Which Wich

When my school had a fundraiser here, I decided to try Which Wich. It was very good! Really good shakes, subs, and service!

I always forget about Which Wich because it is stuffed on one of the side roads in Mayfaire. It is a great place for a quick lunch or dinner and the service is always very fast with friendly employees. The selection is large, even more so than most sandwich shops. It can be confusing to order during the first trip or two, but after that you get the hang of it and it’s not a problem.

Awesome kind funny friendly service always with a smile sandwiches always taste so fresh n delicious n always make me a happy customer… great food great ingredients n great staff

This place has the neatest ordering system ever. It’s fool proof! Upon entering, you walk over to a counter which has several paper bag ordering forms. You choose the bag that best fits what kind of sandwich you want and fill it out with any condiments, toppings, cheeses, and meats. You are also given the choice of white or wheat bread, hot or cold, as well as an option to «skinny your wich» which gets you a thinner bread, but allows for more meat and toppings. You then proceed to give your bag to the cashier who passes it down the line. You watch them as they make your sub, but they refer to your bag to see how you want your sub fixed and there is no communication until they call your name (which you also write on the bag) to let you know that your sandwich is ready. The sandwich is wrapped in foil and paper before being placed back in the bag that you filled out and handed to the cashier. The best part about the bag ordering system is that you have proof of how you ordered your sandwich and if there is a mistake then they can see that it was their mistake. Make sure to add the house chips to your sub. I thought that was weird at first, but it adds a nice crunch!

Today I went to Which Which for lunch. I ordered a hot chicken parm with spinach. There were 6 people working and not a single other customer in the place. No one started making my sandwich until I had already gotten my drink (self-​serve) and stood by the counter looking like I was lost. They looked at me as confused as I was, as if I couldn’t have been expecting the sandwich I just paid for. Then a lightbulb went on in one girls head and she jumped into making my sandwich. I ordered it hot, the bread was toasted but everything in it was cold. Then there’s the picture… One side all chicken, the other side all spinach… I loved Which Which in Raleigh but I’m sad to say I won’t be visiting this location again. Overall the taste by itself was fine and the guy wiping off tables was very friendly. I just hate paying for food I don’t enjoy.

stopped by while exploring Mayfair with my sister and was kinda blown away with how big this Which Wich is compared to the ones in Raleigh! There was plenty of space to sit and everywhere was very clean. Food was the normal Which Wich fare, though I noticed that their chip selection was severly limited for some reason.
All in all i’d definately be back! Great addition to this outdoor mall!

If your in a rush and need something good, which witch is your place then. Many of sandwiches to choose from and tons of great toppings. Staff is friendly and outgoing. Looking forward to the next already.

First time there! We loved it. Tastes great and speedy service! The ordering system is cool too ! My kids even loved it ! Outside seating is a plus !! The club was outstanding ! We will be back

I’ve been here many times, each time is consistently great! From the bbq to the hula (which I just got), the grinder, you can’t go wrong with anything. The staff are also very attentive, friendly and knowledgeable. Which wich is awesome!

Pretty consistently good food. I got the egg salad and it was swimming in mayo. I was disappointed with this. But otherwise it is great food.

I have been to this @WhichWich once after going to the movies. The service was good, and the food was fast and fresh. Plus they have tables outside where you can sit and enjoy the sun, which is nice. Unlike some of the other Which Wich locations, they don’t give you a cookie, or other benefit when you check in with your Unilocal app. I wish they did. I might visit more.
#293

Very nice sandwich place if you want a quick bite. Like the variety of items and that you can have your sandwich served hot. Bread is decent which is unusual for anyplace I have been outside of New York. Cost me $ 43 for 4 adults and 2 kids.

The way you order here is something new but after one time it makes since and is pretty self explanatory. The quality of the food is good. They have lots of options and you can customize your wich to the perfection of your choosing. It’s very casual and chill inside with bright yellow walls and smiley faces. A good sandwich expirence.

Best sandwiches in Wilmington Mayfaire area. Normally eat here twice a month or more. The one time they messed up my order they gave me the correct sandwich let me keep the mistake and topped it off with free cookies. Great service staff.

I’ve always liked this place. I got hooked since I’m from SD, and was happy when I found this on in Wilmington. Sandwich was good. I gave 4 instead of 5 stars because the guys that work there were fighting over who had to make my sandwich. I’m sure they were joking around, but it was rather unprofessional of them. It didn’t make me feel very excited to hand over my hard earned money and hope they can decide who will finally get around to making my food.

Best sandwich option in the Mayfaire/​Landfall/​Wrightsville Beach area. I visit this location with my family on a regular basis; I am a big fan of the of Chicken Pesto and my kids enjoy the shakes. Friendly staff as well.

This place is great. Many toppings and options to choose from– it’s impossible to not find something you like. Also any sandwich as a salad– Whaaaaat? :)

Eh, it was ok. Unlike the others who wrote negative reviews about the ordering system I have to say I sort of like it. It allowed me to not feel rushed to choose what I really wanted.
With that said, what I ordered was nothing spectacular. I mean it was an average sandwich on processed bread.
The idea of the milkshake really caught my eye. Although after spending $ 3 for a small I wish I hadn’t. The best way to describe it, is a frozen serving of ensure/​boost with sprinkles of Oreo cookies. Nothing milk like about it. Very weird chalky and medicine like texture/​taste.

I would give Which Wich 5 stars if they didn’t have a ridiculous ordering system. Definitely threw us off upon arrival. Everyone was huddling over this little table marking down their orders with red sharpies and making it feel really disorganized.
Also, the seating here? Blughhhhhhh. We sat on a high-​top table that had two stools making it impossible for me to put my purse anywhere but my lap or the floor.
Even though I marked everything down that I wanted, they somehow managed to get my order wrong? There was a few ingredients missing from my sub. Pickles and Spinach I believe.
With that being said, my sub was pretty yummy and the staff was really great. I got the black bean burger on wheat with an Oreo cookie milkshake. Really hit the spot! My veggies tasted fresh and the milkshake was really yum.
I wouldn’t say this is my favorite sub spot in Wilmington, Jersey Mikes still has the #1 spot in my heart but we will definitely be coming back here.

I visited Which Wich on the second day they were open. We arrived right at noon, and the line was nearly out the door. There was a friendly staff member, Mallory, who greeted us at the door and gave us the rundown on how the place works. I had never been to a Which Wich before, so I appreciated the information.
Even though they were newly open and extremely busy, the staff worked efficiently, we had our sandwiches in about 5 minutes and dug in. The Italian grinder was excellent; I recommend pairing it with their «spicy pepper mix», which was, essentially, giardeniera. My wife enjoyed her meatball sub as well. I tried their «house chips» which were just ruffled chips with salt and pepper.
In short, Which Wich is a great option for sandwiches. I vastly prefer it to Subway, and I even give it an edge over Jersey Mike’s. For a chain, it is pretty darn good.