Greco’s Pizza

This is good pizza!
We have friends down this way and it’s a rarity that we can all ever get our schedules to link up. As such, it’s usually an odd day or time when we get down here and none of us usually feels like cooking going out. Straight bum mode in full effect.
So we usually end up getting a pizza and other goodies from Greco’s.
Having had their pizza more than a few times over the last few years now, I’d place them firmly in the top 10 pizza I’ve had in recent years. The flavors are just right… Just has that I don’t know what that makes all the difference between a good pie and a not so good pie.
Their wings and salads and other stuff are all good as well. They usually have some pretty decent coupons and specials, and they also have online ordering which is really cool. And it’s near our friend’s house so rarely are we waiting long.
Overall good pizza, good food. Always happy to grab a pizza from here when we’re down in Tom’s River.
Good stuff!

Go to place for Pizza and more. Staff is friendly. Always busy. Sauce is great with everything made fresh. Grandmas pizza is wonderful. Paninis made fresh even the bread. Now has canolli and Tiramisu. Canoli is filled fresh giving. Crunchy cone. Do yourself a favor and try it. Take out. Too hot to eat in.

Didn’t dig it… at all. I could have heated up a store bought frozen pizza, that’s almost what it resembled. We ordered the supreme pizza… so disappointed. Gave it a try, but won’t bother ordering again. Way too many other Pizza places around to be dissatisfied with Pizza. this IS New Jersey, shouldn’t have to have bad pizza

Not sure what happened but over the summer this place was serving some mighty good pizza.
The calamari was delicious and served with the most amazing garlic tomato sauce.
After a few down hill orders –completely burnt pies and just not as good we took a break.
Decided to give them another shot tonight
Only to be even more disappointed.
The pie was thinner than any thin crust could be, ice cold, the sauce was sparingly swirled on and the cheese? Was it cheese? Transparent and paper like.
The delicious sauce … Was BURNT
What a wasted of $ 26. And a shame that they think cutting corners will save them money.
I will never order again.

The one thing lacking in Toms River was a good pizzeria. Finally we have one! Food is always fresh and made with care. From the pizza (with eggplant) to cheesesteaks and dinners this place is hands down the best around.

I was very disappointed with Greco’s, yesterday. I ordered a sausage, pepper, and onion sub, and a cold antipasto. Not much to ask, right?
Regarding the sub, the sausage was sliced thin from the pizza prep station (which brings back nightmares of nearby Via Roma’s sausage and broccoli rabe), the onions were raw, and the bread — not toasted — was stale at the ends. When you order a sausage sub, you want whole sausages, with the accompanying snap of the skin and juices. They didn’t even phone this one in; it was barely two soup cans and a string to connect them. The taste of basil was overwhelming. Not good.
So, then there was the cold antipasto. Cheap, ultra-​processed ham, white american masquerading for provolone, and none of the olives that were advertised. There were three slices of pepperoni tossed loose into the base (which is nothing more than a generic pile of iceburg and tomato, with two see-​through cucumber slices), no peppers or artichokes to spice things up, and just enough dressing for a small side salad. On top of that, the two rolls of ham and cheese, with their attending subatomic particles of salami and capicola, were laid across the middle and sliced like maki, then left in formation like two flaccid, uncircumcized dicks. Presentation score = 0. Satisfaction score = 0.
Looks like another local spot with one foot out the door.

I tried out Grecos after receiving a menu in the mail. Now i order from them at least once a week. Everything has consistently been delicious, especially their hot and cold sandwiches. Just recently, however, if I just order a pizza it has been cold when it has been delivered this has happened about 3 times in a row! It’s bad news when my pizza gets delivered and I have to microwave it before I can even eat it.

I have to admit, I seriously miss the old pizza place that used to be where Greco’s is. Having said that, I decided to give them a try. We first tried pizza and garlic knots during their first week open. The pizza was awful, but the garlic knots were fantastic. The pizza was super salty, and almost dry. It had little sauce on it and no flavor. I just tasted salt salt salt. We decided to stay away from there until a few weeks ago. We used a coupon in the mail for pizza and hot wings. What a surprise! The pizza tasted MUCH better and the wings were AWESOME! Loved the sauce for the wings and the pizza definitely had much more flavor and much less salt. I guess it took them a few months to get on their feet, but I will definitely be ordering again! And during the 2 times I’ve had with them, their staff was always very pleasant and polite!

Pizza was cold, calamari over priced for the amount given, rude staff members. Would rather eat from dominos then here.

Pizzerias come and go in this area. I hope Greco’s sticks around. Great jersey pizza, with tons of entrée offerings. Calzones are good too. Wings are good for a non-​chicken place. Prices are very competitive, and there are daily specials – which for now you need to call or drive by to know. They have a website which is great for placing orders, but they are still working on putting coupons and specials on there. However, until then, online orders get 10% off…
Lastly, great customer service. Other places hang up before asking my phone # or telling me what the cost will be.
Anyway, this is the place I’m ordering pizza from now on.