Whilst a bit rougher round the edges than its conterpart on Broughton Street this is nonetheless a good city centre pub suitable for those who like a decent pint, possibly with a pie, some sport on the tv and a low level of background noise so as to be able to chat without experiencing the Lombard reflex. They also nowadays have a selection of books above the fireplace that you can take from and/or add to if reading’s your thing.
Chris G.
Tu valoración: 2 Edinburgh, United Kingdom
I went to Mathers West End tonight to watch the US game. We scored in the first minute and the four of us Americans who showed up cheered happily. Unfortunately, the bar regulars did not take kindly to that and made their displeasure known, repeatedly, throughout the rest of the first half(we quickly left at half-time). I am a recent expat to Edinburgh, but I have never felt more out of place, nor have I ever had to deal with ANYONE being hostile toward Americans. People in this great city are usually so welcoming to the yanks. Unfortunately the surly barmaids did nothing but comfort the poor natives who had to watch 4 Americans enjoy their team’s goal in the World Cup. Please take down the American flag and don’t tell anyone else to come to this bar for USA games, I don’t want visitors to think this bar represents this wonderful city.
Clarence J.
Tu valoración: 3 Alexandria, VA
Mathers is a small bar with an excellent hole-in-the-wall, ‘local’ feel, including friendly, knowledgeable staff who make everyone feel welcome. The only concern I had was that no one seemed to be eating there; this concerned my friends enough — based on the amount of time we were there and the number of locals who came through — that we went elsewhere for the meal without checking on a menu. That’s somewhat of an unfair comment since we didn’t ask, but I wanted to mention it because it seemed strange to us that evening. I would definitely return at least for drinks again though!
Steph T.
Tu valoración: 4 North Lanarkshire, United Kingdom
I knew I recognised the Mathers name as I have already visited the one on Broughton Street, so I was keen to try this one out for a cheeky afternoon drink or two. It is actually rather nice inside, very clean and plenty of seating. It is what you would class as a traditional pub, so there were plenty of older people and a few tourists inside, but I still managed to get a table. I had a Gin and Tonic, served to me by a lovely friendly lady who called me ‘darling’ which I found rather sweet, in a sort of over familiar way. She was very helpful when I asked her where the nearest train station was, and she seemed to want to chat to me for ages! A lovely pub, much less rowdy than it’s Broughton Street counterpart.
Emma C.
Tu valoración: 3 Edinburgh, United Kingdom
This is the second of two Mathers pubs in Edinburgh, although as this one is in the West End I would say it’s probably the slightly classier one(take that description with a pinch of salt, this is definitely not a ‘classy’ pub). There is a well stocked bar with a good selection of malts and ales that won’t cost you an arm and a leg. The pub has a few tables dotted about, but most of the clientele stand(perhaps sitting is for wimps and girls?). Mathers is perfect If you’re looking for a traditional, no frills pub — just remember to leave your pretensions at the door.
Derek M.
Tu valoración: 4 Edinburgh, United Kingdom
This is the larger Mathers bar which is in a very good position near town centre. Drinks are cheap with good selection of beers. Mainly locals but worth a visit due to it being cheap.
Evarin
Tu valoración: 3 Edinburgh, United Kingdom
Mathers is a small bar at the west end of Edinburgh. It is geared like a locals bar but in the centre of town. The drinks are quite cheap for the centre of town and they have a wide range of drinks. The staff are really knowledgeable about the city and good at their jobs. The only downside to this place I would say is that it is a bit old — mannish and you can get a few stares as a young woman going in but hey maybe some people like that!
Origin
Tu valoración: 1 Edinburgh, United Kingdom
Good selection of real ale, definately not a young person’s pub. Traditional pub, décor and clientele. Busy pub but no real atmosphere. perfect if you drink real ale and looking to have quiet pint. Unfortunately still smells badly of stale smoke despite smoking ban being in place for a while