Chatham Tap Restaurant & Pub

While this might be considered poor form, I’m a huge fan of the downtown location and would rate it higher than 3 stars. However, we’re talking about this location. The service is typically very good but can get a tad dodgy when a big match (LFC v Utd, Chelsea v Utd, etc.) is happening, but that’s to be expected at a football pub. The atmosphere is great on match days, but parents/​non-​soccer fans be warned, it can get loud when it’s a derby day or if a big match is being played. This is the only pub in metro Indy that I’ve found that does their fish and chips with three key elements: use of cod tenderloins and providing HP sauce and malt vinegar as condiments. Also, I love the fact they open early on match days for a wide variety of breakfast items. Now, for the basis of my rating.. . Guinness is basically a food group to me. I’ve had really good pours of Guinness at Chatham and really sub-​par pours. I’m talking like 1 ½″ of head on the pint. Also, this is Fishers. Are we really in $ 6 pint territory? I know the cost of a Guinness barrel and this seems a bit aggressive for the ‘burbs. Nonetheless, as a fan of the BPL, you’ll find me at Chatham as often as I’m able to go.

Best thing on the menu are the wings. There is a great beer selection. The atmosphere is nice and no pressure from the staff to pack up and leave. You can enjoy a meal with some beers and carry a conversation.

With all the good reviews I guess we came on a bad night. Sat at the bar and with the bar servers right in front of us still had to ask to be served after almost 10 minutes. The attitude was bad and a real turn off. Had our drinks and decided not to eat because we didn’t want to put up with it. May try it again since the reviews seem ok but we’ll see.

Best ginger beer around. The fish and chips were okay, but my husband and I loved our spinach artichoke dip!

I’m a regular here. The service is equally good as the beer selection and food. Service is solid in the dining area and top notch at the bar. They serve brunch on the weekend. The biscuits and gravy, and the breakfast burrito are good. My other favs are the spicy steak salad, Evaristo pizza (ask for a side of pico and add siracha), grilled fish sandwich, and BBQ beef. They serve the BBQ beef and grilled fish on a Parisian bread that is crazy good.

I’ve always enjoyed this spot as a bar, but haven’t had many meals here.
I took a client to lunch there yesterday. We arrived at peak lunch time, 12:30, and the restaurant was pretty slow. This worked fine for us. We were seated right away and had a perfectly attentive waitress. Service was awesome for a working lunch. We never went without but there weren’t a ton of interruptions.
I got one of their specials, the bacon turkey burger and fries. The burger was good sized for a lunch portion. After eating it, I was full but not stuffed. The burger itself was well seasoned. The turkey was light but hearty enough. The bacon was mostly good but part of it was not as crispy as I like it. It comes with all the fixings. I got fries as my side. They were perfectly cooked. Very crispy outside but not burnt. They were salty with a lot of flavor. I just wish there was a little more of them.
It was a great lunch all around.

Loved this place! As always, Unilocal gave us a great suggestion. Hummus is awesome, as is the reuben and fish and chips. I really want to try the steak and egg sandwich next time — looks amazing!

good drinks good food good prices.
YES you should get the crab cake special sandwich. easily one of the best crab cakes I’ve had in a long time.
our waiter was great. and of course we were with freak company so that rocked too.
we had some fries and a meat and cheese board for an appetizer which was awesome. everyone else had burgers and they all seemed really happy. yum. A+

Chatham Tap is a nice, relaxed pub-​style bar in a nicer strip mall in Fishers. For my meeting here, our group only had beer, so I can’t remark on the food. Our server was attentive and friendly. I’m told they have the best selection of British beers you’ll find in this area.

Chatham’s is an excellent establishment for you to try.
* Food selection — Menu includes both healthy selections and traditional bar food. However, each item has a delicious spin and both are inventive and tasty.
* Service — Excellent. Even during busy times the staff is efficient and fast. Sit at the bar and you will be treated like a regular if it’s your 1^st or 100^th time
* Restaurant — Chatham’s offers a variety of experiences. The outside offers shade and is sheltered by shrubs enough to feel like you aren’t sitting directly on 116^th. Inside has set-​off tables and sectioned off rooms. The layout offers a wide variety of nooks and crannies. The architecture and décor provides a cozy neighborhood atmosphere.
You will not be disappointed with the variety of brews both on tap and bottled. The staff is very knowledgeable on all spirits and will offer excellent recommendation.
I highly recommend Chatham’s for a quick bite, a leisurely lunch or dinner, a drink after work or a late night snack. Great place to watch football of either the USA or European variety.

