Red Mango

Not impressed. This place is not self service so you’re at the mercy of the counter person when it comes to toppings and most are fruit. The only time I went, they were out of original flavor. I will not be back.

The mango frozen yogurt is a must! Tastes like a mango lassi in froyo form. Tangy and sweet… the frozen yogurt has a creaminess that seems impossible. I’ll be back here often.

If I had to rate my top 3 yogurt places in town (that I’ve tried so far), Red Mango would pull a solid second place.
This place has a couple things going for it that lands it that spot:
–While there aren’t many flavors, the flavors they do have (though I know they rotate) are absolutely delicious. They’re tart and sweet all at the same time. White Peach is my favorite. Mango runs a close second.
–It’s actually fairly healthy for one of those beloved cold and creamy dessert concoctions.
–The fruit in the toppings bar is super fresh and tasty.
But there are some things that keep it from the top spot too:
–They only have 4 flavors at any given time
–This place is not self-​serve so your toppings are at the mercy of the person behind the counter.
–It’s more on an a la cart pricing model, so if you don’t really make it worth it (laying on the toppings), it’s pricey.

this red mango sucks.
I’ve had red mango in other cities and had no problem with it, but this one is just bad. when I order two toppings and get literally 3 pieces of strawberry and 5 pieces of oreo that is just unacceptable, especially for six bucks. and it’s not just that it’s not self serve, the employees just don’t give a crap.
they always have 3 other flavors — but it’s usually just the same handful — pomegranate (I don’t get this trend), vanilla (meh, not very good), and one rotating flavor, usually something seasonal (i.e. pumpkin) or chocolately.
the parfaits look tasty, but I’ve never tried them because I fear I’ll just get a giant tub of expensive froyo with no toppings… so basically, what I get from there anyway.
it’s the only froyo in high street area, so sometimes I make do. but it’s worth it to go over to orange leaf or cuzzins for more toppings and better quality.

I’m surprised they have such high reviews! I avoid this place like no other! The prices are sky high compared to other fro-​yo places, and it isn’t self serve. I’ve been there a couple times when flies were all over the toppings! Yes, it’s great that it’s in the University Area, but no thanks! I’ll make my way down Lane or to Clintonville for my yogurt fix.

I can’t even guess at how many times I’ve walked past Red Mango. I think since it’s been there about two years or so now, it’s probably somewhere in the hundreds. But I never stopped in, because a) I wasn’t entirely sure what it was, and b) it reeked of L.A. in-​your-​face trendiness, and that tends to be a bit of a turn-​off for me.
But today was different. I was with two friends of mine, wandering up and down High Street, and the heat was beginning to give me jelly-​legs. We needed to cool off with something. Dairy Queen was mentioned, as was Sonic, and as we deliberated, we happened to walk right past Red Mango. I instantly remembered that they sold frozen yogurt and pretty much said «Why walk any further?» They agreed to give it a try.
I was sort of blown away by this place. First of all, the yogurt they use is top notch. It’s probiotic (think Activia, but slightly more posh than Jamie Lee Curtis talking about bodily functions), and at 120 calories per serving, it’s not going to wreak havoc on your summer diet.
With only four flavor choices available at once (not counting smoothies), some people might be skeptical. But let me tell you, in the age of information overload, NOT having to scan a menu of 31 flavors can sometimes be a relief. After trying a sample of the White Peach (I assume this is their seasonal flavor?), I was sold. Creamy, light, and with a substantial sweet-​sour tang, it was perfection in a cup. I added strawberries on top, and the combination achieved the impossible and improved on the aforementioned perfection.
It’s a little pricey. It’s 2.95 for the small cup (though I promise it’s a satisfying amount, if you divorce yourself from the whole American mindset that Chipotle burritos are normal-​sized), and $.50 for one topping. I didn’t realize at the time that if you pay a full dollar extra, you can get as many toppings as you want. Oops. But I’m still riding the good mood that little cup of frozen goodness gave me, so I’ll get over it.

