The Olive Mill

I have frequented the Olive Mill several times and have enjoyed a number of their Oils and Vinegars. Most of them are terrific. Recently I purchased 3 – 4 bottles of a combination of the oils and delicious vinegars. After I tried my selected oil on several entres after getting home, I no longer cared for one of the flavors. I called the manager, (who btw, gives Carmel the definition of the attitude that so many people think we all have in Carmel-​not good). I explained that I had purchased and tried several oils and vinegars (and dropped a chunk of change), and wasn’t happy with one of them and asked if I had any options to return it. He said that is why they allow tastings (I understand that, but I had tried several and I think my bottle tasted stronger and I didn’t care for it after getting it home and putting it on some things). Very politely I asked if there was a chance that I could get one that I knew I liked, and (after correcting my pronunciation of ‘Province ’ and giving me the French pronunciation) he basically said no that I was stuck with it. If you don’t allow for an occasional unhappy customer with buyers remorse, don’t expect return buyers, especially with that kind of an attitude.

I’ve passed this shop a few times and after listening to a special on NPR over Olive Oil felt I was ready to try a few specialty oils armed with a bit of knowledge.
I was looking for an olive oil that was unique and specifically used for finishing a dish vs cooking. I use quite a few flavored olive oils in cooking was looking for a high end specialty oil as a splurge.
The cups are actually not a bad thing as the oil should be felt on the tongue as well as tasted to appreciate the delicacy of the blends. However, I agree the samples are delicious and instantly a craving for steaming French bread is inevitable.
The décor is adorable. The owner was friendly and helpful when we had questions but was also discreet enough to let us browse without being intrusive. The mixed spices in the back are a definite bonus. A lot of varieties for mixes as well as exotic salts and peppercorns.
I recommend planning for at least 20 mins to allow time to sample a few. My absolute favorite item is the Tuscany Balsamic vinegar. If you enjoy cooking this location should be added to your list of favorite ingredient stops!
Adorable gift packs also make a great gift idea.
Due to the shelf life and wish to try several varieties I brought along a friend to split the cost of a bottle. Tip: if you return your bottle clean and dry a 10% reduction is offered on refills!

This little oil shop is adorable! Recently opened this summer, you are able to taste test all the flavors and produce your own concoction. They also sell plenty of common goods such as recipe books, bottles, pourers, and all things bread & oil!
Love the idea of making my own blend and great for gifts!
Downside: They do not provide bread to taste the oils, you either drink it or I like to dip my finger in my little cups… they may have changed this but I think it should be a must to have some bread around!