The nachos were the surprise of this meal. We ordered it as an appetizer, and I was floored by the overall quality and originality. The chips had a baked taste, with lots of fresh cut jalapeño and pico. My burger was nicely prepared, and it was very thick. Almost a little too thick, actually, but who’s complaining. Service was fast and friendly.

This is a good 2^nd edition of the Mass Ave Chatham Tap. Also, the service is a lot faster and friendlier.
Fish and chips here are as good as the Mass Ave location and that’s no small feat.
The interior décor really makes you forget that you’re in suburban Fishers. Very pub-​by.

The same delicious menu as the downtown Indy location, but larger, with better service, and kid-​friendly!!!
Even on Friday nights, they have drink specials. And their fish and chips is pretty hard to beat.

Walked into the bar to grab a beer at 10:30. Their door says they close at 1. A lot of the chairs were up but there were enough people at the bar. I asked if they were closed and the bartender replied «Kinda.»
Kinda? Talk about customer service.

Let me start by saying, I’m in LOVE with the Mass Ave Chatham, so forgive me if I am a bit critical of this locale.
I went here on a lunch date on a Tuesday afternoon, and sat at the bar. Our server was nice, but forgot to bring our waters out to us, and then passed us off to another bartender… but forgot to tell the bartender that he was going to be helping us. I usually go for the tenderloin but I tried something different this time (grilled chicken sandwich… forget official name!) and I was just lukewarm about it. I was hoping that this location would have the same cool/​European soccer-​y vibe as the downtown location, and I’m sad to report that this is more of what I expected from your typical sports bar.
I’m sure I’ll be back for more lunch eats, but I hope that they can get in on what makes the Mass Ave location so awesome!

This place is normally 4 stars but when they mess up your first drink, your dinner, and then you get an extremely flat beer from the tap and the bartender in the schmedium shirt with the beard proceeds to say that its supposed to taste that way, you drop to a 3. Hopefully this was a one time thing and not a poor class of new bartenders and servers. Only time will tell.

I came here for the World Cup finals, so I kind of figure that I had a different experience than normal.
That being said, I really enjoyed this spot. Having recently relocated to central Indiana, and I loved this bar. They had a great beer selection. I wasn’t quite sure what I wanted, and my waiter offered up options to meet my wants. He was so knowledgable and led me in the right direction! His name was Shawn, and he seemed like a beer master.
We also ordered the cheese and gravy chips. Cheese fries are NEVER a bad idea. They were amazing, and according to the menu, they’re «Doctor Recommended.» So, go for it!

Cool local spot to grab a beer after work or have something to eat. Have never had dinner here (just beer and appetizers) and have never had any issue with the food or the service. Very good selection of beer… ask the server for a recommendation on something different to expand your hop horizons.
Eclectic crowd in general. after work peeps, families, couples, singles, etc. Sort of a pain in the ass to park in their lot when the place is full. Nice outdoor seating area along 116^th weather permitting.
And if you like soccer (football) then this is the place for you. This place will be full when the World Cup starts… plan accordingly. Are the Colts on yet?

Randomly driving down 116^th Street looking for a bite between events and no time to pull over and Unilocal my options… Luckily, Chatham was there for the weary traveler. Granted, this female traveler was a bit out of place by herself and just looking for food… Yet the food found was good! The chicken lettuce wraps provided a surprising fresh Asian fusion option in a distinctly Euro Soccer atmosphere.
Best for meeting friends for a no-​kids outing.

Good selection of beer, and a pretty large menu, although I almost always get the smoked gouda apple melt — it has APPLES! It’s HEALTHY!
I wish their outdoor seating had a bit more ambiance, but I’m not sure that’s possible with 116^th St. traffic whizzing by.
Overall, one of the better places (there aren’t too many, and I hope that is remedied soon!) to get your drink on in Fishers.