3 Stars overall: Our waiter last night was great(he was 5 stars) due to his desire to be of assistance. 4 stars for the pool tables and shuffle boards, and overall environment. We were a party of 6 on a Tuesday night and had the place to ourselves(mostly, that is). The deduct in points comes from the food. The menu is limited, especially for people who are gluten free and/or paleo. I think this place excels at bar food, but not healthier options. It is pricey and not everyone in our group loved their selections. My $ 16.95 salad left me completely under-whelmed. I left hungry!
Cora A.
Tu valoración: 3 Indianapolis, IN
Atmosphere was great, service good too. Bartender told me the Mac n cheese was«so, so good», but was hardly. My husbands bean burger was delicious, which is what I would have normally ordered but am a mac n cheese enthusiast… live and learn.
Peter M.
Tu valoración: 4 Fishers, IN
Good value all around. Pub menu so burgers, salads, wings, beer and wine. I had the wings(very good), my family had the big pretzel and for dinner we had burgers, chicken tenders and orange chicken. Everyone was please with their dinners. Also had an IPA which was very good selection. Service was solid and timely and atmosphere is very family oriented. Pool tables and shuffleboard tables and a bunch of big screens to check out sports. I would definitely come back.
Nicki C.
Tu valoración: 2 Westfield, IN
Maybe I just didn’t find my «signature dish», but I wasn’t overly impressed with the food. I tried several items on the menu, but here wasn’t anything particularly unique about any of them. In my opinion, Henry’s was on par as every other American classic chain around. The only reason for 2 stars instead of 1 was our waiter. He is a bartender, and from my perspective, he appeared to be the only one also serving tables on a slow evening. Despite being busy, he really took the time to help us make food and drink choices that would suit our tastes. I’m just not sure Henry’s has the food to back up the service.
Bill Z.
Tu valoración: 5 Palm Beach Gardens, FL
I met a friend from high school there last evening for dinner and some beer. It was«$ 3 beer Tuesday» and we got there in time for the Happy Hour menu so we had dinner for a really good price. My macaroni and cheese was good, though a tad too much garlic for my liking. The chips and artichoke dip were quite good. We ate in the bar, but the waitress was very attentive and the manager even stopped by to see how we were enjoying the food. The relaxed atmosphere was nice. All too often you are crammed into a bar-restaurant, but this was upscale, bright and had plenty of room. It seems to attract a «youngish» crowd, but there were all ages there. After my initial experience here, I hope to come back again for dinner.
Nicole L.
Tu valoración: 5 Indianapolis, IN
I’m gonna go out on a limb here and give this place 5 stars, because the food was superb, we had great service, and they had good beer on tap. This place is trying to be cool and hipster, but the effort came off contrived. I think my wife and I were the youngest people there. It’s like a hipster pub you could take your grandma to, and she would love it so much that she may start to schedule her weekly bridge games there — and that would be entirely appropriate. We had the beer battered cod tacos and the peanut buster burger, and we were both very pleased with our selections. Prices are about $ 12 per entrée, beers run about $ 6 for the beer on draft. So know what you’re getting into– it’s a yuppy wannabehipster pub, with good food and good beer and decent prices. Go there, but don’t go to be cool(Cuz it’s not!) go for the grub!
Christine C.
Tu valoración: 4 Westfield, IN
We’re so glad Henry’s is here. After not being too thrilled with the other restaurants who have occupied this space previously, it’s so great to see this new place consistently busy and the parking lot packed. Henry’s has been consistently good, each and every time we’ve eaten there. It’s great for families, it’s great for date night, it’s great for a night out with friends. I love how diverse the menu is. Their Mongolian Beef is delicious, but if I’m in the mood for a burger, they build some of the best in town. Insider Tip: Even if you’re sitting in the main dining area, ask for the special bar food menu. There are some crazy good(delicious) deals on there, and you can get them any night of the week.
Porshia M.
Tu valoración: 5 Noblesville, IN
We love this place! It is so nice to be able to go somewhere with good food, live music, drinks and games that is kid friendly. I have younger siblings and they also love this place! They have an awesome peanut butter burger on the happy hour menu, and it is filling! You have to sit in the bar for happy hour. Overall– we love this place!
Erin D.
Tu valoración: 3 Westerville, OH
I initially came here because I thought it was a restaurant I had been to years back. It must have changed because I was a little confused when we were seated. The crowd was an odd mix; families and then we sat overlooking pool tables with signs for a 40th birthday party. Everything overall was good. Table liked the pretzel. Whole grain mustard was the best dipper. Had fish tacos; solid bet. Hubby w a wintry Mac & cheese, he couldn’t finish. I wouldn’t be vying to come here again, but better than a typical mass market chain.
