P & P’s Pizzeria New York Style

Best pizza in the Mentor/​Concord area. My family’s go to ordering spot. Owner is very personable will share stories of his life growing up in Italy

The calzone is the best item in the menu. The pizza is a 9 out of 10 and the wings are juicy with the perfect amount of seasoning.

This is NOT New York style pizza. This is average, at best, Cleveland style pizza. I’ve been dying for New York style pizza near mentor/​painesville. I’m still searching…

Great local pizza… good delivery and service.

I can’t say enough wonderful things about this mom and pop pizza shop. I have been going here for over 20 years and they never disappoint. They have the best NY style pizza around cooked by a genuine Italian. (What more could you ask for?!) Whether you want just a slice or a whole pie this is the place to go. Their salads are great too and perfect for sharing. They only use the best and freshest ingredients and it shows. This place is a tradition in my family.

Awesome pizza. Exactly my style. Thin New York style crust that’s both crunchy and chewy. Just like it should be. Perfect sauce, not over garlicy not over sweetened. Wish I lived closer to eat more often

Best pizza around here. New York style slices made by real Italians. Family owned and operated. Always Friendly staff. We always pick up or have it delivered. The inside is kind of small to dine in.

I have lived all over the Cleveland area and have had pizza almost everywhere. I can 100 percent say that this is HANDS DOWN the best pizza in Cleveland.
I started riding my bike there as a kid and fell in love. It became a once a week spot guaranteed all the way up until I moved to California. I even continued the tradition when I went to college, downtown. Classmates and I would take 30 min road trips to P and P’s once a week because we all unanimously agreed it was the best pizza in town and 100 percent worth the trip!
I live in Los Angeles now and P & P’s is always my 1^st stop upon coming back to Cleveland and my last food stop before flying back. That’s not an exaggeration. I will usually get P & P’s 3 — 4 times within a 10 – 14 day visit home. Not only do I feel strongly that it is the best pizza in Cleveland, but I have yet to have pizza anywhere in LA (or California) that tops it. I highly recommend you order by the pie rather than the slice.
If I had a magic lamp and a genie granted me three wishes, I’d spend all three of them on bringing P and P’s to Los Angeles.

Crust thin and just really chewy. Maybe that’s how NY style pizza is supposed to be but not for me. Dough ball in stomach for days.

Best New York style pizza in Cleveland the difference in the quality of the cheese makes it amazing don’t forget the cannoli!

Great pepperoni and white pizza, best in Mentor. If they would only use real sausage then I would have to move into the back room!

Meh. Not terrible, but exactly the kind of pizza you would expect from a low rent strip mall pizza joint. I would give it 2 ½ stars if that were possible.

Pp’s is authentic Italian with good old «down home» service! The menu is pretty typical so don’t expect the unusual… just good pizza & pasta dishes. It’s our goto place for delivery when we don’t want to cook or eat out.
Get your card punched for a freebie.

I live in California, so the only time I get P & P’s is when I’m home visiting the parental units. And you can be damned sure that when I’m here, we’re getting take out from this joint. Chewy thin crust, garlic-​y tomato sauce, more than generous cheese… and I’m drooling again. Mom-​unit swears by the white pizza. Wish I could find ‘za this good on the left coast.