Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop

Amazing pies! Got the mini apple pie while my mom got the mini hound dog pie. The apples were crisp but not too hard. Great mix of spices and sugar for the filling. Also, the crust was buttery and firm. Tried the i40 pie which was amazing as well. Went around 2pm so it was not very crowded and they still had all of the selections. Would recommend for sure! A fun place to go with friends or even kids. Something for everyone’s taste.

I finally had a pie here! So many people were hyping it up! One of the guest bought a pumpkin pie from here for friendsgiving and I initially didn’t know it was from here. I thought he made it and I was super impressed. The crust was a tad thicker and less flaky than I would have liked but the pumpkin filling was very satisfying. If you ever want a good pumpkin pie, this should be your to go joint. It’s not too liquidy nor hard nor sweet nor plain. It’s best served warm and with ice cream!

Expensive not so grand pies. It’s nothing special if you can buy a pie that’s just as good from Kroger. Seem to have a couple of regular territorial customers.

I called again last night since I hadn’t heard back from them all day. Shocker, the manager I had spoken with left for the day all ready. The lady on my phone took down my information again and said she would get with her manager to get this resolved but if I didn’t hear back from them to just call again. Finally, 24 hours later, the manager called me and said that she shipped the pie yesterday. Although, when I asked for a tracking number, she couldn’t provide me with one. So, I have no way of knowing if it was really sent out or not. She then blamed the website for the delay and didn’t even offer an apology. This has to be the worst experience I’ve ever had with any restaurant/​dessert place. Needless to say, from this bad experience I won’t bother going in the store and I will tell my friends to quit going as well.

I’m in love with the I-​40 pie… and the Deep South and the Buttermilk… I could go on forever. The I-​40 has pecans, coconut, and chocolate chips and it’s delicious. They have regular sized pies and smaller personal pies. I think it makes more sense to get the 4 mini pies that way you can share! I think its about $ 16 for the mini pies and they are enough for one person, extremely rich and tasty. We usually get some before a family get together and they are a hit!

get the cloud nine! one of the best desserts ive had. its their form of a blizzard you get a full pie mixed into ice cream. the ice cream and pie is incredible, I went with the peanut butter pie with chocolate ice cream, its huge and sooo good!

5 stars for the peanut butter pie and the friendly service. Unbelievable flavors that dance across the palate. Just YUMMY!!!

I love Pie.
We had a bit of a mixed experience, but I’ll write part of it off to the fact that we went there late in the day before they were ready to close. The nature of pie means we should expect the crust to have become a little soggy and some of the fillings to settle a little. That’s on us. My wife got a little chocolate pie and was disappointed because it wasn’t sweet at all. I’ve had chocolate pies both ways (sweet and not-​so-​much) and like both, but I can see why she’d expect it a little sweeter. I had coconut cream pie, and it was amazing. Exactly what I was hoping for.
Seriously, though. Don’t go to a pie place on Pi Day and expect much. You’re one of hundreds of people who think they can just get whatever they want, and everyone wants something different. Just be thankful it even exists or make your own damn pie. I liked this place enough that I’ll likely go here again. It’s definitely worth the trip.

Man these were all good pies!!! I went and got my hair cut at Tease and was wondering about the tiny little pie shop I always pass by… Then I was told about their 4 for $ 16 mini pie box deal! I stopped in around 5:30p. There so many many pies available!!! I got an I-​40 — OMG this was the best!!!; Granny’s Apple crumble — really great topping!; Coconut meringue — very good; and chocolate meringue — my least favorite but… having a favorite among these amazing mini pies is like having one, single favorite jewel in Scrooge McDuck’s massive treasure vault… Warning though… if you & your loved one (s) have zero self-control…hide 3 of the 4 mini pies…

Fiancé and I went here tonight. Got a big chocolate meringue pie and a small strawberry pie. Strawberry pie was amazing. The strawberry one was for me. So good. You can tell they used actual strawberry. Not too sweet. Chocolate pie was good. A little to sweet for my taste, but the fiancé liked it. Will go back!

Pie is delicious on any day of the week, but it tastes even better when you eat it on National Pi Day. We arrived to the shop around 1pm and this little, tiny pie shop was packed to the gills. The ladies in the shop kept up with the crowd and the sweet lady at the register met us with smiles. She was prepared with a cheat sheet slip of paper and let me rattle off the first 15 digits of pi in exchange for a FREE small pie. In the honor of the shop’s name, I decided to try a buttermilk pie. While waiting for my pie, I was able to see the girls in the kitchen working quickly to assemble rows of little pies to keep up with the holiday crowd.
We pulled up one of the few stools in the window and settled in to eat our pies. I loved the little wooden forks! First bite: still warm from the oven! It was heavenly — so sweet and rich. The crust was the perfect kinda flaky! I don’t know how to describe a buttermilk pie, but I will tell you that I get why they made it their namesake! And while this was heavenly, I have been in many other times and have never had a bad pie. I usually get one of their fruity offerings, but would highly recommend any of their specials!
This is a great place to pick up dessert for a special occasion, whether a small pie or a regular size pie. I have always had good service here. One of these days, I’ll have to branch out and try their biscuits. If I can get past their pies, that it.
Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop closes early and given the line out the door on Pi day, it’s no wonder they ran out of pie shortly before closing. If anyone had a bad experience here, I’d urge them to give it another shot. The delicious pies deserve it.

