Anthony’s Pizza and Pasta

Best NYC pizza around.
Over and over they produce heaven lol
Delivery takes over an hour every time as they deliver many pizzas at one time
One my pizza came with all the cheese on one side and so greasy.
But every single other pizza was spot on!

I will be upfront and say that I am a pizza snob, being raised on the east coast. I also have Celiac disease and am always on the lookout for good gluten free pizza. Anthony’s is the worst I have had. It was very small, expensive, and they burned it. Chewy, like eating a soggy cracker. THE WORST. The pizza that my husband and kids had was average– but again, so expensive, especially for the quality. Go to Dads and Dudes. Well worth the money.

Time to start looking for a new pizza place. Had a horrible experience at the 16^th Street Mall location off of Wynkoop but had a great experience off of Stout. I figured this placed wouldn’t be so bad. If you go during meal times be prepared to be 1) Ignored 2) Looked at as if you’re a nuisance 3) Ignored even longer. I phoned in my order and showed up 40 minutes after my call. When we showed up, a girl in some skull t-​shirt and an Anthony’s shirt wrapped around her waist just stared at us. At first I didn’t know if she worked there but acknowledged us with the «I hate this job but since mommy and daddy won’t give me money, I have to work» look.
We waited an additional 15 – 20 minutes before we asked about the pizza and miraculously it popped up 5 minutes after Just to discover it was lukewarm meaning it had been sitting out for awhile. By the time we made it home, we ate one slice and tossed the rest in the fridge. We lost our appetite. Thanks Anthony’s pizza, we’ll be looking elsewhere. If anyone reading this has suggestions for other pizza places, I’m all ears!

We have ordered from here quite a bit over 6 years and the staff is usually friendly. Delivery always takes a while. But tonight when our pizza got here the toppings were everywhere but on the pizza and it was cold! First time I have ever paid delivery person and went straight to microwave for warm food! Just not okay! Way too much $ for this quality!

No complaints about Anthony’s! I’ve lived in Denver for almost four years and have seen many Anthony’s across the area but never tried one out. I’m a huge fan of pizza (Duh, who isn’t?) but especially pizza places where you can grab a slice and go because sometimes that’s all you need. I really dig all the topping options they have at Anthony’s plus other goodies on the menu. My fiancé and I split a large house salad and each got a slice with a couple of toppings. I got pepperoni and jalapeño (pickled, aw yeah!) and it was wonderful. Not too greasy, not too crispy, just some great pizza. The salad was equally delicious so it was a nice, semi-​light lunch for two without breaking the bank. They have an outdoor seating area in the front which I’m always a fan of but then again, this is a strip mall so there isn’t a lot of ambiance involved.

We come to this Anthony’s every couple of weeks for slices. We’ve always enjoyed our pizza and the toppings are plentiful. The dining space is pleasant enough and the staff has always been nice. It is what it is, more of a take-​out place with no ambiance. But we love the pizza!

The service here is awful. Called and left on hold for 7 mins before I hung up. Ordered online and their site doesn’t make deliver clear so I pressed submit and was told I had to pick up. Go there and confusion at the front counter. Finally helped by a girl… super clueless… she rang me up for a soda and I waited 15 mins… which was 20 mins after the pizza was supposed to be ready. Watched staff text on their phones and complain about customers. Finally asked the girl «are they still working on my order». Super clueless look on her face and then asked me what my name was again. Went back and brought me my food right away because it has probably been ready for 20 mins. The owners need to get this place together… far too many alternatives for pizza in the area to deal with this…

We waited hour and a half for pizza became cold we called to get a discount they didn’t want to do that, this place sucks we called again after we receive the pizza they are there ignoring our phone call.

Called this place but I was left on hold for 8:28sec while attempting to place a take out order. Woman at the register finally answered as I pulled in the parking lot. She was completely indifferent and unapologetic.
I’m sure my dismay was evident do there’s no telling when or how my order will come out. Interestingly, there were only 4 occupied tables in the place and their phone rang just once as I waited.

Ordered spaghetti with meatball and sausage. meat was good, pasta cold, sauce cold and out of a can at best. chicken Alfredo came as a piece of chicken and dry cold pasta. they did come back out and replace, or actually «exchange» the food. They actually took the incorrect food back and brought new. Felt that was a bit tacky and almost like they were calling my bluff. Anyway, sub par food. Nice staff at least. oh yeah, ordered cheese with extra cheese on my spaghetti and got 14 little plastic containers of grated, powdered cheese.
Amazing Cannoli!

