Square Donuts

Affordable, delicious donuts! Staff is extremely friendly and the atmosphere is always light and casual. There is seating both inside and outside the store. There is a variety of donuts however, glazed is still personally my favorite. They also have coffee available! Highly recommend if around the area, it’s a unique experience and truly worth the visit :)

We are from out of town but have family in the area. This is our # 1 donut shop in Indy. The staff always greets me kindly when I arrive and for $ 9 a dozen it’s a great deal.
I’d recommend sticking with the classics, glazed yeast, sprinkle, chocolate, and strawberry. Not to mention, the cinnamon donut! O, the cinnamon donut, it resides firmly in my top 5 favorite donuts, ever. Yes, maybe a bold claim, but each time I visit I reaffirm my vowels.

I’m a regular here on Saturday mornings. A great addition to the Arts District for those wanting to spend a few leisurely hours looking at the galleries or shops.
The doughnuts are delicious. I stick with the yeast doughnuts and the chocolate frosted. My grandson devours the sprinkles, and my bf enjoys the maple. The plain glazed are insanely delicious. Melt in your mouth, warm, and fluffy. Add the chocolate frosting and I can inhale them. The staff are wonderful. No matter if there is a line or we pop in during the rare quiet moment they take the time to answer questions. The tractor doughnut was a sample one morning and it was good but the yeast own my heart.
If you have the Carmel calendar which we picked up free at some event there are coupons for buy one get one free for up to a dozen. A fantastic deal.
Unfortunately, I’ve tried to stop on the way to work and they are not open early through the week. That accounts for the 4 star. If I could stop and pick up dozens on way to work I would certainly take advantage of sharing these with others. However, with current opening time I’m forced to use other shops.

Friendly staff, but there are better flavored donuts around. who really cares if they are square or round?
they cater to the Ritters gas station crowd, so not necessarily going for quality.

So disappointing! I love supporting local businesses and the idea of the small guy being successful in a corporate world. The first several times the experience was great. However, after the last 3 visits coming up empty handed I’m done! Two of the best opportunities (automobillia and art fest) they either ran out or started with 0. I tried again today on a Friday morning and by 9 they were out again of chocolate iced. This is another example of a business with a superior product and the demand but bad business execution. Having your donuts made somewhere different then where they are sold will destroy this business. I love love the product but are driven to the competition because of the lack of supply.

I called ahead to place a large order. No one ever answered the phone. I even made 2 phone calls 30 minutes apart to give them the benefit of the doubt. It would have been extremely convenient when I take my clients donuts, fun and new. My review is based solely on customer service. There was none. Their donuts may be delicious, however I will never know. I will be using Jack’s. Out of my way but very nice and they answer their phone.

These guys are just right around the corner from my work and I must say I visit them more often than I’d care to admit. Some days just for a cup of joe (their chocolate raspberry blend with a half packet of Splenda) and some days for the donuts. Days that I go in a little bit later, the donut selection seems to be lacking — but their staff is super friendly and helpful so that makes up for not having my first choice (jelly filled) always available. The cinnamon sugar donut is delicious as well. Definitely a good spot to hang out and get some work done or have a quick convo with the staff on my way to the office!

We LOVE the donuts, especially the maple and chocolate iced, but the last three times we’ve been, they had either ran out of donuts by 10am or didn’t have what we wanted. Today was day 2 of the Arts Festival — shouldn’t they have been prepared for a large number of visitors? We walked 2 miles for an iced donut, only to be told they didn’t have any. We will just go to Jacks from now on. They have great donuts too!

I have been twice and both time the lack of selection of donuts was super disappointing. If you go stick with the non filled ones. The ones that are supposed to have filling simply just don’t have any filling and will leave you disappointed. We bought 2 dozen donuts on our last trip and 18 of them were filled ones and they were basically empty. I am not sure who makes these or where they are made but there is no continuity or quality control when just about every donut had nothing in them. Maybe a machine makes them? Maybe it was broken on our last 2 trips here?
I will give it 2 stars as the yeast and the cake donuts were good, but there are just too many other donuts places in town that are better.