Listen, I love me some frozen yogurt. And Red Mango is heavy on the yogurt. But the business model just doesn’t work as well for me. There’s four flavors at a time which rotate. Only one of them really sounding super delicious to me. The staff was really cool about giving samples since it’s not self-​serve frozen yogurt. Get the pomegrante! It’ll treat you right. Toppings are extra… it’s a a la carte kind of price model instead of a pay-​per-​pound model. Although! If you like tons of toppings, this could be your place. They stop charging more for toppings after two. But it’s kind of obnoxious to pay for toppings when you were just getting them on a whim. It ended up being a bit pricier than most frozen yogurt I’ve tried, even though I feel like I got about the same amount of product.
Speaking of the product, I like that it tastes more yogurt-​like than the majority of frozen yogurt. Don’t get me wrong, I love when my taste buds are tricked into the deliciousness being ice cream. But it just feels healthier and kind of great when something is clearly yogurt, but some really good yogurt. It also feels a little healthier since they have little signs in front of all the toppings saying what the topping is good for (ie. blueberries: antioxidants. Peanuts: protein). Some of the topping perks are a little far fetched, but I like feeling healthy as much as the next girl. Another unique thing to Red Mango is that it’s more than just yogurt. I was intrigued by the ad for frozen hot chocolate, so I think Red Mango might draw me in for another visit based on their various offerings. So nice job, RM!
I don’t know when this opened, but it still looks new from the inside. A bunch of tables with a good view of High Street shenanigans. But parking is a bit tricky since this place is on campus, so come armed with quarters and stay away from cam car lots!

The store itself was nice and clean, though small. Unlike some other fro yo places of late, Red Mango is not self-​serve. First let me state that the product itself was delicious and delightful. My docking of two stars is for the following reasons. 2 toppings are $ 1.50. For the amount of topping you get, this is a little steep. I got a small pomegranate yogurt with strawberries and chocolate chips. It was probably 1 or 2 strawberries tops that went in to the topping. A bit much money for product received, I must say. Also, there are only four flavors to choose from. Now, these were all tasty, but other places have more selection. Also, and this is a thing with me I know for I am Old Now and thus Curmudgeonly, places in that part of Campus are hard to find parking and you often have to pay.

I don’t usually like ice cream or frozen yogurt but I visited Red Mango this summer at an Indianapolis location and LOVED it. I came back to Columbus and had no idea we had a location on campus.
The interior and overall feel of the shop is lacking character and warmth but it’s one of the few places where that doesn’t matter.
The flavors are fresh and they don’t bog you down with a thousand options. Simple and delicious.

Red Mango opening up here is the best thing to ever happen in Columbus. The frozen yogurt is frikken orgasmic. It’s creamy, tart, and sweet but not too sweet. Best of all its healthy for you, all the posters around the interior of the store says so. Just wish they would bring back green tea tart.

Red Mango, you make me so happy! The Madagascar Vanilla they have is probably the best Vanilla Frozen Yogurt I’ve ever had. The toppings you get there are fantastic: Fruity Pebbles, multiple assortments of fruits, other cereals, the list is delicious! If you’re craving something sweet for lunch, this pro-​biotic yogurt is by far your best bet. Not only do you get absolute deliciousness all over, but you’re also eating a rather healthy (and very filling) meal! A regular sized yogurt will go a long way and a large is HUGE! I got the large once and my two friends had to help me finish it, and I know how to eat!
Overall, 5 stars for Red Mango. You’ve made me a return customer!

Here is a nice and refreshing spot if your tired of all the local icecream spots such as UDF, Coldstone, Graters, or even Jeni’s. Why not try some frozen yougurt! The staff was really nice and even gave us fresh key lime pie you’re to sample upon entering the establishment. The décor is splashed with red and large artistic pictures.
Tip on parking: it’s impossible to park right next to the store. You will have to turn at 15^th & high then go downth one way alley to either the parking lot next to the old longs book store or next the starbucks. These meters always seem to be filled up and don’t let your meter run out of money, the meter men/​women are not lenient.
High point: extremely cheap
Low point: hard to find a parking spot. Closest sport is down a back alley to park near a Starbucks a block away.

Don’t blink. You might miss Red Mango.
Located in the middle of campus on High Street, this store does nothing to promote itself or the location. In fact, I’ve been told the only way you can find Red Mango is if you’re NOT looking for it. Only out of the corner of your eye will you see the Red Mango logo.
So how does a store that you can’t find survive on High Street? Delicious frozen yogurt. Beyond delicious. And good for you! Not just pretend-​good either.
Probiotics. I don’t know what they are but I’m told they are good for you. And they make me fart. Red Mango frozen yogurt is full of probiotics! And you can top that good-​for-​you treat with tons of fresh fruit, dark chocolate bits, or cereal.
You have two «choices». Either pay 50 cents a topping or $ 1.00 for unlimited toppings. No contest — always shell out a buck!
My favorite combo? Tangomonium (citrus) with tons of berries, coconut and dark chocolate bits.

