Flyer’s Pizza & Subs

Great pizza. This has been my go to pizza for over three years now. Pizza is always hot and delivery is always ahead of scheduled time.

Loved the pizza and chef salad. I also ordered an Italian Sub, it was tasty but it had more bread than meat and not enough dressing. I will most definitely come back to this location, the service was great and they were very friendly…

Very good pizza ! Old world pepperoni is awesome! And they have a drive thru! Subs are outstanding as well, very friendly service, they recently added a dining room section!

Great pizza (crust is yummy and love the sauce as well), great Italian sub, quick service and drive through window is great!

The sauce!
The subs!
The place is a winner…
Dine in and enjoy the pizza right out of the oven.
You will not be disappointed…

I have tried it today for the first time and was very pleased with the food quality. They have a lunch menu everyday including Sunday. The Italian sub was very well made, full, stuffed, and tasty. I almost did not catch that choc cookie they put in my lunch togo box. Fresh, chewy, and definitely a yummy treat. The fries were waffle style, fresh and hot. Haven’t tried the pizza yet but I’m already a fan of their subs!

Lived in hilliard for 9 years and finally gave this place a try. It’s now one of our favorite pizza places and we wish we would have tried it sooner. They use tons of toppings and the pepperoni is very good. They also use some kind of spices on the pizza and in the sauce that give it great flavor. Would highly recommend.

By far my favorite pizza in Columbus! I love the thin, crispy crust and the sweet pizza sauce. I’m partial to the sausage pizza with extra sauce… we order this almost once a week. The drive-​thru is very convenient for picking up orders, and my dogs love the treats they get if they are in the car with me.
While we don’t get appetizers often, my husband loves the «pump cheese» on the bacon cheese fries. The boneless wings are a little too greasy for me, but also a favorite of my husband’s.

We ordered 2 Nightmare sandwiches and a sampler of 3 appetizers for delivery. Everything arrived as promised in a reasonable amount of time. The sandwiches were 12 inches and loaded with meat and veggies. The sandwiches lacked some kind of tasty sauce to make them really stand out. The appetizers were hot and fresh. We ordered waffle fries, mozz sticks and pizza bombs. I especially liked the pizza bombs.

I’ve ordered from flyer’s quite a few times, and they have always been kind when ordering over the phone. Their food has always been delicious.
This evening I had food delivered and the order wasn’t exactly as I asked. I asked for the homemade chips, but they delivered lay’s chips instead. Not a deal breaker. However, about an hour after the delivery, there was a knock at the door, and they delivered the homemade chips! This means a lot to me since the weather is terrible as well as the roads.

I love flyers pizza! This has been one of my favorites for the last 15 years. The pizza sauce is so good! I also love the Italian sub and the garlic bread. Great service always too!

To the people with negative reviews– I truly have to question if you really had this pizza. We have tried all crusts, topping combos and have yet to be disappointed.
The best part is the constant reward they give returning customers– since maybe our third order we’ve received some sort of discount.
I consider myself a pizza snob (hate the big chains) and this is our go to place

My least favorite pizza in Columbus so far. The crust was bland the cheese was bland the sauce was bland… get the picture? The old world pepperonis were small and cute and tasted good. I called to pick up a pizza… the girl taking my order had to get all my info… name, phone number, address… I wouldn’t have minded as much if I didn’t have to repeat everything and then spell it for her… come on its for pick up!

Flyer’s is hands down one of my favorite ‘go-​to’ pizza places around Hilliard. The sweet sauce gives it just enough of a different taste to lure you away from the big chain pizzas, and the ingredients are tasty tasty. As far as people commenting on the price… maybe I have a skewed sense of pricey pizza after experiencing Dewey’s in Grandview, but their pricing and sizes don’t seem ridiculous at all in my books for the quality pizza you receive. My husband and I usually opt for make your own with pepperoni and mushroom. We have never eaten in the restaurant, so I can’t speak to that experience.
Only downside for us is their delivery areas do seem a bit skewed — we live closer to the Hilliard location (so that’s our standard pick-​up location), but whenever we order delivery we have to call the Galloway location. Inconvenience when it’s saved in your phone… but a small price to pay for Flyer’s goodness, and they’ve never been late on delivery and we don’t notice a taste difference between locations. If you live in the area, watch the coupons and they usually have pretty good ones to stock up on too!

