Reginelli’s Pizzeria

One of the best pizzas I’ve had in a long while. Definitely recommend it (go for the Classic Combo) and plan on eating here again next time in New Orleans.

We had a great lunch here today! Good menu and drink selection and reasonable prices. Our group got a mix of sandwiches and salads and there was a lot of sharing. Everything was delicious. I personally got the Dream State sandwich, which was a great decision! We all agreed that the focaccia bread it came on was to die for. The wait staff was friendly too, and our food came quickly. Definitely adding this to my list of yummy, low maintenance NOLA eateries, and can’t wait to take advantage of their free delivery next time!

The cheese stix were amazing, the blend of cheeses was perfect! We got the Mediterranean and the Classic Combo pizzas, both delicious! Great friendly waitress as well. Great pit stop on Magazine Street if you are looking to get out of the heat and enjoy good food!

Reginelli’s is okay, but that’s not what I’m here to talk about.
The more I think about it, the more I realize that the Home Alone and Lethal Weapon franchises killed Joe Pesci’s career in the long term, although he probably made a hefty pay day on all of those films in the short term. I just miss angry tough guy Joe Pesci. Just a thought.

Simply amazing. They have awesome and fresh ingredients on their pizzas and the sampler trio is perfect to have for lunch for two people. My husband and I thoroughly enjoyed coming here for lunch twice this weekend! The staff were super friendly and we are definitely coming back for our next trip! I recommend the dressed hummus and the Mediterranean pizza with roasted garlic!

Little by little we are eating our way through all of the pizza joints in New Orleans. We chose Reginelli’s based on the recommendation of a few trusted friends, native to the area.
The recommendation was to choose Reginelli’s if we wanted thin crust pizza. Well, we wanted thin crust pizza so we picked up the phone and ordered takeout.
The pizza was ready pretty quickly and I’m happy to say that our friends were right. The thin crust pizza is out of this world. We appreciated the nontraditional options considering we really weren’t in the mood for simple pepperoni. There are plenty of artisanal choices and can I say arugula is really good on pizza! Who would have thunk it?
We will definitely be eating more Reginelli’s in the future!

3.5÷5 neighborly
so this is my neighborhood reginelli’s, and i’d say whenever i’ve needed it (examples: late, drunk), it has been there. and yeah, the menu is standard. but you know, i’m still always slightly pleased when that fancy hummus spread comes out, i mean come on, pita triangles!
so really, the thing that probably makes me a fan has been the service. it’s pretty genuine for what it is. it’s like, yeah, we know we’re a pizza joint, so you’re gonna get pizza joint service, but good pizza joint service. they’ve been chill when i’ve walked in with drinks from outside, have been accommodating when we’ve needed tables mashed together, knowledgeable and patient when our drunk butts are indecisive past 10pm, etc. etc. so for that alone, i’ll gladly consume their specific carbs. and i’m generally happy with the one that has the capers on it, the calzones are oddly satisfying, and the vegetarian sandwich is pretty tasty as well!
like a good neighbor, reginelli’s is probably within reasonable distance and will take your money in exchange for cheese and bread.

I just had the trio that was an appetizer that was amazing. Also I try there pizza it all really good.

Awesome place to hangout with friends.
Great Pizza with Great ingredients.
Excellent staff and service.
I will just highlight the pepperoni pizza.
The cheese was gooey. The pepperoni crispy. The Dough cook through and firm Great crust that had the great golden brown of bread. Sometimes burnt, but meh.

Yum! Yum! Yum!
For whatever reason I never felt the need to stop into Reginelli’s. Then for whatever reason I did, and I’ve had pizza twice in the past week (whoops).
Service is fast and friendly.
Pizzas are hand tossed. The Classic Combo is a definite favorite. I tried the Smokin’ Chicken. It was good, but it seemed to be lacking some pizzazz.
Definitely a new go to spot for pick up or eating in.

