All American Pizza

Favorite pizza place. Great pizza with a fabulous price. I love the supreme calzone and my boys favorite is the bacon cheeseburger. Everything we’ve had so far has been fast and delicious.

What a surprise. I was delighted with the pizza quality at such a low price. I was thinking how are you staying in business with such low pricing. But then I realized it must be repeat business. Great job mr. Owner.

Great prices pizza with good taste and very nice staff. Only Hong I can say wrong was the crust was a little doughy.

TL;DR: decent pizza, decent prices, but logically challenged to the point of customer service being annoying to say the least and their website is seriously lacking in even basics like ACTUAL specials they are running.
First off, every time I’ve eaten All American Pizza the pizza has satisfied. It’s not OH GOD AMAZING, but it’s good. No major complaints, though the crust is a little simple (still good, and I eat it, but my wife piles the «pizza bones» up as garbage-​fodder).
The cheese is adequate and the toppings taste like the toppings they are. Oddly the toppings are hit and miss with being excessive or being skimpy. Example: the hawaiian tends to have a buttload of pineapple but my wife complains she has to dig and search to find any canadian bacon. On our Pepperoni and mushroom there were probably 2 – 3 slices of pepperoni per slice, but the mushrooms were tiny and sprinkled about randomly.
Sauce is forgettable but does the job.
The prices are not terrible. For $ 17 I was able to walk out with two larges and feed my family of 3 twice. (even if one of those family members is a 4yr old girl).
The ambiance of this store is sketchy. I don’t feel unsafe or that the food will have roaches or anything, but I would NEVER take a hot date to the store itself. It’s more of a bare-​bones waiting room for your pizza.
WHY ONLY 2 STARS THOUGH?
The first time I went to the Yukon All American Pizza I noticed they had a large 1 topping pizza for $ 6, and a large «specialty» pizza for $ 8.
I asked the cashier how big their pizzas were (having never been there before) and she replied «I don’t know.» Didn’t offer to show me, or bring me a box to compare, or venture a guess, or call a cook/​manager over to help.
I asked how big their large vs small salads were, again, no clue, no help, no box, no anything. Not wanting to make a huge scene and just wanting to try their food I gave up and ordered.
So, I order a large Pepperoni ($ 6) plus mushrooms ($ 1) and a Hawaiian ($ 8). Then it dawns on me, a canadian bacon pizza would be $ 6 + $ 1 for pineapple… So their Hawaiian SHOULD be a $ 7, but because it’s «specialty» it’s a dollar more.
What’s worse is: everything is done by hand and they refused to change the deal because «it is what it is.»
So I tried again yesturday to get pizza because it was decent and the prices weren’t awful. This time I check online, see their site is completely unchanged since last time, only special is 1 topping for $ 6 and specialty for $ 8.
I order a Pepperoni and mushroom and a Hawaiian, not even bothering trying to explain how stupid their $ 1 upcharge for being listed as a specialty is. I’m quoted a big shy of $ 17. Whatever, sounds about right on my way home from work.
I get to the store and see a «family special» or something, 1 large 1 topping, 1 large specialty, 1 2-​liter coke-​product: $ 13.99… So I turn to the cashier and I ask why that wasn’t posted on their website, and she seems oblivious to the fact that their website hasn’t been updated in at least a month. So I ask «well, I ordered a specialty (which I asked for half to be just cheese for my daughter) and a 2 topping, could I just make it that deal $ 1 for adding an extra topping to the pepperoni?»
«Nope, we can’t do that. Sorry.» She ends up apologizing to me like 12 times all while refusing to barely alter the ticket. I mean, it would literally be ordering the same pizzas I ordered, tossing in a 2-​liter of coke, starting me at the $ 14 price point and up-​charging a buck to $ 15+tax. Instead they couldn’t do that and make a customer happy while honoring a special they were running (without posting it on their website or mentioning it over the phone when they took my order), all because my $ 15 + tax order didn’t include a drink. So they would be out a whole 2-​liter of coke to save face and make me happy.
Again: They «can’t do that» to allow me to get the special they are currently running me, which wouldn’t change the price they’re charging me at all, all because it would give a free 2-​liter away and make me happy.
After that and the ignorance behind charging $ 8 for a 2-​topping «specialty» pizza when a 2 topping would cost $ 7 according to their own prices, I’m just disillusioned by this Oklahoma-​born pizza place. I don’t expect perfection always, but I feel like whoever is in charge of these rules is intellectually challenged and needs to take basic middle-​school math, or maybe Algebra.

This is the absolute best pizza anywhere!!! My favorite! Quality ingredients and a great value! It is always hot, delicious and quick! The best!!!

