I went back to the restaurant cashier was not friendly but made my order within 15 minutes! So one star for the speed! One pizza, 2 chickens a burger and 4 slices 57 $! Not bad! One more for the prices Ok! Pizza is good always like today! Hamburger combo was a good surprise! Chicken parmesan was good and chicken cacciatore was really good! Fries good enough crispy and tasty! Two more stars for the food! My only problem was that the guy on the front doesn’t wear a hat or gloves but still touch the food! I’ll come back sorentina!
Lorraine P P.
Tu valoración: 1 Brooklyn, NY
Kept going back here because its close to home. But no more, last time I was there they served me the flattest lasagna I ever saw. Staff is odd.
Jason T.
Tu valoración: 4 Brooklyn, NY
Delicious Italian food everyday. Chicken Francesca is amazing! Sicilian pizza! The best!
Julio S.
Tu valoración: 1 Dyker Heights, Brooklyn, NY
I received an errant order I had placed through a third party website. I called the restaurant to see if they could help with the situation. The lady that answered the phone was nasty and didn’t even try to help me. She told me that I was responsible for the order and therefore I had to pay for it. I payed for the errant order but I swear to my dead ancestors they will NEVER get another dime from me. I’d rather die of starvation than give them my business ever again!
Philippe C.
Tu valoración: 2 Manhattan, NY
Long wait times(30 min for a single burger). I agree with other reviewers, the staff is not that friendly and helpful. If you really have to order something here, call at least 30 min before you pick up. I made a mistake walking in and ordering a burger. I was not informed the wait time would be so long I ordered a combo, the guy took the money and gave me a burger with fries then walked away. I had to remind him to give me things like soda(which is included in the combo), napkins or ketchup… The burger is just a very basic, dry burger. Fries… — please look at the picture
Jessica L.
Tu valoración: 2 Freehold Township, NJ
Three stars because i been coming here for over 10 years. This was my favorite place to eat as a child but it changed! So heres my review –Caesar salad. Amazing dressing but found a bug in our salad while eating so we stopped eating right away. Yuck –penne vodka. Its hard to mess up on this dish but it was bland and lacking flavor. To much sauce. Not enough pasta. It used to be better — stuffed artichoke. Looked better then it tasted. Very dry and tasted stale like it was 2 days old. Not sure whats going on with this place but they need to improve. Kind of expensive for three small dishes 35 $. They don’t even bring you your food anymore you have to get up and get it yourself.
Tito T.
Tu valoración: 5 Los Angeles, CA
I like this place they got some good pizza fresh italian bread and other nice dishes. They also got a pretty Italian chick working there shes always cool.
Alphonse B.
Tu valoración: 5 Brooklyn, NY
Brick oven !, if your looking for a great brick oven pizza look no further!. This place uses a real brick oven, not a pizza oven. And can you taste the difference ! La sorrentina is also connected with the Italian restaurant /steak house a few doors down, their fresh ordered pasta is great, I’ve had the pesto and fettuccine Alfredo with chicken and it hit the spot. They serve a variety of different items they cook fresh and display, if you like authentic Italian brooklyn cuisine and tired of the imitations, you won’t go wrong here.
Jason L.
Tu valoración: 4 Brooklyn, NY
One of the older restaurants/pizzerias around this neighborhood that is still standing from the influx of Asians in the area. I have been passing by this restaurant when I was just a kid. very happy to see that this is still here. I ordered from here about 2 weeks ago with their KILLER seamless deal. $ 20 for a large pie, 2 subs, and a 2-liter soda. Unfortunately, my soda was not delivered and when i called, they said that the deal no longer includes it. They offered to make things right, but I am not going to trouble them just to save $ 2. The pizza from the family deal was OK. It wasn’t anything to rave about, but it tasted fine to me. From what I remember, it was their brick oven white pizza that was really good. I haven’t had that in a few years, but I’ll never forget how delicious it was. Need to make a visit here again soon.
John I.
Tu valoración: 1 Brooklyn, NY
If you don’t mind waiting 2 hours for a crappie cold pizza pie that sucks order from here nene again!
Mike R.
Tu valoración: 5 ROCKAWAY PARK, NY
Wow, this is like the only true brick oven pizzeria left in this part of Brooklyn. The pies and rolls are great. Try the brick oven chicken roll!
Jorge G.
