Jimmy’s Pizza

Place is hit or miss. Sometimes pizza is awesome, sometime its a bit cold and flimsy. Its cool that they give you some zeppolies with a large pie, but last time they tasted funny. Hope they get their act together.

I received a flyer in the mail like I did for every other pizzeria in the area and decided to give this place a shot. I ordered 1 pizza with extra cheese (as I can get 2 free toppings with my coupon) and a cheese steak.
I waited almost an hour after I was quoted 30−45min. That didn’t bother me too much. They even threw in a free bag of zeppoles that I felt was a nice gesture.
Where it all went wrong was when I opened the pie of pizza. It’s literally like they took the pie that had been sitting on the counter all day, slapped some cheese on it and delivered it. They even forgot to leave it in the oven to warm up.
So we decide to call and complain a bit. The owner Jimmy (guy on the phone) the owner talked to us. He claimed the pizza was fresh. I begged the differ. I worked in a pizzeria for most of my teenage years into my 20’s… There was no way it was fresh. I won’t ever use this place again. There is way too much competition to be screwing around for a $ 3 piece of dough… Oh, and the customers aways right.

They brought us zeppolis with our pizza for free! So nice of them! Yummy pizza, will def be ordering again :)

Been here couple times before I started to Unilocal.I’ve always thought this was a decent place. Today I decided on the sausage parmesan sandwich. Nice chopped onions and peppers at the bottom and seasoned well
The décor is simple. Few table and chairs. but very clean establishment. Family friendly place and the folks are nice.
Down the street from work and will be back to visit.

We picked up two pies last week. Canned mushrooms. Yes, canned mushrooms. Are you kidding me in 2013 in Jersey they serve canned mushroom. Two stars is generous, the other pie was cold. Never going back.

Everytime I order from Jimmys, it’s chaos. They forget something and are running around like its their first day. Pizza is good thin crust, and you get zeppoles. The woman in there seems nice but has to ask Jimmy everything, who appears to be in constant, frantic chaos. Once ordered an Italian hotdog and gyro platter at 9pm on a Sunday, went when it was supposed to be ready. Waited there a good 20 – 30 more minutes as Jimmy forgot the hot dog. A family came in, ate, and left and I was still there. I was texting my wife to come looking for me if I wasn’t home in another 20 minutes. The «double» Italian hot dog is two tiny, poor quality dogs. The sautéed onions and peppers were tasty, though.

I read these negative reviews and I have to agree (although I never got to taste the food). I placed an order, similar to a previous post, and at 1 hour 20 mins, I called to find out what happened to my order. They said that my address didn’t exist. Even after I had given them detailed directions, they still insisted it didn’t. They then lied and said they called my phone, but they didn’t. I will never order from them again and I hope you don’t either.

I thought his place was ok then it started to go downhill there pizza wa pretty good yet lately it’s very bland and I only order it when I get a coupon otherwise I stick to sopranos or Linwood

I used to love this place however the last few times we have ordered it has been touch. They have a pizza special which is 2 large pizza’s 16 bucks and they throw in a bag of zeppolis. The last two times the delivery was poor. We waited 2 hours for the delivery because they were short a driver and the second time the pizza arrived cold. Also they are putting less and less cheese on the pizza. I thought it was looking skimpy and my boyfriend reminded me that we ordered extra cheese. But you do get alot of food for the money.

Very good pizza– when you order an x-​large pie they give you a free bag of zeppoli. Good stuff.

Although I will admit that Jimmy’s Pizza makes a very tasty pie, I ordered one night and waited over an hour to receive my pizza. I called and spoke to Jimmy who told me the delivery person had already left with my pizza (from about 5 blocks away). I waited another 20 Minutes and called again, and again spoke to Jimmy, who cursed me out for calling him again and hung up on me. I then left the house with my girlfriend to go to Pizza City (who makes a better pizza anyway) when the delivery guy showed up. I told him I didn’t want the food any more, he told me that Jimmy had forgetten to put it in the oven until after my first call. I will never order from there again, not because of the negligence but because of getting cursed out and hung up on. We have a lot of great pizza places in the area… we don’t need this one. Sorry, but I hope this one fails.