Extreme Pizza – Boise

Pizza tasted like «skyline chili», I had the
Caesar Salad, was good, plenty of dressing.
Only ok food.

Ordered delivery, expected pizzas to be delivered in 45 – 60, what was stated on eat24hours web site and was ok for me. They delivered it in 25 min. Pizza toppings were tasty!

Definitely a 3.
OUR ORDER
We ordered a half Yard Sale and half pepperoni pizza (they charge for the more expensive half, FYI), a dozen sweet BBQ boneless chicken wings, and the Thai salad. We ordered via eat24 for delivery at a hotel downtown.
It took about an hour for it to be delivered (estimated time was 45 – 60 min, which was right on). The pizza was hot, the wings were warm, and the salad was chilled, so all okay there.
THE PIZZA
The Yard Sale half (a bunch of veggies and meats) was tasty, even though the big tomatoes on top weren’t salted. The pepperoni half was disappointing. They bake the pepperoni under the cheese, which does not allow the pepperoni to get crisped and salty. And the sauce and pepperoni were scarce, just like other reviewers said they would be. The Yard Sale had so much going on, so we didn’t notice the sauce problem as much there.
THE WINGS
They were really like fat chicken nuggets. The breading was sort of steamed by the time it got to us, but there are browned marks on the bottom, so I’m sure they were pan-​cooked. It seems like they were probably frozen and just reheated. The sweet BBQ was a mildly sweet flavoring, rather than any observable sauce. (Unless they accidentally sent me plain?) I’m pretty sure they weren’t worth the $ 8 they cost, but they were plump, and it’s nice to get a hit of protein when you’re also eating pizza.
THE THAI SALAD
It was big, fresh, and worth eating BUT it wasn’t Thai like. For one, I’m pretty sure it was supposed to come with peanut sauce, and it came with ranch dressing. For two, its Thai features were merely a few pieces of canned mandarin oranges and some store-​bought wonton noodles (the extruded stick kind, not the tasty cut-​up wonton kind). But the lettuce was lovely, and the chicken was okay, and when can you say that about restaurant side salads? Almost never.
SERVICE
The manager on the phone and the delivery woman were both friendly. But I read on a Unilocal review that when Extreme Pizza delivered, it forgot to send napkins, plates, or utensils. So I called after I ordered online and made sure to ask for those things. The manager said, «Of course.» But when the delivery woman showed up, she didn’t have any of that and said she hadn’t even thought of it, forgot she was delivering to a hotel, and wasn’t told I’d especially called to ask for paper/​plastic ware. So that was a bummer.
All in all – acceptable in a pinch, but I’m not sure I’d order again unless I craved the Yard Sale.

The crust is pretty okay, and the garlic kmots aren’t bad, but the pizza overall was TERRIBLE!
The gorgonzola, walnut, rosemary pizza I ordered tasted faintly of rosemary and not at all of any of the other toppings. Do not be fooled by the enticing flavor combinations listed on the menu. They screwed up the execution so badly, it’s hard to imagine how they could have messed it up that badly without trying.

Good pizza, GREAT bread sticks (twists) and fast delivery. I’m quite pleased.

Not sure why Unilocal says its 4 stars. The crust was dry, cheese and sauce scarce, and got my order wrong.

Great pizza! It’s not super saucy and not over the top doughy. The crust is crunchy and the toppings are always fresh. Fast delivery and super friendly staff. This is my go to pizza place.

Great tasting pizza in Boise! Extreme Pizza is located right across the street from the stadium. I had the extreme twists and an 8″ pepperoni pizza. Both had great flavor and were made fresh to order.
It’s a little more expensive than your standard «Papa» or «Hut», but its well worth it IMO. Support your local Boise small businesses!

So when we drove past this place I was a little skeptical it looks like any old fast food joint shoved in a strip mall but I was proven completely wrong! The homemade crust and twists are excellent! We had the Yard sale pizza which has a little bit of everything and was excellent! Hands down some of the best pizza I have had. We also tried the traditional buffalo wings which were cooked perfectly and delicious. The prices also are reasonable and they run great deals and have a Unilocal deal when you check in! I know we have found a new staple when we are in Boise I just wished I lived closer because they also deliver!!!