Tu valoración: 2 Brooklyn, NY
Nothing special. I like that the place is run by older Italian guys –I accept that this means ‘attitude’ and ‘scowls’ and lazy service. But I trust these guys to make pizza. Its who I want making pizza. Mind you, that’s not to say that I trust them to make good pizza. That’s expecting too much. This place cranks out the same generic, bland, tastes-exactly-the-same pizza that 80% of all the surrounding pizzerias do. But at least it’s old Italian guys making it. I had a slice of plain, round – off the counter – and it wasn’t good at all. It wasn’t bad either; it was just… forgettable. Uninspiring. No zing to the sauce; and the cheese was absolutely flavorless. Texture of thick shoe leather. What I want in pizza is the spark between slightly-sweet tomato sauce and salty cheese. That’s what it’s all about. Crust: the La Sorrentina crust demonstrates no special effort. No thought seems to have been put into this crust. It wasn’t thin. It wasn’t thick. It was boring. The interior of the restaurant seemed spacious and clean. Points for that. And maybe some of the other menu items are fabulous; I can’t judge. But I wouldn’t go out of my way to return here, myself. I wish them well with their business but for me to purchase pizza(I feel like I’ve eaten a million slices of bad pizza in my life) I have to be majorly excited and the slice I had here just didn’t do anything for me at all.
Chris S.
Tu valoración: 1 Brooklyn, NY
Have been going to this place for 4 years and so far they have been pretty good, not great, pretty good. Recently I noticed the pies have changed. The squares have become incredibly thick. All bread(very dry) with a small amount of sauce and cheese. Why did you change your squares!!! Was in there as a round pie was coming out of the oven for delivery and it was also way to thick. Now here’s the kicker… I ordered one of their roles to go(they have eggplant and chicken parm and sausage and peppers and so on) and when I was eating it at home realized there was a rubber band in the roll. I think I ate the first piece I bit off. Disgusting!!! A blue rubber band was baked into the roll! I’d give no stars if I could! I will never go back! What happened to you Sorrentina? I gave in and started going back because it’s convenient and the guy behind the counter tried to overcharge me(he’s done it before but I thought he made a mistake). I think he’s doing it on purpose. Menu said hero was $ 9. Written on bag was $ 9. He charged me $ 10. I think I’m done with this place. FYI. It’s a pizzeria and they started selling pre-packaged sushi. SUSHI !!! Don’t go there!
Mallisa A.
Tu valoración: 1 Brooklyn, NY
Ok let me start first of all they are over priced and make up there own prices as they go always a different price for same plate week by week, screw this place! There chicken Marsala use to be $ 12 went up to $ 18.50 plus tax within weeks!!! WTF!
Maria D.
Tu valoración: 4 Brooklyn, NY
White pizza is not as good as I’ve expected. But it’s tasty and from the brick oven for sure. There’s only one waiter. So you have to wait! There’s more Italian mood than taste. And many Italians from the 60th!
John M.
Tu valoración: 4 Seal Beach, CA
Solid pizza here. Since it’s so close to where I live, I used to come here quite often to get a slice of pizza or loaf of freshly baked bread. I love pizza. I used to order a whole pie or two every week from these guys. Recently the quality has been going down(last year or so) so I stopped eating pizza as much. I went back here last week and was happy to see the quality has indeed come back up.
Thomas M.
Tu valoración: 3 Brooklyn, NY
this place is a gamble. I order from here a couple of times a year and it’s either really good or really disappointing. price wise, it’s on par with any other pizza/italian place. very inconsistent.
Karol L.
Tu valoración: 4 Brooklyn, NY
Since I work around the area, I often order from La Sorrentina. Though I only order for take-out, their pizzas always comes HOT and tasty. There are many pizzerias around here and this place is one of my favorite spots to order from because they’re fast and their food is delicious! Whenever we have big gathering at work, we always order from La Sorrentina. So far so good! Definitely will continue to order from here :)
Franny A.
Tu valoración: 4 New York, NY
Round pizza rocks here. A classic slice of Brooklyn. The round is not Brick oven baked, but has the right combo of sauce, cheese, olive oil and a dark crispy crust that makes it a great«Bite of Brooklyn.» The square while looking good has less crisp to the crust, but is still a formidable slice. The round is where it’s at. It was pure coincidence being on 11th Ave. as we were taking a «short cut» to Bay Ridge when I spotted La Sorrentina which was recommended by fellow Unilocaler Stephen W.
Jessica N.
Tu valoración: 2 Brooklyn, NY
La Sorrentina — where you go when you have no other choice because it’s fast and close to work. Is it cheap? Not really. Is it good? It’s okay. The pizza is actually satisfying and enjoyable. The only thing is, I usually feel like I’m bothering the staff when I’m trying to order. It makes waiting for my Sicilian slice very uncomfortable as there are certain pizzaiolo there who just stand, stare and grimace. If you’re in the neighborhood and not enticed by the dozens of Chinese bakeries in the hood, stop in for a slice and run. At least they have orange soda. Fuhgeddaboudit.