I’m a frozen yogurt fanatic, and Red Mango is by far my favorite!
Going to Red Mango requires a trip to Campus, but that’s A-​okay with me! I’ve read a few comments about the location and the interior, but come on people — it’s about the yogurt! To me, Red Mango is simply the best flavor of any frozen yogurt I’ve ever had. They use real sugar to sweeten the yogurt, and I think you can totally tell the difference! Yagoot uses corn syrup, and I can always taste a sticky aftertaste.

Red Mango has only been open a few months (like less than six) and it’s already really worn down and shabby inside. Every once in awhile I need to go to places like this to remind myself that I do not miss the campus/​college lifestyle. It was kinda warm and smelly in there.
It’s a shame because I really like their yogurt! It’s much more creamy than the Yagoot that I’m used to. It’s almost like a frozen greek yogurt. They aren’t shy about prices though. I was a little taken aback by what they charge.
I also tried their green tea-​lemonade probiotic iced tea. I usually stay away from any sort of sweetened green tea drink because they tend to be sickeningly sweet, but this was tart and refreshing. Perfect for a warm, sunny afternoon.
I hope they open some cleaner locations around the area soon, I will definitely go back for a yogurt fix.

The boy and I finally made it to Red Mango after a foiled attempt (Friday night trip to Red Mango + hundreds of OSU students with nothing to do = bad idea). It was a gorgeous warm (ish) afternoon when we arrived. The menu is projected on two large screen tvs which rotate among the different offerings, so you have to catch it at the right time! We got a large pomegranate with fruity pebbles, which cost a little over $ 5… ouch.
The yogurt itself was quite creamy, and did not have much of a pomegranate flavour, which was disappointing. The swirl was also hollow in the middle! However, fruity pebbles help cover many flaws.
There was only one other person in the shop — a friend of the clerk. The shop was bright and cheerful, but the table we were at was woefully unstable.

This is quite possibly the best thing I have ever eaten. My husband and I find ourselves going completely out of the way just to stop by Red Mango. The original flavor with dark chocolate chips and fresh red raspberries is to die for! It is a little on the expensive side, and I am not a fan of the location (Ohio State campus is SCUM, parking is a B, and it’s very far from my house in the suburbs), but the yogurt is well worth it.

This place has a fantastic choice of froyo which is new to the Columbus scene as far as I know. I’ve honestly never had soft serve froyo prior to eating here but wow! The flavors are bold and smooth with the great selection of toppings!
They recently replaced my favorite flavor (green tea) with pumpkin spice. If it was any other flavor I might have been upset but it’s a worthy advesary.
A must try!

I can’t believe this tart yogurt treat can taste as good as it does and contain 0 grams of fat! Located between 15^th and 16^th on High Street, this little shop is situated right on campus. White walls and cute little red tables & chairs decorate this store.
There are three flavored yogurts along with the original flavor. Tangomonium, green tea and pomengranate are the choices and you get to try them first before buying. The green tea is really excellent and tastes like a more mild version of green tea ice cream. Tangomonium tastes like smarties candies and ended up being the flavor I chose. Then next to the yogurt are all these fresh fruit toppings, chocolate toppings and other delicious goodies you can top your yogurt with. I chose fresh mango cubes which weren’t quite ripe enough but still good.
The yogurt is tart and reminds me of Pinkberry. Yum! A small with one topping was around $ 4.00.

oh dearest tart yogurt, how wrong it was of me to abandon you during the summer of 2007. i confess, i was thinking only of myself when the land of cornfields and buckeye football called to me. it was my fault, i should have never left you in the concrete landscape of new york city.
but you prevailed! i knew you would! the journey you made from the left coast to new york prepared you for the two year long adventure into the heartland. your creamy, puckering, icey treats inspires song and dance from deep within my loins. oh dearest tart yogurt, please accept me into your perfect swirling folds dotted with juicy fresh fruit bits. i swear, upon the graves of tasti-​d-​lite and tcby, i will visit you every day for the remainder of my life.