With so many great Pizza options in the neighborhood, why Settle? I guess some of the out of towners think this is better than Ohio pizza or something but they haven’t walked down Knickerbocker, yet, i guess… because all 3 pizza places on Knickerbocker are far better. As a matter of fact, the other two pizza places on Myrtle are also better.
Ryan M.
Tu valoración: 2 Brooklyn, NY
I can’t believe some of the good things people are saying about this place. I lived across the street from this place for 2 years and have eaten everything on the menu. Pizza here is horrible. Only decent pizza item is the pepperoni roll, but ONLY if it has come out of the oven in the last 5 minutes. Chicken gyro is decent. Fettucini alfredo is good half the time. Sphagett and meatballs not good.
Thao L.
Tu valoración: 1 Brooklyn, NY
Even drunk this was by far the worst thing i have tasted in my life. Poem: We were drinking georgi vodka, Then we craved teh pizza, so we called Henry’s pizza. Bonsuela rang the door, to get the pizza. We paid 11 dollars, the pizza did not make us hollar. Nonetheless, we still finished the pizza. The end.
Ariel D.
Tu valoración: 4 Brooklyn, NY
Henry! I’ve never been to your spot & I actually don’t even know where it is, but I will say this: when I order a pie, be it Pepperoni or cheese, your always on time & you always get it right! Perfect Brooklyn style pizza!
Alexander M.
Tu valoración: 3 Brooklyn, NY
I ordered a large pepperoni pizza for delivery after reading the positive reviews here. Delivery took about half an hour and the staff seemed nice enough. Price was a little high for the neighborhood and the pizza was about average. The cheese and sauce has good flavor, but the crust was disappointingly hard and chewy.
Shannon H.
Tu valoración: 3 Brooklyn, NY
Just moved into the neighborhood — no furniture, utensils, anything — and wanted to get some pizza to enjoy on the floor. Henry’s was definitely fast, which honestly goes a long way in terms of taste in my book, but the price for a small pie(no topppings) was a little steep. The cheese was of that thick, gluttonous variety that reminds you how fattening pizza can be, not to mention the grease happily announcing itself on both the bottom and top of the box. A little bland, but the crust kept it afloat. I suppose that’s NY pizza though, and I live in NY now.
M P.
Tu valoración: 5 Brooklyn, NY
Delicious. The pizza has a unique taste. I can’t explain it. I always order a plain and Sicilian slice. I always think I will stop eating when I finish the Sicilian and save the plain slice for later, but I simply can’t. I have to eat the first slice. and it’s not because I’m not satisfied with the Sicilian is because the plain slice is simply irresistible, lol. The sauce has a unique sweet taste. and the cheese is simply delicious! I’ve tried the garlic knots and they’re pretty good as well. I’ve also tried the mozzarella sticks, which aren’t too bad — a little on the soggy side though, but not bad at all.
Christopher E.
Tu valoración: 4 Clinton Hill, NY
Must remember: never skip the hole in the wall place. Walked by several times and just assumed this was a typical pizza/chicken joint. Not quite. Full menu of Italian pasta dishes Really great pizza. The crust was divine. Unique variety of slices: chicken and brocolli, taco pizza, and standard pepperoni and cheese. Plus even a small personal pizza pie. Super great staff. And I second the above, those garlic knots look fantastic. Definitely my new go to neighborhood pizza joint.