Very good pizza with excellent flavors, even with the wheat crust! Most people definitely don’t get the wheat crust right and it usually ends up tasting like eating toppings on a sheet of cardboard. But these guys absolutely rocked it!
On top of the taste, delivery was fast and the food was all super hot still… which makes all the difference for a delivery meal. These guys really put the effort into everything, another thing you don’t see very often.
Overall, excellent job! I highly recommend some of their smoked bacon on anything on their menu! :)

Pretty good pie for a chain. Easy ordering and speedy delivery too.

Called extreme pizza after Flying Pie could not figure out how to get some pizza delivered to a park after a ten minute conversation. The lady on the phone was so accommodating. I asked to have 6 pizzas delivered to a park by a certain time and they were there 5 minutes early. I also asked to have 2 other pizzas ready to pick up at 6pm at there store. Those pizzas were hot and ready at 6pm on the dot. So the service is top notch. As far as the pizza goes it was very good as well. It’s not fast food/​Pizza Hut/​dominoes type pizza like a lot of the other reviews state. The pizza is very similar to a NY style thin crust pizza but the crust has more chew to. I will definitely try Extreme pizza again and really appreciate the great service and food!

Definitely some awesome pizza. I definitely have my favorites: drag it through the garden, chicken bbq w/​cilantro, railroad Grande. You can’t really go wrong with what you order. Their breadsticks are just as amazing. They’re very soft, cheesy and filled with the right amount of garlic.

Excellent pizza and salads! They are super careful with the gluten free toppings! We will be back!

YUM!!! Whether dining in or having it delivered to our home, across town, in West Boise, the food has always been great – hot and ready to eat. We have had several different menu items and enjoyed them all… calzones, pizza, salad, sandwiches and desserts. The staff is very friendly; we’ve had a very pleasant experience all around.

Really good pizza. Good crust, fresh toppings… pretty good. Ordered the Hanoi Fever, pretty good, would add tomatoes if I could do it over.
Only negative. It took an hour 15 for delivery… pizza was still really hot though. 3.75 out of 5

My husband and I live nearby extreme pizza and after driving by countless times we decided to stop in and try it out. It was one of the best pizza places we have ever gone to. They have all the traditional types of pizza but they also have some great unique combinations. The staff were very friendly and the service was pretty quick. They also had TVs playing that we could watch while we were waiting. We will definitely be going back again sometime.

So glad I tried this. My new favorite place for delivery pizza. Everything I ordered was quite tasty. Its not gourmet but if you are looking for something a little fresh and different try them out!

Very good. A little pricey but worth it. Super FRESH ingredients. Finally pizza and a salad that u can enjoy and not feel NASTY after eating. no greesey grossness. just fresh snd DELISH

Very easy to order online and they deliver… Both huge +‘s for me. We were hungry, tired, and staying at a local hotel looking to try some of the local flare. The prices were reasonable and surprisingly it was delivered hot. The salad was fresh and absolutely yummy for a take out. They forgot to deliver any cutlery so make sure to ask for silverware (especially for the salad), napkins, and plates if you need them.
We loved that you could do a «half and half» specialty pizza. We got half Paia Pie (+mushrooms) and half Yard Sale. The Paia was average but The Yard Sale was dynamite… We devoured it. It’s a thin crust pizza style. The «extremely twisted bread» sticks were mediocre but the «Back Country Betty» salad was delicious, especially for a take out salad. Usually take out salads aren’t that great but it was fresh, good sized, and tasty.

Avoid.
Ordered a vegetable calzone and a salad and it came to a little over $ 15 (the driver actually asked me if I wanted change from a $ 20 — oh, sure, please keep $ 5 for not remembering my fork or paper plate).
The food was boring and plain. I would never, ever in a million years order from this place again. Boise must have low standards when it comes to pizza because I was super disappointed.
Expensive and bland and they forget important stuff that you need to eat with and then when you call them, they tell you to go down to the hotel lobby and see if you can find some there. Oh, no you didn’t. Not impressed. Pass by, quickly. Or, if you’ve never eaten NY pizza, or Pizza Hut, you might enjoy it.
AVOID.