Let’s start with service since there were so many complaints. This was my first time, it was nice and clean, the guy greated me, he was friendly and explained the process since I had never been here before. Pizza came out pretty fast, it was hot and good.
Good job, I’ll come again.

Love this style of pizza. Anthony’s does a superb job and this location is awesome. The restaurant is clean and feels like a pizza joint. My favorite is a couple pepperoni slices for lunch.
You can’t go wrong here!

I ordered pizza recently from the Smoky Hill Anthony’s Pizza as we have countless times over the past 10 years. I called in our order around 6:40 and was told it would be an hour to an hour and 15 minutes to get delivered. We would eat a little late, but no big deal. At 8:15 I called back to find out where my pizza was and was immediately put through to the manager who said our order had been canceled, but she did not say why. She said she would have the cook make me a new pizza and send it out ASAP (and she would give us the pizza no charge). Everyone makes mistakes, so I was OK with this.
Replacement pizza shows up at 9:15. It’s ice cold (pizzas from here are usually so hot you have to wait to bite into them). Delivery driver mentions that he tried to deliver the pizza to one of my neighbors and they said they didn’t order it so he took it back. The order was not canceled, they tried to deliver the pizza to my neighbor and then took it back to the store.
So the manager had the driver wait an additional 45 minutes to bring me a pizza that was over 2 hours old. I was furious when we got the cold pizza so I called the store and let her know that I knew what she had done. She told me I could quit getting pizza from them if I wanted to and could not have cared less. She also told me the kitchen was now closed so she could not make me another.
I asked for the owner’s phone number but they won’t give it out, so I asked them to have him call me. He called when I was in a meeting, but just left the restaurant phone number for me to call him. When I called back, he was gone. I tried calling a couple more times and he is never there and has not called me back. I assume the terrible attitudes that his employees have starts with him.
We won’t be eating at Anthony’s any more.

Mm this place sucks every time I come the front counter has a bad attitude. It’s like wow I did not choose your job profession. No thought into making good food been here twice kicking myself last time I came second time I threw myself down the stairs out front. Be smart drive the extra go to Marcos pizza great service great people

There is a difference between reasonable and absolutely ludicrous requests. I worked food before and I understand this, so I didnt think that extra cheese was too much to ask.
The cook must have thought different because there was so much cheese on our pizza, it made it inedible. Literally a quarter inch of cheese. It was so thick, it wasnt even completely melted. And the individual slices we ordered were cardboard tough to the point my daught couldnt tear through it with her teeth.
I would recommend the garlic cheese bread. That was definitely tasty.

This pizza place is as disappointing as my ex husband. I’ve had Anthony’s from other locations but this location is horrible. The service is bad, the pizza is bad and they just throw toppings on without even cooking them. It literally looks like someone just took the pizza out of the oven and dumped a handful of olives on top without cooking them. They were still raw.

Pizza by the slice is perfect for single diners. The slices are generous, warm and delish! They offer 2 cheese dlices and a soda for 6.25 or 1 slice, salad and soda for 6.99. Yummy for the tummy!

The pizza was okay however extremely overpriced. There was not a clean table in the place and the girl helping us kept wiping her nose and never washed her hands. Then she brought in the floor mat from outside and still didn’t wash her hands. I also was surprised that I was penalized for ordering my pizza to go. If I ate it there it was going to be 24 inches but since I had it to go it was only about 19 inches. What in the world is that all about! When I asked her about it she told me that was their policy.

Had them as a dinner while moving into my new house. Ive had Anthonys many times before and always thought of them as one of the better CO chains. Im happy to say this location made two really nice looking pizzas, and were tastier than other Anthonys I’ve had. Its a bit pricey, that is a legit gripe.
Is it going to make you think youre in Wrigleyville or Manhattan? Of course not. Pizza snobs from Chicago and NYC should realize that is colorado, not known for pizza in the least; and for multiple reasons why!

So disappointing. We ordered a large pizza. ½ mushroom, green pepper, and black olives. The second half sausage and pepperoni. The veggie back crust was more crisp than the meat however the body of the veggie was soggy and stuck to the paper. The real problem was the ingredients were not spread evenly. The green peppers were cut in all kinds of shapes. Some big pieces and some tiny. Hardly any mushrooms but plenty of black olives.
Wanted the leftover pizza the next day. Boo hoo it just wasn’t good. Next time it is back to Dominos.