Ange’s Pizza

We’ve ordered from here on a few occasions and the pizza is always good. We did the stuffed deep dish one night, and after waiting over an hour, which is to be expected given the cook time, the center was cold. Kind of a bummer.

Get the deep dish! It was amazing. Ive only had it once but it was super good. 23 ounces of cheese! I couldn’t even finish!

This is hands down the best deep dish pizza in Columbus, Ohio!!! We love this place! We have tried several items here, but their deep dish pizza is the best! Highly recommend it!

Agnes Pizza Hilliard has the best pizza in town we ordered a large pepperoni pizza that was outstanding the sauce was slightly sweet it was absolutely delicious and on top of the excellent food the staff is friendly and helpful. Will definitely be going back soon.

My fiancée and I come to Columbus from time to time as an exchange point for him and his son.
Tonight, I decided that I wanted to get some actual good food in Ohio, for once, since all it seems there is around here are fast food joints and buffets. Most of which are truly sub-​par and when edible, give me food poisoning.
Anyways, I used Unilocal to find a good non-​chainish restaurant around our hotel (the Holiday Inn off of Maxwell Place) and came up with this place, a mile and a half, that delivered. So we used the website to decide what we wanted and… awesome! Found out that we could order our food right there online. There were cannoli’s, cool looking pizzas, and salads. We ordered a few and some wings to boot and submitted our order.
We ordered at 7:19 PM. At 8:37, I decided to call the number on our order confirmation page and was directed to the location in Whitehall, 17 miles away. The person that answered me asked for the address, I gave it to him, and he told me that he didn’t see the order there, so it «must be on the road to» us, and to give it another five minutes or so.
I waited another twenty, and then called back again. This time, my fiancée handled the call, and was told that they had found the order in the online system and OH! don’t deliver to our location.
I’m RIPPING pissed. First of all, there is a hold on my card from this dump for $ 52.50, which we have been told will release since you know, they blatantly failed to meet the «service» they should have provided, which I’m not 100% sure I believe since you know… THEY CAN’T MEET THEIR PROMISES. Secondly, because I was really friggen excited to try their food.
So, in short… Ange’s! Not sure how they do stuff out here in Ohio, but here are some pointers on your CRAP website:
1) If someone submits a request to the incorrect location, FARM IT TO THE CORRECT ONE.
2) You obviously have the email address and phone number that I ENTERED ONLINE to submit my friggen order, how about some common courtesy and CALLING OR EMAILING someone when you can’t fulfill an order.
3) Better yet… why don’t you just have your website know what addresses you don’t deliver to, so there is no miscommunication?
Ohio…in a state with this many «restaurants» and the eighth highest obesity rate in the US, you’d think you’d be able to get a decent meal! Can’t wait to get back home.

These hard working folks were open Christmas night. Service and food both great.

I’m updating my review and giving Anges five stars after trying their deep dish pizza. Their Chicago style pizza takes an hour to bake but it’s worth the weight! It’s absolutely delicious! The pizza is loaded with cheese and toppings and weighs over 3 pounds. I love their standard pizza as well, but the Chicago style pie really is something special!

Ordered my pizza, it was delivered on-​time. The lady that brought it was very friendly. The pizza looked great, only thing I wished was for the sauce to be a little spicier rather than sweet and the crust to have a bit more flavor. But otherwise, very affordable, they run great specials & good customer service!

ange’s chicago stuffed pizza… you da real MVP

First time that the wife and I ate here, it’s a nice little pizza place. The bread sticks was amazing and pizza was really good. The prices were also very, very reasonable. The only gripe about the place is that it didn’t have big enough tables. But don’t let that keep you from coming in ordering some really good pizza. The wife and I will definitely be back. The staff was great as well, very fast and friendly service.

Solid pizzas with great, hand cut toppings. This place is definitely one of the better ones in the Hilliard area.

Anges Pizza is the best! Great crust, fresh toppings and nice staff! They also make a delicious Steak Sub. Try them today, you won’t be disappointed!

We really enjoy Ange’s and find them to be very consistent. We usually order carry out from inside and have a drink down the plaza. The staff has always been very friendly. We like our pizza well done and they are one of the few places that actually do so when you request. Delicious, reliable, and can always find a coupon to make the price reasonable.

Pizza is awesome they make there own crust good price only been to the 1 in Hilliard so don’t know if the other locations are as good but the 1 in Hilliard is really good. My favorite pizza In Hilliard and 1 of my favs period.

From the beginning to the end, a very pleasurable experience. I called to place a delivery order and was greeted by a very friendly voice on the other end. My order came within the time promised and the delivery guy was very nice. The pizza was delicious (thin crust, fresh ingredients). I am definitely ordering from them again soon!

We order from Ange’s almost once a week. There is times that the top will be nice and brown and the bottom will seem under cooked. We usually ask for well done when ordering. But the buttery crust flavor with the sauce and cheese is just pure happiness!!!

I must agree with the other reviewer in that pizza is a very personal topic. For me this place knocked it out of the park. The prices are very fair (2 topping large for 12 bucks) and the pizza tasted… well…like pizza should taste!
The pepperonis are a little greasy but they have great flavor. The ham was the proper thickness for a pizza (not too thin a la donatos and not too thick a la papa johns). The mozzarella cheese used on the pizza tastes like what I would use on my own pizzas at home not like the weird salty mess they use on most nationwide chain pizzas. Unlike the other reviewer my pizza’s crust was fantastic. Though it was ¹⁄₈ of an inch thick there was plenty of flavor from it.
Essentially all I can really say is GO HERE! Support independent pizza chains who keep flavor and quality alive in a world where the contents of a pizza are so questionable that chains must prove in advertisment that their ingredients are real…

I’ll start out by saying PIZZA is definitely a subjective topic — some like it thick, some thin — some like chunky tomato, others smooth — the only consensus comes from the use of fresh toppings. And Columbus certainly is a hodgepodge of pizza places — every different kind (except maybe New York style) without any one type claiming a market lead or mandate on «the» pizza…
So here’s my review — I just didn’t like it. The crust was so thin, it could not hold the toppings when I tried to hold the piece. The crust was soggy and barely an eighth of an inch tall — this would make Donato’s standard pie a thick crust pizza. The crust was browned all over and under — but had no substance. And no taste.
There was little sauce — luckily or you wouldn’t be a mess eating the pieces. The sauce had little taste. The cheese was smooth and did not resemble any mozzarella or provolone that I’ve ever used or eaten. It was pretty sparse as well. There was a good portion of pepperoni — it was greasy, but acceptable. The onion and banana peppers were fresh, but sparse as well.
SO $ 9.20 for a pie that I wasn’t crazy about — but I am not a thin crust person. And you never know until you try it.