I’ve eaten pizza at a TON of places across the state, as part of my former job I kind of had to.
The few pizzas I’ve had there were decent at the least. The chicken garlic pizza was awesome! It’s clear that they care about quality ingredients, and that matters a lot. However, this makes their price for serving said ingredients that much higher.
The above mentioned sampling of the pizza were from an employee; I never had to buy a pizza myself.
One day I had a craving for a chicken garlic pizza. I went online to order it, and I was floored by the price ($ 17.99 for a large) I was going to pick it up and it was too much to be worth it; imagine a delivery fee added plus a tip!
They choose to use odd numbered sizes too 11″ 13″ 15″ (their pizzas are «bigger» but cost way more per inch)
Bottom line: this company chooses to buck the system in terms of standard pizza sizing, delivery charging, and even the way the send drivers to your house. Ask them about how they choose which driver takes your order to you. If they’re honest about it, you will be very surprised.
The product is good, sometimes great, but almost never worth the price. I’ll buy a $ 50 steak, but it had better be worth it.

I liked the chicken something or other pizza even tho it is probably the most expensive pizza in Columbus & had ordered it several times for delivery. I called once again about a year ago & was told they’ve «never delivered to that location» & had to actually argue with the guy about them having always delivered to us! Needless to say we didn’t get pizza that night. I’m huge on customer service & have never been back.

Their pizza is OK, it’s not the best by any means. The sauce is sweet not to my liking. I have only been in this bar once and it’s not that big of a deal. A typical WEST side bar. Back to the pizza, besides the sauce pizza is OK. I also got the boneless hot wings and they were more like mild. With a large pepp pizza with a 10ct. of wings it cost a little of $ 22.00, and to me that was WAY over priced. And the wings were small as hell. I’m not going out of my way to eat their again.

Good pizza and great sub in their nightmare sub. But eventhough its a good pizza the pricing kills it… Its a decent pizza for a huge price.

Flyer’s is my favorite Columbus pizza. There’s something about their thin crust, sweet pizza sauce, and flakes of dried oregano that makes the planets align. I always look forward to Friday night pizza, our personal tradition, because I know I’ll be treat to a country garden pizza with broccoli, mushrooms, green peppers, diced tomatoes, onions, and extra cheese or my all-​time Flyer’s favorite, the plain Jane mushroom.
Flyer’s cuts their pizza into those small, rectangular slices, which can be a bad thing because you don’t realize how many pieces you’ve eaten until you’re staring at an empty box.
We’re lucky to have a location pretty close to home. But sometimes we just don’t feel like driving over to get the pizza. Con: they add a delivery charge on top of their already semi-​expensive rate ($ 13 for a 15″), then there’s always the tip. Delivery time is average. They’re almost never late.
Flyer’s has a plethora of specialty pizzas like The Bomber (provolone, pepperoni, sausage, ham, salami, mushrooms, onions, and green peppers), Chicken Garlic Supreme (garlic white sauce topped with provolone, cheddar, Parmesan, marinated chicken strips, diced tomatoes, and red onions), The Popeye (spinach, mushrooms, diced tomatoes, provolone, Parmesan, and red onion on whole wheat dough), and their best seller Old World Pepperoni, which guarantees at least 120 spicy pepperonis on the large 15″ pizza.
The specialty pizzas are slight more expensive than the build-​your-​owns. If you’re planning on just getting a few toppings, here’s the list: classic pepperoni, 95% fat free ham, special recipe Italian sausage, green peppers, Dole pineapple, black olive, broccoli, diced tomatoes, hot banana peppers, jalapeño peppers, diced yellow onions, mushrooms, Ezzo salami, Sugardale bacon, marinated chicken strips, green olives, ground beef, fresh spinach, and, of course, anchovies.
Flyer’s also makes starters (including wings), salads, sandwiches, subs, breads, and desserts. Try their always soft chocolate chip cookies.