Pie was just ok.

We planned to go to this pie shop for a Unilocal event on Pi day. First with the good: Their pie crust is flaky and delicious, the place is quaint and cute and the situation is good, close to our neighborhood.
Now… The customer service was not, I repeat NOT friendly. Ok, it’s Pi day and maybe they are overwhelmed… Yet they did not offer plates, silverware or even if we wanted to get something to drink, which is the best source of profit for a business. They did not make the most of their one holiday a year by putting up any decorations or even saying «Happy Pi Day!» or anything. I had to take three mugs they have on display with the letters «P», «I», and ««E» and rearrange them to make a «P» «I» to go with the festivities… To top it all off, and this is the saddest for the owners of this business, they ran out of pie by 6 pm which probably meant a huge loss of income for such a small business, They had to turn away a LOT of people while we were there eating our pies.
Oh, the only pies they had left, which was the only choice we had, were «Meh»… Bottom line: they wasted the biggest sales day, and Meh pies.

PI DAY and they only have some big pies left… not many. only the Chess, I-​40 and pecan pie. Thats it. $ 26.00 Otherwise, chocolate merigue, smore’s a 45 minute wait… hmmmmm. What’s wrong here.
Very tiny place. You would think it being «PI» day they would have LOTS of PIE… having to be prepared. One lady in here asked the lady if she knew it was PI Day, she said NO!!! WHAT!!!
With the reviews, we are gonna pass… the ladies in the back are trying to figure out how to make the merigue. ALOT of people do not look happy especially after hearing that lady say NO. ALOT of people are walking out.
Would not recommend. Very unprepared and very unknowledgable.
Merigue shouldn’t take 45 minutes… after that round she said they are done for the day!!! Wow.

A little bitty establishment located a few miles west of downtown. They make some tasty pies in individual or full size portions. A point and pick process of ordering your selection, because all the finished product is displayed for sale.
I had a individual cinnamon sugar topped appel pie of goodness and coffee. The pie was just about prefect with a crispy sugary topped crust, good apple to gooey cinnamon filling ratio inside, and their signature soft and flaky shortbread pie shell crust.
The coffee is local roasted… it was good, not outstanding, but good for pie.
The problem is the price. Just seemed a bit steep for the quantity despite the quality. 4 individual pies and 2 coffees…$ 21 and some change.

I’m not sure why everyone keeps referencing grandma’s pies. Did they do some type of advertisement suggesting that they had traditional pies? When I went I got three of the individual little pies, which I think is a cute idea.
They were good. Not the most amazing thing I’ve ever eaten, but a good pie at a decent price; not sure what more you can ask for.

My husband and I are from Chicago, so we are pretty finicky when it comes to our food. We went to Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop and we took away a couple of the small pies. We were very impressed that the apple pie was so chock-​full of delicious big apples in such a little pie. The taste was very home made apple pie! We also took away a chocolate meringue pie which was equally delicious. Just the right amount of very chocolatey taste without being overwhelming. I hope we will be able to visit this store again sometime if we return to this area.

Delicious pie. Friendly people. This will become a ritual for us. I can personally vouch for the peanut butter and the key lime… And my wife loved the peach. So glad they opened up! Don’t believe the frozen pie comments… This stuff is crazy good!

Buttermilk Sky Pie shop is not your grandma’s or even mother’s pie. Very average, just a step about freezer pies at Krogers.

I was SO excited to finally try out this place, and I was extremely disappointed when I did. Here’s why:
1. Upon walking in, it smelled… funky, to say the least. The way I described it to my sister as we were walking out was «like dogs» but I don’t know if thats entirely accurate. But one thing’s for sure it did not smell like yummy pies, it didn’t even smell CLEAN. It just smelt weird.
2. I thought, that for the prices and for all the hype I’ve seen on Facebook, these pies were going to be GOOD. Not only were the pies below average, so were the thumbprint cookies that I bought too. Thankfully I only bought a few instead of the fabulous deal of 12 for $ 10! Give me a break! They’re MAYBE worth 10/​$ 1, although if I were going to buy cookies I’d most likely opt to use that dollar to buy a couple of cookies from the Publix bakery.
3. The pies. I got the 4 inch buttermilk pie and my sister got the 4 inch Elvis pie.
The Elvis pie was missing an ingredient, bananas, the cashier informed us because they ran out… which I thought was weird because there’s a target 10 minutes away that sells bananas for 20 cents a pop. Sounds like bad business to me to completely leave out an ingredient just because there aren’t any in the building.
The cashier put the elvis pie in a cute little box and my buttermilk pie in a paper bag. Why I got the short end of the deal I don’t know, but I did. By the time I got my pie home, which was maybe 20 minutes later, the paper bag that my pie was in had grease stains soaking through. Talk about disturbing…
It was a lackluster experience overall. But to be fair, I will say: their packaging, and marketing are ADORABLE. Everything down to the sign outside and the décor inside the shop is to die for! Everything, that is, except for the food.