Wow, this restaurant is terrific. We went on a Wednesday night for the Chicken Specials. For $ 12.95 you get soup or a salad, entrée(8 different ones to choose from) and dessert(Cheesecake or zeppolis). Food was delicious and the service spot on. Bring your appetite and expect to bring home leftovers. We will be coming back again. P. S. Did I mention how good the breadsticks are? Yummy!!!
Frankie F.
Tu valoración: 5 Central Islip, NY
My family and I love this Italian restaurant, great food, big portions, and the owner is very friendly, we eat there or order out there at least once a week.
Jeannine W.
Tu valoración: 5 Islip Terrace, NY
Mary’s service and food are excellent. I have so many favorites I can’t list them all. No matter what you order you won’t be disappointed. Dine in, pick up or delivery are all great. And the weekday specials are a good deal.
Samuel R.
Tu valoración: 5 Central Islip, NY
I love this place. I have been coming here since it was a small shop. Over 15 years… Just love it.
Michael O.
Tu valoración: 2 Bay Shore, NY
I guess I’m in the minority here but I found the service horrible. I was there tonight for the seafood specials and while the food was good, the service was really poor. First they forget the salads, then they never come back to the table to fill the water glasses which were empty and after the main course was served they never mentioned we get free dessert. I had to ask for it. I had to track my server down to get my bill. There was not an adult in site to even complain to. Usually on the way out of any decent place someone will ask«how was everything»? I have to say they will not be seeing me anytime soon.
Robert F.
Tu valoración: 4 East Islip, NY
Best meatball parm anywhere around this area. The meatballs are not some hard rubber balls, they are moist and flavored well. Not all bread crumbs. Oh and they serve in in the attached container so it’s not some blob of sauce, cheese and meat like others that wrap up a hot hero in wax paper and tin foil. And by the time you get it home its mush.
Joe D.
Tu valoración: 3 Holbrook, NY
This review is solely for what they call Chicken night. Every Wednesday for around $ 13.95, dine in and you get a soup or salad, chicken entrée(or two eggplant offerings) and dessert. You really cant beat this deal. The list of entrees to choose from is pretty large. The portions are more then you would expect and all dishes come served over pasta. Id say the food was 3 – 3.5 stars. Service was on point and all of the staff was very friendly. Definitely worth checking out for Chicken night(weds) or Pasta night(mon/tues).
Donna G.
Tu valoración: 3 Stony Brook, NY
My family comes here all the time whenever we are in the mood for pizza.(Side note: Their squash soup is the bomb! But unfortunately, they are only served in the fall.) Their pizzas are also great depending on which flavor you order. I always stick with the good ol’ cheese pizza because it goes great with red wine. Their bread is also made fresh. Their lobster ravioli are also a steal but their pasta could be better.
Stefanie L.
Tu valoración: 1 Deer Park, NY
Food is mediocre at best. They do not wash their lettuce for salads and they give you the bitter yellowish-green lettuce. They do not take pride in all of their food. 2⁄10 times I’ve eaten there the food was okay. I generally always have a tummy ache after I’ve consumed their food too. I recommend finding another place to eat.
Frank N.
Tu valoración: 5 Meriden, CT
Holy pizza joints! This place has every type of topping you can imagine! All delicious although I just went with the pain slices. Get here early for lunch it gets crowded!
Missy K.
Tu valoración: 5 St. James, NY
Mary’s is, was and will always be the best place to eat for Pizza or Pasta nights! We were regulars for years… delivery especially! Timely and HOT… the fried artichoke hearts with lemon sauce are still a huge fav(we moved and miss them) and the Crispino Pizza is sorely missed. The dine in pasta or seafood nights were delicious… the only problem is trying to decide which favorite to order! The people who work there are among the nicest most professional… and we never had a meal we didn’t love. clean, well made food served or delivered by nice people. at a price we could afford! What better recommendation could you ask for. I wish they would open in Smithtown or St James so we could go on enjoying their food!!!
