Tosco’s Pizzeria

Great pizza by the slice or whole pie. Have eaten in the dining room and taken out. Great unusual pizzas like ones with balsamic on them. Nice folks working there. A great place to have so close by.

We ordered the fried chicken and it was the worst we ever had first off it was over cooked and the batter was sweet. Stick with the pizza it’s your best bet.

Great pizza and food. Very friendly and accommodating service. Newly expanded with a dining room, finally! Best pizza in wallkill.

This is one location of three restaurants run by Tosco’s. I occasionally order here with large groups of people. Every time we order, there are problems. Either the delivery doesn’t arrive until 1 ½ hours after the time the order was placed, or the order is wrong. Most times that I order something here, my order is wrong. The delivery people are good — they will bring the order back to the restaurant and eventually deliver the correct order… but this is time consuming while people are waiting for their food — especially when it’s a normal occurrence. It is very rare for Tosco’s to deliver the order in a timely manner and for the order to be correct. The stars have to line up perfectly for everything to be good — receiving the food in a timely manner and the order being accurate. Even then, the food often tastes like cardboard. Many of the foods taste like its been previously cooked and reheated and the fries are usually soggy.
Their pizza is usually pretty good — but again, unless you order a plain pie, expect your order to be wrong. And it takes forever to have it delivered. Their baked ziti dinners are usually pretty good also — when they can figure out how to get the order correct. If you order it without cheese, it comes with meat sauce. If you order it with meat sauce, it comes without cheese.
They have a very difficult time getting orders straight and delivering the food in less than 1 hour.