Jason S.
Tu valoración: 4 Fishers, IN
First off, if the service wasn’t so freaking on point I’d have given this place 3 stars. Was there this weekend for a guy’s night out and we all had a pretty good time. Our server was quick and attentive and observing the management, you could tell the place was well run. They have a couple shuffleboard and pool tables which were great for our group. They have tons of TVs like every bar does anymore. I noticed a couple Golden Tee machines if that is your thing. With that, why would I possible take away two stars? Food quality and price. I love me some onion rings. The breaded, crunchy goodness with a flavorful onion finish. Except one problem… there onions had no flavor at all. Literally, nothing. The best anyone at our table could describe it was like eating breaded water. Prior to the onion rings, we also had some gargonzola waffle fries off of the happy hour menu and they were heavy. That may have been okay if the waffle fries had any oomph to them. They were not seasoned, crispy and actually pretty soggy because of the mound of cheese. A couple folks in my group had burgers and said they were good but the standard fare fries were meh at best. In terms of price, other Unilocalers have mentioned it, but spending $ 6 – 8.50 for a pint is pretty difficult to swallow and that seems to be what every establishment is charging to prey on the craft beer clientele. Toss in my $ 9 fried water rings and the cost can quickly devalue the amazing service delivered by your staff.
Alex D.
Tu valoración: 4 Indianapolis, IN
The beer selection is small but very good. The kentucky red ale is superior. There are multiple shuffleoboard tables and 8-foot pocket pool tables. The tables are spread out enough that you don’t feel so cramped. great time!
Leslie H.
Tu valoración: 5 Carmel, IN
After strings of a variety of different restaurants in the same building, this one I think is a keeper! The bar area has lots of TV’s for the sports freaks. The more important part, the bar is stocked with good selection of draft beer, tons of local products, great cocktail selection and knowledgeable bartenders. They can whip up something great and customize it with however your heart desires. As for the food, they have a really good selection and reasonably priced. The cheese curds are great and the Bavarian pretzel is ginormous. The entrees are good from meat, seafood and pasta selections. It’s an American standard fare and they put some spins on some items such as their Americanized orange chicken who his actually pretty decent with their jasmine rice. They also have a kids menu. My son loves their chicken tenders and fries. Don’t expect pink slime on their chicken. It’s the real deal and how they seasoned it is pretty good. They have daily specials. Probably my fave will be the bottomless mojitos on Mondays.
Erin Q.
Tu valoración: 3 Carmel, IN
I recently went to Henry’s for dinner, and I found the overall experience to be pretty mediocre. If you’re a sports fan, this is the place for you! Tons of tvs– maybe more than any other place I’ve seen. There is no seat in the place that doesn’t have a clear view of a big screen. They also have a wide range of seating options… High top, regular tables, booths, oversized plush chairs, etc. The menu is large, but doesn’t have a lot that catches your eye. The beer menu is also small, but they do have some high quality brews. The issue is the price. I don’t really want to drop $ 7.50 for a pint, unless it’s something really special. I had the Philly Cheese Steak, and the waitress quickly said, this isn’t your typical PCS– I asked if it was with Cheese Whiz, and she looked at me like I had a third eye. So then I asked if it was good, and she said no– I couldn’t tell if she was joking, so I decided to go ahead with my order. The sandwich was okay, but it was different. It’s a semi-liquid cheese sauce on top of an open faced hoagie. The meat had a great favor, but everything else was just okay. My boyfriend had the onion rings, and those were also okay. I would go back to Henry’s, but only to catch a game and a cheaper beer :)
Fernando E.
Tu valoración: 4 Westfield, IN
Great atmosphere and friendly staff! Great food. Will definitely enjoy the rest of my evening and be back again! The only reason I don’t give it a 5 stars is because my wife did not like a drink that the waiter pushed on her saying she would really like it. We didn’t drink it and still had to pay for it.
Carie W.
Tu valoración: 4 Indianapolis, IN
Husband and I happened upon Henry’s one weekend while running errands. We had been a fan of Kincaid’s, but didn’t make it a habit to stop in after we moved further south. I’d heard Kincaid’s closed and there had been this, that, or the other in the location. Again, never made an effort to give whatever came next a whirl. The stars aligned for us now that it’s Henry’s and I can’t tell you how glad I am that they did! From start to finish, it was a spot on experience. The calamari was delectable. Crispy, habit-forming, addictive. The mix in jalapenos and serve with a jalapeño-bacon tartar that is just delightful. This was a very, very good start. For entrees, I ordered the Peanut Buster Burger and Husband chose the Dirty Dog. Both were scrumptious! I seriously can’t wait to dig into exploring more of this menu. And the drinks. I was driving on this day, so I was only a taste-tester while Husband got to enjoy the libations. As taste-tester, I can tell you the Cucumber Spice Martini was just knock-your-socks-off good. Not too sweet, not too overwhelming. It was a refreshing, sip-able, cocktail, perfect for a Sunday afternoon. Last, but not least, I really loved the older crowd vibe here while watching the Colts. It was just our speed. The service? Excellent. Perfect combination of attention, needs anticipation, and pleasant conversation. You hit it out of the park, Henry’s. I’ll be back very, very soon. Show me consistency and I’ll show you that fifth star!
