Buggy Shop Bakery

Excellent bakery, a great hidden jewel in Warsaw. Blink and you’d miss it, but look for the small sign with the buggy logo on it, next to Reneker’s Sport. This in not an Amish bakery per se, but the recipes are inspired by the husband and wife owners’ family recipes. The owners are very friendly, personable people. They sell a variety of items including dinner rolls, garlic cheddar cheese bread, sweet sticky cinnamon rolls, brownies, cookies, whoopie pies, jellies, jams, peanut butter spread, and apple butter,. They also offer a variety of pies including pecan, blueberry, apple, cherry, cream pies. My favorites are the «Can’t Leave Alone Bars» (mixture of brownie and yellow cake — a small tray $ 4.50), strawberry cream pie ($ 10ish), and their red velvet whoopie pies ($ 6ish). They also have a stand at the Kosciusko Farmer’s Market.