The Dory Trading Post

Youngstown pride! This little boutique encompasses passion for the village with local artist-​made knick knacks. Everything from little boats carved out of wood with seashells on them to cute little Youngstown-​themed stationary cards and bumper stickers. It gets a five from me because it’s really quite a pleasure to browse around in and the prices are very reasonable.
My wife loves sea-​themed anything, so I bought a framed picture of a seashell for her as well as a little stone with hand carvings of sea-​things. The woman (Jane, who is also one of the owners) behind the counter was very helpful in helping me find these things and wrapped them up like a pro.
If you’re gift shopping, especially for someone who has some sort of connection to Youngstown, I don’t think there is a better place to go. It’s open year round too.