4.5 stars.
+pizza selection, dare I say «gourmet» (e.g., «gumbo pizza»)
+fresh ingredients
+friendly and helpful staff
+casual and laid-​back ambiance
+$ 2 pitchers of beer Mon and Tue (Abita Amber and another domestic brand, I don’t recall)
Had a great meal/​time. Glad we stopped by.
Don’t know if it’s «as good as it gets», but it’s sure damn close.

I don’t believe they use a pizza oven like Amici a block away but produce a better pizza in my opinion because they use fresher ingredients and are more generous with their portions. Friendly helpful staff.

I live in the neighborhood and regularly order the same salad from Reginelli’s. Tonight when my delivery order arrived I was sad to see that the salad was about half the size as normal. It was also missing one of the key ingredients, drunked breadcrumbs. Worst of all the prosciutto had been replaced by gross, chewy, inedible large chunks of ham (even my dog had trouble downing it).
I called and spoke to the manager. Instead of apologizing to a regular, she was defensive. She said that whether or not to use drunken breadcrumbs varies by the cook (nevermind what the menu says…). She also said that their supplier shorted them on sliced prosciutto, so instead they are serving a different type of «prosciutto» (which it’s clearly not) in its place. No, they never mentioned this substitution when the order was placed.
Whatever happened to putting customers first, regardless of what’s going on in the kitchen? Why the defensive tone? Instead of apologizing she said «well what we usually do is give you a credit on your next order.» Implying that I’m going to order again. Upon request she did refund my credit card instead, but made it seem like it was a big hassle. And no, she never asked if I wanted anything else instead.
No thanks Reginellis.

This was one night where we wanted to get out of the house and the night called for pizza. It’s a kid friendly environment so my 16 year old niece was able to accompany my husband and I. The service was fast and the waitress was friendly. When we arrived, the place was pretty empty but as it got later more people came in. There’s a bar inside which is great and the large windows allow you great street views. Parking was kind of hectic, so we parked in the nearby Walgreens’ parking lot. We started with the garlic knots which were delicious and then came the pizza… perfection!!! We’ll definitely be back.

Okay, I’m not trying to brag but I have eaten a lot of pizza in my life. I consider myself a bit of a pizza aficionado. A pizza enthusiast, if you will. All of that to say, you should trust me when I tell you Reginelli’s is some of the best pizza in the entire US of A.
Located in a really fun part of town, near the garden district, Reginelli’s is a stop I make sure to schedule in every time I visit NOLA. The pizzas are just so. good. And the super inexpensive pitchers of beer can’t be beat!
The servers are always incredible friendly and helpful, but still chill enough to never be overbearing.
If you’re gonna eat at Reginelli’s, get one of their specialty pizzas. Live it up. I recommend the Gumbo Pizza with my entire being. It’s one of the best things I’ve ever eaten in my entire life. Topped with loads of veggies, andouille sausage, crawfish, and the perfect blend of creole seasonings, this pizza is the stuff my dreams are made of. (Yes, I dream of pizza. You don’t? Psh.)
Grab a large pizza or two to split with friends and some pitchers of delicious local beer and you’re in for a really good night! Just, be wary of food comas. The post-​pizza nap is strong with this one.

Anacona Salad is great! Delivery driver could not find the house, even with the address on the building and & no flatware was provided.

Great pizza. Okay service. This is my second time here and I must say that I will only come back if I don’t want to be bothered. The servers only come to you when you summon them over, which isn’t good service in my opinion. I give it three stars because I like the food.

Great meal, very lovely waitress although I think she had the impression my friend and I were gay!
Great pizza and especially loved the Oreo beignets and caramel gelato!

My fiancé and I ordered a pepperoni pizza from Reginellis last night and it was just perfect! We will definitely be coming back to explore their menu a bit more but I can definitely say their pizza is freaking delicious and their prices are great too.

Though no fault of Reginelli’s, when I’m ordering from here, I’m not usually in the «high expectations» frame of mind. However, this is what I’ve come to trust when ordering pizza from this Magazine Street location:
+soft, pillowy thick crust.
+usual myriad of toppings to choose from.
+delivers to my favorite bar.
+tastes good sober (ish) or drunk.
+delivery time is reasonable, even when I’m drunk & hangry.