Jimmy John’s

Very disappointed. Ordered Gourmet Subs from their Catering Menu for some special visitors — total of 20 people — for the first time. If you get just a single sandwich, it’s huge and worth the money,. If you get from the Catering Menu they are disappointing — hardly any meat. Everyone agreed, we will not order sandwiches from Jimmy Johns when we need lunch catered.

I’ve never been a fan of Jimmy John’s. Quite frankly theirs is the least favorite sub shop of mine and I have a sub pretty much every single day for lunch. Sometimes however, I am forced to order from JJ because other options are not feasible for me.
You would think businesses would at least have their core day to day operations pretty down pat, but this JJ proves this is not always the case. I had to repeat what I wanted to order 4 times on the phone because apparently a turkey sandwich without tomatoes is too hard to comprehend. I literally thought I heard the girl’s head explode when I mentioned «NO» tomatoes.
Anyway, after too much back and forth we finally got the order correct, so I thought. When it arrived the driver forgot my chips and drink. No big deal I guess since they were only around the corner, but don’t advertise that you have extremely fast delivery if you can’t get it correct the first time. It doesn’t count as fast if you «COME BACK» fast the second time after messing up the order.
When the driver gets back with the chips they are not even the ones I ordered (Go figure). At this point I just want some sort of nutrients because I am starving only to open up the package and see what is just a poor excuse for a sandwich. Not cut, sloppy condiments and weak on the meat.
Need less to say I won’t be ordering from JJ ever again, no matter how hungry, desperate or out of other options I am. I work hard for my money, I’d like to give it to businesses that do the same!

Well, unfortunately I can’t really describe the food, as after placing my order and waiting 30 minutes it hadn’t shown up. I called back and after 15 minutes of them trying to «find my order», not my food mind you, my «order», they finally informed me that 2 miles was outside their delivery range and they would not be able to deliver. This is after taking my order AND charging my card, which they said they would be happy to refund but will take up to 10 business days. Just stay away from this place, incredibly unprofessional. If you live close enough, just order subs from Roma’s in Red Lion (
).

Jimmy John’s fills a much needed niche in the casual food world. Very often, I’d like a *REAL* sub (not Subway or other fraud) but anything that qualifies is just too darn big. Jimmy John’s is right on the money– delectable, high-​quality Italian deli products in the perfect compact size– not too big, not too small at a good price. As an added bonus, they really are «scary» fast. On at least one occasion, our two subs were wrapped and ready *before* we finished ordering! I know that sounds impossible.
I think if you’re looking for that giant, over-​stuffed hoagie, you might come away disappointed. If you think in terms of — good ingredients, great flavor in a well constructed sub, sized just big enough to hit the spot for a good price, you’ll leave smiling

I ordered from here and it took 30 minutes to get it even though I was only 2 miles away. My wife ordered a Beach Club cut and it had no turkey on it and wasn’t cut. I called to complain and was told the manager told the employee on the phone that there was nothing they can do but give me a free sub card. I live no where near a Jimmy Johns as I was visiting my sister in York. This is horrible customer service and even worse for a place such as this. The other location in York is on point. Avoid this slow, rude location.

⁴⁄₅ on this one because its been 3 times now i’ve ordered and its taken them more than 30 min to get to my house. I Love this plce largely because of the «Freaky Fast» delivery.

They refused to deliver to me even though I am located 1.6 miles from them. They said they don’t go that far. Unprofessional, unaccomodating, unfriendly.

First time coming to this place. Ordered online. Wanted a giant Italian hoagie. Got a small one for the same price as the big one. Staff doesn’t have your best interest in mind. Don’t want to work. Avoid.

Great food and fast service! Love the subs! Staff is friendly and curteous.

Clean and very fast. If you are in a hurry, this is a great option. The Vito (Italian) is great, be sure to ask for «hots» (hot peppers if you enjoy a little heat).

I’m not normally a huge fan of these types of sub shops. However this was pretty good and I’ll definately be back again. Mary got the #1 a Ham & Prolalone with the works and I got the #10 a Roast Beef sub. These were the perfect size and the rolls really make the sandwich. Only issue I have is we ordered the giant pickle but never got it and I had to ask for my recipe back.

