Magic Bagels

Stopped in on the way home for some «mini» bagels. Pleasantly surprised at the variety of bagels, baked goods, salads and cream cheese spreads in this small shop. Very helpful staff even cut my 2 dozen (26) mini (biggest minis I ever saw!) bagels and gave me a sample of their lox cream cheese while I waited. Yummy! Don’t miss the case of baked goods by the register. Apple turnover was like the good old days! Definitely worth another visit!

Has the greatest bagels in Valley Stream. They’re even better when they’re just coming out and they’re warm. The amount of butter/​cream cheese that you get will depend on the person. Some barley out any while some slap on a ton. At least that’s why there’s napkins provided.

I have been coming here since I was kid… Best bagels hands down… always fresh chewy crispy. The best enough said.

I used to live in central Queens and was fiercely loyal to one bagel shop out there. When I moved to Valley Stream, I didn’t think I would find a bagel shop so close to my house that was just as good (if not better) than my previous favorite bagel spot in Queens. Magic Bagels was a pleasant surprise and one of the reasons why I love calling Valley Stream my new home!
warning: cash only!

Super disappointed in this bagel shop. I’ve been to plenty of bagel shops in New York and although some are better than others, I haven’t had a bad one. Maybe because I had high expectation of this place based on the reviews but I was very disappointed. I was way too far before I realized my bagel order was wrong. I came here today and I ordered a French toast bagel with walnut cream cheese. I asked the woman helping me what flavored ice coffee they had. She said we have too many flavors. I just looked at her. She did not name one. Not one. Then she told me to go to the other side of the store and there is a list. I go look at the list and there is 7 flavors!!! She couldn’t name one??? I opted for the cupcake ice coffee with cream and sugar. While driving away I unwrap my bagel and realized I got a French toast bagel with REGULAR cream cheese. The bagel is sooooo tiny. The bagel did not even taste like French toast, it tasted burnt! No where in the iced coffee did I taste cupcake. Not even cream. Not even sugar. Just coffee and milk.

Magic Bagel is a nice place to sit and have a cup of coffee and a toasted bagel. They know how to toast a bagel. Not too dark, not too light.

Great customer service, the staff is really friendly and helpful. But twice now I went and the bagel dough was sticky inside like still a little raw. This has been 2 different months even. May try once more but was a waste of dozen bagels again.

best bagels around. even better than some of «the best» I’ve had in brooklyn. been coming here forever.

Positive: the everything bagel and whole wheat bagel are one of the best around. Get them toasted with cream cheese or butter. Add a snapple iced tea to make it complete.
Negative: cash only

Everything is Amazing. Great assortment of great tasting cream cheese and bagels! I’ve tried other bagel places in the area and Magic Bagels takes the win. Coffee is really great too! You’ll love it! Just go!

Lots of flavored bagels and different cream cheeses, it’s a heaven for bagel lovers like me. I rated it 5 stars because their bagels are incomparable. Had starbucks bagel, dunkin’s bagel and cream cheese, and even Sip This bagel, nothing comes close to the texture of Magic Bagel’s bagels. You gotta try and taste it to believe.

Always receive great customer service and the best bagels in town. The veggie cream cheese is my favorite and they’re very generous with the cream cheese lol :)

My favorite to go place for breakfast. Everyone in there is so friendly and the service is super fast. I love their bagels, they are delicious!

I grew up in the area and after many years finally found myself in the neighborhood with a craving for a bagel. They are still really good, but not as good as I remembered. As far as I’m concerned, there are 3 better bagel joints:
1. 24 hour bagels in Oceanside.
2. Bagel Oasis in Queens.
3. A&S bagels in Franklin Square.
But if you’re in the area, this would still be on the «recommend» list.
Come here and see for yourself!

«Mini plain bagel toasted with chicken salad please! & Small iced coffee two sugars and vanilla crème».
This is my order at Magic bagels almost 90% of the time I go there… It never gets old! Magic is a Valley Stream favorite. It’s a tie between affordability and the variety of bagels/​bialys/​muffins/​and salads they have stored behind the counter. I only needed to carry a $ 5 bill with me everyday for lunch and that was even a bit much for my order! No wonder I kept coming back.
Or was it the friendliest staff in town?! I’ve been in Magic so much that the staff has grown to welcome me by name and even remember my order. Before I even finish my sentence, they know what I want.
Order Plot Twist: French toast bagel with crème cheese, blueberry muffin top, and an iced tea (sorry chicken salad).

This has been my bagel joint forever til now. I went there yesterday to get bagels and my daughter show me this hair substance that was cooked into the bagel. She was grossed out and told me that she can’t digest anything that comes out of that store.

Magic Bagels makes a bagel the way it should be made. Soft and chewy on the inside, slightly hard on the outside. Subtle infusion of flavors in each different bagel offered. The Everything, Salt, Sesame, cinnamon Raisin, and French toast bagels are our favorites.
It’s a treat that is delicious with butter, cream cheese, or flavored cream cheese.
The Lox is good too, but comes from a package.
The staff are friendly, the price is right and there’s a lot of positive high energy here.
Easy parking in the parking lot.

Best breakfast place in valley stream!!! Great people!!! Great service!!! ou can find all kinds of bagels here. Easy to park, just make sure you bring cash, it’s cash only.

The top half of the bagel is usually chewy soft and good while the bottom half of the bagel is crunchy overcooked and yucky. Lol. This isn’t describing one bagel one time, this is describing every bagel every time. They have been a part of the community for as long as I can remember. I just wish that they made a better bagel.

I have been coming to Magic Bagels since I could remember. They used to have the best bagels around. I have been there recently to find that their bagels are falling somewhat flat on taste. I ask for a little butter and when I go to eat it there must be a stick of butter on it!
I would love to give them a higher rating but they need to step up their game.