Tom B.
Tu valoración: 3 Westfield, IN
We were very happy with Henry’s. We were greeted by a very friendly pair of young ladies as soon as we walked in. We arrived at about 5:45pm on a Friday, so there weren’t many people when we arrived, but it got packed quickly. My Jambalaya was spicy, but that’s how I like it. Our appetizers were exceptional, including the sushi and hanging pretzel. Our server was extremely polite and prompt, and the manager came around to check on us midway through the meal. This place exceeded my expectations.
Marc M.
Tu valoración: 5 Carmel, IN
Wife and I came in tonight to a packed house and patio. We saw Chef Sean and called him over to our table. We asked him if we could mix some things up on the menu… he said I’ll do whatever you want. My wife ordered the Cobb Salad but instead of chicken, she got a hamburger patty cooked medium… don’t knock it until you try it! The staff goes out of their way to make you feel at home. Don’t believe me? Just ask Chef Sean for something special. Mark and Josh will be by to make sure everything is to your liking as well!
Kira T.
Tu valoración: 5 Westfield, IN
LOVED everything about this place! Great upscale sports-themed pub. The food was so simple but unique. Brats, fish tacos, cheese curd appetizers, giant pretzels, philly cheese steaks. It was all delicious. The service was amazing and the server provided a lot of information about the place and what they have to offer on football sundays. There are some games for people to play and plenty of TVs for game day. Good selection of beers, would like to see some more local ones on tap. The manager came around and said hi and was also very friendly. The food came out quickly and was very hot and fresh. Overall I thoroughly enjoyed my visit here. I left in a great mood after I had a bad day at work and was very happy we decided to stop in. We’ll back ALOT for sure!
Ron R.
Tu valoración: 5 Indianapolis, IN
Holy wow!!! What the… I had no idea this place would be so awesome… first of all, the place is very nice… a bit small but perfect for Clay Terrace. Wood structures everywhere give it an elegant feel. Very nice bar setup. 2 nice(FREE) pool tables and a large full size shuffle board table. Also 2 brand new Golden Tee machines if you are into that. I came here for lunch with work and not a single person was disapointed… everyone was blown away by quality from a «pub & grill». OK, so this isn’t rich french cuisine that has layers and layers of complexity and depth… but what it has(and doesn’t try to pretend it is something else) is flavor… and a ton of it. I had the Philly Cheese Steak sandwich(all of the entrees for the most part are very plain«bar food» sounding) and it came in a fresh demi-bagguete style french bread with a hole in the center and the topping piled in. The flank steak was tender and delicious, the mushrooms sauteed perfectly and the onions/peppers were perfectly sauteed. Topped off was a small layer of Tillamook cheese(they use Tillamook on everything). As a side I opt’d for the Gorgonzola Fries… and wow… it was like hitting the jackpot in Vegas… I don’t know how these things aren’t famous yet. Seasoned and breaded waffle fries covered in a Gorgonzola drizzle with chunks of Gorgonzola crumbles. These were heaven. If you only come here for one thing… try these fries! I’m so excited that this place is around and hope that it fares better than its predecessors in the same location. Hats off to you Henry’s.
T.j. K.
Tu valoración: 4 Carmel, IN
My wife and I used to enjoy Kincaid’s back when it was in this location until they changed the menu and took off a couple of our favorite things. Once they did that it didn’t stick out like it used to and we started going other places and hadn’t been to any of the other iterations since. We had someone to watch the kids late but not enough time to check out a movie like we normally would so we decided to head out for a dessert and stopped in here. The interior is nice and I really like the pool/shuffleboard room that they have set up and they had some live music playing outside. We didn’t actually end up getting any dessert once we got there because a few of the items on the app menu jumped out at us so we had to try them. We got the fried cheese curds and giant pretzel. The cheese curds were different because they have a spicy sauce like you will find on calamari which is one of my wife’s favorite apps so that was a hit. The pretzel was giant as described and also very good. We choose the ale cheese and pb & bacon dip. Both were good but I think the cheese was better. I would definitely like to get back some time and try a few more things to see how good all the food is.