I would just as soon go to Subway; The food is good, but for the price there are better options.
Since you are in the area, cut through the Lowes parking lot and go to Taste of Italy.

A bit too much mayo and not quite enough of everything else.

NEVER EVER EVER!
This over priced sub shop is a ripoff! NO MEAT ON SUB! I felt like I was eating a sub roll with a few vegetables on it! I also asked for xtra onion and xtra tomatoes and there were barrely either on it!!! NEVER AGAIN!
I ALSO CONTACTED CUSTOMER SERVICE ON NUMEROUS OCCASIONS AND LEFT MY NAME, PHONE NUMBER AND EMAIL AND WAS TOLD THE STORE OWNER OR MGR WOULD CONTACT ME AND RECTIFY THIS IMMEDIATELY… NEVER HEARD A WORD!
IF YOU LIKE TO GET A SUB WITH A FEW PAPER THIN SLICES OF MEAT THEN THIS IS YOUR PLACE!

Big fan of Jimmy Johns!
1. They deliver
2. They have breadless sandwiches (lettuce wraps called the unwich)
3. Giant pickles
4. Really good Italian called the Vito
5. Not too expensive

Went to JJs based on Unilocal reviews and I wasn’t disappointed. I got the #9 Italian and it was excellent! The meats were perfect and the whole sub kinda just melted in your mouth… I love my subs and sammy’s so I will def. be bk here again.
Service…well, I had my sub before I was even finished paying for it… now THAT’S service!
Thanks fellow Unilocalers, you didn’t let me down!

Today I finally broke down as the last person in the office to order from Jimmy Johns.
The size of the pickle they gave me was fantastic. A BIG ASS PICKLE.
My sandwich (Totally Tuna with cheese) was ok. The lettuce tasted weird and the tuna was very salty. Not really impressed.
The delivery was very quick and ordering was easy.
I cant say that these sandwiches are gourmet or even great, but they filled my stomach with food. Meh.

As soon as I bit into my Italian sub, I declared it the best sub I had ever had. It was amazing and puts Subway to shame.
I am very excited that they are putting another location in on S. Queen St.

Great sandwiches!
i lived out in the midwest when JJ’s came to town and I was instantly a fan of the franchise. When I moved away I truly missed the fresh bread and super fast service. When I saw that a JJ’s was coming to York I couldn’t have been more excited. My expectations were high and this location did not disappoint!
All sandwiches are made to order and they do them FAST. As soon as you order about 10 seconds later your sandwich is being delivered to your hand! I now stop here about every two weeks to get me a good sub. I love it way more than Subway. Its got that «Hoagie» feel to every sandwich with the fresh french bread that they use.
The only thing that is bad, is that they don’t have one closer to my home so that they can deliver it right to my door! Maybe one day as this catches on and they start to expand a bit in PA.

I was anticipating the arrival of Jimmy John’s when I saw the sign in the window since I am not a real fan of Subway or Quizno’s. I decided to stop in for some sandwiches for us to go after I realized they don’t deliver to Manchester on their website.
I was greeted by a friendly cashier who looked like she was learning the ropes and a line of busy sandwich makers. The store was well lit, clean and had some modern rock playing. I asked about delivery and they showed me the map which was nice. I got my food really quickly as promised and drove home. The food was according to order except the cucumber was missing from my wife’s Beach club. I loved the Italian Night club — it was fresh and the bread was great. The flavor of the meat was slightly spiced and there was plenty of it. I got it with mayo which was not overboard and the tomato was juicy. I will definitely be back and the convenience of online ordering ahead of time is great — you can choose to pick up your subs when you want to.
Another option they offer is catering, not something I have a need for usually, but nice to know you can get it. I hope to try the JJ Gargantuan some time– a really big sub and the jalapeño chips were spicey but not hot –crunchy and tasty. I am a fan of Jimmy John’s so far — I will re-​review for sure after they are open for a little while.