Maureen L.
Tu valoración: 4 East Islip, NY
Amazing marinara sauce & amazing ala vodka sauce. Their regular pizza is great– love the sesame seed crust. My boyfriend loves their white pizza. Had the eggplant Rolla tiniest to tonight, it was great but I recommend asking for it with melted cheese on it. Pretty fast delivery.
Lily C.
Tu valoración: 5 Islip, NY
I guess you could say we’re regulars now. Last night we went to Mary’s and had exemplary service by our waiter, Chris. The hostess put us in a far table, away from the rest of the diners. It seemed as if we might have been forgotten back there and sure enough, we were. However, when Chris learned we were there, he quickly made up for the oversight. The rest of the dining experience was delicious as usual but Chris made a point to check in on us frequently. It’s hard for me to order anything besides the Chicken Parm here because it is always cooked perfectly, the portion size is ginormous and the sauce is perfect. We love Mary’s even though there are great places by us. And thanks Chris for the awesome service. It means a lot.
Hugo H.
Tu valoración: 4 East Islip, NY
This place has come a long way since I was 1st introduced in 2000. The food is amazing, delivery service is available and comes in a decent timeframe. Prices on the food could be a little lower. I will say that all of the Heroes are a little small for the price. I would estimate that they measure approximately 6 – 8 inches and for the price it’s a bit disappointing. Th atmosphere inside the restaurant is beautiful and warming. Overall it’s a beautiful place with fair prices.
Chelsea C.
Tu valoración: 3 Islip Terrace, NY
Specialty slices are good but each time we have ordered a regular or Sicilian pie, they have little cheese and the crust was taking over half of the pie. They are quick with a replacement pie but wish it wasn’t needed in the first place.
Miss Y.
Tu valoración: 4 East Islip, NY
YESYESYES!!! Many specialty slices to choose from — I am tired of regular pizza, seriously I live in New York everyone thinks they make good slices around here but specialty slices are where it’s at!(The flavor of the crust could use a bit of work, the dough just isn’t quite there yet which is why only 4 stars) Chicken francaise slice– YES. Spicy BBQ slice — ABSOLUTELY, they also have a restaurant area where they have specialty nights like pasta night or chicken night. I will get back to all of you when that happens, but for now a quick stop lunch spot and they have a bar! The staff is super nice I picked food up once and they kept apologizing that it was taking forever — honestly guy, no worries, please stop apologizing lol. But hey at least they let you know that they know you’re still there. If you’re ever there when they have the Spinach and Artichoke balls — stop and order two. Seriously I am OBSESSED with them. Ridiculously tasty.
Kimaura T.
Tu valoración: 5 Central Islip, NY
I have been coming here for about 2 years, since i moved to the area. Each and every time i come here the staff is wonderful, the delivery service is quick and easy and the food is wonderful!
Rodney L.
Tu valoración: 4 Central Islip, NY
The food is always good. Just love the pizza. Best in the area and the service is great too. A must in the area.
David M.
Tu valoración: 3 Merrick, NY
Stopped into this outfit of this popular Pizza Chain. Much like the other locations, they offer a wide variety of specialty slices and each is clearly labeled. I had one chicken parm slice and one grandma slice. Both were acceptable but by no means spectacular. I like the décor of this location and the big booths make for a comfortable eating environment. Lots of employees running around but not much seems to be getting done. Wasn’t that busy during my visit. Add a star if your into all those wild specialty slices.
Rachel A.
Tu valoración: 3 Central Islip, NY
Watched Mary’s evolve from a whole in the walk to taking up a quarter of the space in the islip terrace shopping center. Hate to say the quality has really fell off. Ordered takeout the other night and it was more like linguini in soup than linguini in white clam sauce. Used to be my favorite. Service fell off too. Got to the counter and the cashier is busy texting and gives me the wrong change. I say«thank you» and he doesn’t even look up to say«you’re welcome.»