Cobblestone Pizza

the pizza is way to greasy I couldn’t even eat it when I got because it was just soggy! and it was way thin crust so that might be the problem idk!

Disappointing. Stingy toppings, appearance left much to be desired, delivered cold, and just bland. It was like eating day old pizza. Not a fan, won’t repeat, and I’ve definitely had better.

We are first time travelers in Oregon and have been using Unilocal to find places to eat along the way. After a long day of exploring Newport, we decided it would be nice to order pizza for delivery to enjoy in the comfort of our lovely hotel on the beach. We chose to order from Cobblestone Pizza and are glad we did! The customer service was very pleasant, from the girl who took our order over the phone to the girl who delivered our pizza. We ordered a pizza that was ½ Hawaiian and ½ vegetarian. Wow! It was loaded with toppings! The vege side had artichokes, spinach, tomatoes, mushrooms, onions, bell peppers and more! All ingredients were fresh and delicious. The pizza was hot and we really liked the crispy bottom of the crust. All in all, it was a delicious pizza!

Delivery was 1 hr. Told 40 mins. No big deal. Pizza was hot. Crust is more breadlike. Bland to me. Plenty of toppings my son and i were pleased about that. Lite sauce which i like. Overall better then pizza hut and places like that. But not NY pizza by any means. Woyld i order from here again if in the area. Yes

Pretty good combo. The crust was awesome. My only issue was there was a TON of mushrooms on it. So if mushrooms aren’t your thang maybe skip em or ask for for less

Delicious pizza! Shrimp Alfredo, yum! Cobblestone combo, yayah! Friendly service and takes delivery orders until 930pm. Highly recommended!

Called tonight to order a pie. Wanted Italian special with all the pepperoni on half the pizza and sausage on half. No extra toppings but distributed differently. Stupid order taker argued etc rather than trying to accommodate. Very frustrating. Then just said to her, just give me a pie. She was twangy voiced and hard to understand. A bad experience. When we got the pie it was obvious that toppings were not fresh but from cash and carry. No taste in the bland sauce. Crust under cooked. Waste of money.

Its a good thing that this twelve pound, 28″ pizza is offered as a two person challenge because even with extra help, this monstrous pie has never been defeated. When members of The Big Eaters Club arrived to take this bad boy down, everyone watching was hopeful for our success and cheered us on every step of the way.
We chose the four veggie topping option and were not disappointed by either the amount or quality of the ingredients.
With the clock ticking on the 1 hour time limit, we dug in. This pizza was hot, fresh, and as delicious as it was large.
If you drive to fast down the Highway 20 business loop, you might miss the small and unassuming building that houses some of the best pizza we have ever had. The family run operation was obviously a labor of love. Its the sort of pizza joint that would be the first choice for meeting up after the game, for a birthday party, or when you just wanted a tasty meal.
The owners were friendly and the pride in their product and business showed.
With locations in Toledo and Newport, Cobblestone Pizza and the Oregon coast make for two great stops

I’m a world traveler so I have had better pizza, but this is good. Glad to live close by and our first thought when all are home late from work and tired.

I think this is a wonderful pizza place and they deliver!!! They are also very community minded and hold all kinds of fund raisers.

Stumbled upon this place from an ad in the newspaper, offering up free garlic balls. Garlic balls? My husband and I know a thing or two about garlic balls ;) We didn’t think there was any place that could compare with our hometown favorite from back in the day.
Sadly, Toledo, Oregon is quite a ways from where we live. As I frequently say to my husband, «JUST CALL THE PLACE AND ASK!» he did so, and alas they would deliver all the way to our place for only $ 6. Heck yes I’ll pay that, I just got home, I don’t want to go driving 10+ miles to some unknown pizza place!!!
Oh, I forgot to say I’ve never been in the place.
BUT! The pizza is Divine! It is a tad on the spicy side, so order a little less pepperoni if it’s for the kids; but for the adults YUM! This pizza was «eat the crust» good!
«But what about their Balls?» you ask? Oh yes, they were yummy… at least as good as our favorites back home.
This isn’t Domino’s, Pizza Hut, or Papa Murphy’s. This Pizza is grown and full bodied! And if you have a question, just ask them!
The fifth star will be added when I get to go eat at the joint!

We rolled into Otter Rock on a Sunday evening to embark on a week of Oregon Coast rest and relaxation. And, people, we rolled in HUNGRY. It was late (ish) and so we settled on ordering some pizza to bring back to our chalet. Having already done our Unilocal research, we called the pizza joint Unilocalers had recommended only to find they were in the process of closing for the evening (and thus hadn’t the time to make our pizza). Called our back-​up place – closed. So, my husband grabbed his phone and searched Unilocal for another option when we came across Cobblestone Pizza. 3 ½ stars? That’ll work – we’ve got children to feed!

Called them to find them open (yes!) – a bit of drive from where we were, but at this point, we were just happy to find a place open and willing to feed us. We ordered a pepperoni for the kids, which was solid. I had a bite or two and found the pepperoni had a nice spice to it. For the four adults, we ordered a veggie pizza, which was nothing short of superb. It had feta, sundried tomato, green peppers, just the right amount of olives (I find too many and the flavor overwhelms the other veggies), mushrooms, spinach, and the piece de resistance: fresh tomatoes added AFTER cooking (just the way I like it!). The sort of pizza so piled in deliciousness, it requires a fork. Fanfriggintastic.
The service was lovely both on the phone and during the pick-​up. The ambiance is cute and casual. A bit out of the way for travelers, perhaps – but the pizza is definitely worth the drive!

Cobblestone is a great addition to Toledo. There’s been a lack of a good pizza place for a while. I really like their chicken and garlic combos and some of their mostly meat combos. Good, friendly service, nice atmosphere. I do agree that their take-​out pizzas tend to soak through the box, but you could fix that with a plastic grocery bag on the car seat.

Very yummy pizza. They were very friendly and willing to do a ½ ¹⁄₄ ¼ to please our ever picky children. We also ordered a half dozen of the yummy garlic rolls! The giant pizza was large enough to feed 2 adults, 4 kids and we had 3 slices to bring home. Clean and bright. We took advantage of the outside dining. We will return next trip to the coast on highway 20!

Edit: The quality of the pizza has degraded significantly since my first visit. They seem to be using fewer and lower quality ingredients. The reduction in quality of the cheese was especially noticeable. I would recommend going elsewhere.
— — — -
Cobblestone has excellent pizza! The dough and toppings are always fresh and the service is fast and friendly. They are hands-​down the best pizza restaurant in Toledo, and one of my all-​time favorites. Prices are a little higher than I’d like, but the quality of the food is definitely better than they charge you. The restaurant has a comfortable indoor seating area as well as outdoor seating (umbrellas provided). In addition to pizza, they offer amazing salads, calzones, grinders, and more. If you’re around Toledo for dinner, definitely give Cobblestone a try!