was once we reached our destination. To begin with, the photo Wall Menu is awesome!!! Definitely helps the customer with making a decision (in a place of endless decisions) due to variety. Secondly, the ladies that were behind the counter were pretty, fun, and full of enthusiasm. Lastly, and most importantly, the Donuts were colorful, well made and delicious. In closing, the prices are right were they should be in a place that puts as much care and creativity into their product. Will definitely make that 40 minute drive again.

These donuts are INSANE. I ordered six for myself and had zero regrets. They’re the perfect size — not too big, not too small. The atmosphere here is great. Every single employee is super nice and welcoming. They make the donuts in front of you so you can watch your very own donuts being made! They also have specials every day, which are really creative and fun. Their donuts are definitely on the sweet side, so if you don’t have the biggest sweet tooth then you most likely won’t be a fan.
The specials change daily, but as for the classics… I got the s’mores galore, the fair haven, and the broad street. All six donuts were AMAZING. The broad street was my favorite. I highly recommend going here if you’re in the area. You won’t regret it.
Tip: After you get your donuts, walk a couple of shops down to Rook and get a coffee to go with your donuts. Amazing coffee plus incredible donuts = happiness.

Absolutely love this place. Top three doughnut places in NJ/​nyc area, besides dough in Brooklyn and purple glaze in asbury park. Best part of this place is the eclectic creativity of the daily options particularly for vegan gluten free folks like myself

It’s heaven in here. The Staff is amazing always very welcoming. My husband brings me a box when I spend my weekends in Jersey. Their doughnuts are so fresh always hits the spot.

I have been following this shop on Instagram and finally got to stop in and try a few. I loved it from the minute we waked inside. We were greeted by the friendly girls behind the staff and they were happy to share the specials and answer all of our questions. They start with a delicious cake donut and add the toppings or fillings. All of the donuts are fresh and made to order. You can place your order and grab some delicious coffee next door! I can’t even pick a favorite … And we tried 9 !
Make sure to order a love triangle!

Kept seeing these donuts pop up on Instagram and I HAD to make the trip out to get them. I drove an hour up to Oakhurst on my day off to get my hands on these little gems I kept coming across.
Inside was small yet cozy, with super friendly staff. There’s a board with pictures of their classics, and the specials were displayed behind the glass. I ended up ordering 2 specials, a Broad Street donut, and a Vanilla Chai donut. Each donut was prepared fresh so it was about 5~10minutes before I got my box of 4.
The donuts were good, but I expected a little more. The problem for me was the base donut which each flavor was created on. It was not quite a cake donut since it was not crumbly, but it was also a little more dense than a traditional donut. Overall, it’s a little chewier in texture.
Another thing I wished was that there was seating inside the store. Although the store is small, there is definitely enough room for a few chairs and small tables. I sampled my donuts on the little wooden counter on the side where the napkins and utensils were, while standing.
I wouldn’t drive up an hour again JUST for the doughnuts, but I definitely would come again if I were in the area!

I’ve been here a couple times and it’s pretty good. They have a bunch of exciting doughnuts… They even have vegan/​gluten free which is awesome. I thought the toppings were awesome and really good. However, the actual doughnuts weren’t the best. Kind of boring tasting and a little too cakey instead of light and fluffy.
There is usually a huge line when u go in too which makes it hard to go to unless it’s a special occasion or the weekend. It also confuses the people who work there. The last time I went my boyfriend ordered right after me but they weren’t calling his name for like twenty minutes after I got my box. After like five other customers who were behind us got their food I asked what was going on. It turns out someone made half of his order and forgot to fill the rest of the box. Pretty annoying!

Simply amazing. These donuts are made to order and are so worth the wait. Trouble deciding just order a full dozen.

Was so excited to finally try this place, then…
Disappointment.
1. They got my order wrong. Which was slightly unfortunate since I drove up from DC.
2. They’re donuts are not made fresh (they actually taste a little stale) like DoCo, so save time and money by heading there.
3. The staff isn’t very helpful. The most helpful girl is a girl with short dark hair and glasses…
4. Stuffing the donuts by cutting them in half makes them more stale. I was hoping for a donut, not a sandwich.
5. The one star I gave was for its proximity to Rook Coffee, which helps everything taste a little better. :)
Like I said, take a few minutes and head out to DoCo. It’s worth it. The last time I came to broad street I ended up feeding my donuts to the homeless cats under the seaside heights boardwalk…