Disappointing business practices.
Honestly the donuts here are very delicious, however the majority of the time they are out of them. This morning was the FIFTH!!!, yes 5^th time that I have shown up at this establishment only to leave with nothing at all. I understand that they tend to sell out of donuts, especially if you come later in the day. My issue is that when I show up at 7:00am to find a sign on the door that says the donuts are running late. This has happened multiple times. Obviously their donuts are made off site, which is no problem if your product is on the shelves when you open for business. There are plenty of other donut places around town who actually have donuts on their shelves when they open, those places will be getting my money in the future. Like I said earlier, their donuts are good if you are able to show up in the short window that they are actually available.

I won’t go back. 2 bad trips is enough for me. I heard such good things, but we bought 2 dozen doughnuts, 1 dozen was supposed to have filling, but the sad amount that was in there was pathetic. We may as well should have gone to Dunkin at least I know they suck. Being square may be unique, but that’s all they have going for them. They aren’t iced well and aren’t fresh tasting, but they are square.

There’s quite a few doughnut places to choose from… this is definitely the cheapest, most convenient, and friendliest. The doughnuts are yummy but the selection does run out quickly on weekends…
The strawberry cream is my favorite… the kiddos love their crullers. Coffee is not so good but they do have fresh-​squeezed OJ and hot chocolates and espressos.
Again, the staff makes the place. Always warm, friendly and quick.

So of course I decide to stop in on National Donut Day, myself along with the rest of the city! The line was out the door and starting down the block, at 7am, 30 minutes after they opened.
I waited nearly 20 minutes, which, holy cow. But, I wanted to treat my coworkers so I stuck it out. I purchased two dozen and was inquiring about my favorite old fashioned, sour cream glazed, as I had seen some behind the counter. The rather snippy woman at the counter informed me I couldn’t have those as they were a call in order. Umm, ok, had no idea you could call in an order for donuts! After I asked if there were more she gave me nasty look and informed me they were sold out and walked away. Yes, it was packed and hectic and stressful I’m sure, but let’s not throw customer service to the wind here!
Anywho, the donuts are tasty, definitely better than a chain place. I will return for my love of fried dough, despite the attitude. Word of advice, these are mainly yeast donuts. I’m big on cake donuts and they don’t carry many varieties.

Tried one of their cinnamon dusted donuts at the Saturday Farmer’s Market and loved it! I was shocked at how cheap it was (only $ 1!) and how fresh the dough was, especially since they had been sitting out all morning. This morning I tried a couple other flavours — chocolate dipped with Bavarian crème, apple and glazed — and enjoyed them even more the second time!

At $.90 a pop, these donuts are a good, little, inexpensive treat (or meal, if you’re like me). I’ve tasted the glazed, maple and PB&J, and the glazed is probably my favorite.

They’re doughnuts. It’s really hard to go wrong. And Square Doughnuts is really right.
Tried the blueberry cake doughnut. It was still warm. It was crispy. It was so sweet and so good.
Nice lil shop in the Arts and Design district. #treatyoself

I’ve enjoyed these ANGEL FARTS in Bloomington for years.
Now we can enjoy them here in Carmel !
BRAVO !!!

When I first heard of Square Donuts, I was concerned that it was simply going to be a gimmick, with no depth beyond the novelty of a donut with a high efficiency shape for packing. I was mistaken.
The donuts are moist and creative. I would definitely rank them with the likes of Longs or Taylor’s. The service is friendly and the coffee is surprisingly good. I highly recommend spending a Saturday morning picking up a coffee and donuts and walking around Downtown Carmel as you enjoy your local donuts.

First impressions: friendly staff and some tasty, affordable doughnuts. I tried the blueberry cake and the chocolate square along with the apple cider, all of which were perfect for a cold fall day. I overheard the owner saying the cider came from a family owned farm in Vermont. The cider was great without being too sweet. There is a small parking lot on the side of the building and several tables to enjoy your doughnuts on site. Overall, this is a nice place to stop in and enjoy a doughnut and a great cup of cider.

This place has been opened for about a month. A customer comes in one a time to order.
I, on the other hand, was not impressed with their 90 cents /​donut or $ 9 for a dozen. I had a bite of their lemon cake donut. It was ok, but I was not going to pay their asking price. They sell more than square donuts (who really cares for the shape).