This is the best take out pizza we’ve found so far in OKC. It is really cheap so I was worried at first that it wouldn’t be good but it’s delicious. I’ve ordered from here three or four times and it always tastes great. The staff isn’t friendly on the phone but they are in the store when I pick up the order. I’m so glad this amazing pizza is right by our apartment!

Excellent pizza value. I love the thin crust style pizza with all meat or the chicken bacon ranch. I recommend the hot wings to go with your order. The calzone is very good as well. Did I mention great value? Prices are cheaper than most, but in this case you don’t get a cheap pizza. They don’t deliver, but it is worth picking up.

Delicious pizza for an awesome prices. Great for a quick pizza run waiting, no more than 15 min. I recommend the meat lovers! Enjoy

I love their pizza. Great prices, fast, and taste amazing. I highly recommend their Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza.

I love the pizza here. Very great price and way better than Pizza Hut, Papa Johns, Dominios, etc.

I just moved here from out of state, desperate to find a good pizza place. From the reviews, I chose this place. I ordered over the phone. 2 lg pizzas and wings. ½ plain ½ buffalo. No prob. Hubby went to pick it up. Got home, 2 lg pizzas were completely wrong, and the wings were all buffalo. I called them back, now I was told they don’t carry plain wings. :/​umm. Ok. So I had to keep the wings, bring the other 2 pizzas back, get the correct ones. Never got money back, plus we overpaid bc the 2 wrong pizzas were more expensive than what I originally ordered. Wings were cold by the time we got to eat. The pizza was wicked gross. And all 3 of us got sick after eating their food. Extremely disappointed, never going back there again.

Ordered pizza over the phone… Was ready in 15 minutes. Website says the place is closed on Mondays but I called and they were opened. One middle aged man making the food and young kids taking orders and working the front counter. The younger ones assume you’ve been there before I guess. I ordered a side of ranch and when I asked where it was she responded with «it’s over there in the fridge» I asked «so do I get it?» Her response «I mean… it’s whatever.» A little odd but «it’s whatever». Other than that it’s all really good.

I am also from philly, I haven’t had a good experience in okc. That is, until I tried the calzone and chicken Alfredo from this place… Best pizza I’ve had in Oklahoma! Dominoes can suck it!

Pizza was delicious! Very good price too. But the website listed is not correct. They did not have fried mushrooms. We only asked for those but who knows what else they didn’t have. I would definitely recommend the pizza though.

This is not a bad little pizza shack in great city of Yukon, OK. They have really good deals on their pies and are typically pretty quick about getting your order out to you. The reason I gave them 3 stars instead of 4 was because of an order that I put in a while back took about 4 times the amount of time that they had told me, so I had to wait there forever to get my pizza. I don’t know what the issue was, but they kept telling me it would only be like 5 more minutes and about 30 – 40 minutes later, I finally got my pizza.
I still decided to head back to this location, and every trip since has been a good experience. I guess they just had some kinks that they had to get worked out or something. I want to say that they typically have a large specialty pizza on sale for pretty cheap. My wife loves the Hawaiian pie, but I’ve been pretty happy with everything that I’ve tasted.
If you like cheap pizza, this place isn’t bad and I’d suggest it to my friends! If you are in Yukon, and have an achy breaky heart for some cheap pie, this is your spot!

Great taste and even better prices. Really enjoy the all meat pizza and calzone. Cheese sticks are a favorite with the wife and son too.

This is one of my favorite local take out pizza places in the metro. I had no idea they had a store in Yukon, so I got lucky. Their pizza is great and cheap! Only $ 6.99 for a large and it’s wayyyy better than Little Caesar’s if you’re looking for cheap. The only thing I feel that is missing from All American is spinach as a topping choice. They have a great chicken alfredo pizza and if they had spinach to add to that, I’d be giving them 5 stars!

This pizza is awesome. Plenty of toppings and they have big pieces of tomatoes, my favorite! The only complaint is that they use canned mushrooms instead of fresh.

This place just opened up recently and they have the best pizza I’ve had in Oklahoma so far (I’m from Philly so I’m a pizza connoisseur).
Very greasy, very good. And it’s dirt cheap! It’s like $ 6 for a large one-​topping pizza. I think it’s like 13 – 14 inches so it’s not the largest large I’ve seen, but it’ll easily feed one and maybe two if you’re a little less hungry than I usually am. $ 5 for a medium and $ 4 for a small one-​topping. Well worth the price.
Beat that Dominoes.
Not really anywhere to eat inside, so expect to take out. There’s also an All American Pizza in Mustang and 2 more locations. The one in Yukon is closed on Sundays but there’s another location like 10 minutes south on Mustang Rd.