Pizzoni’s Pizza

Run by kids. Food didn’t hit the oven for 35 min. Got a refund and went to Panda. No mature management onsite.

An overall amazing place. The staff is friendly and helpful, and the pizza is fantastic.

Very yummy pizza for a decent price. After spending the day at the space center, we stopped here on our way out. We ordered the 23 inch pizza for $ 22 ($ 19 + $ 3/​topping). It came fairly quickly and was delicious. It had fairly thin crust, a tasty light sauce and a large crust area to hold on to. The place was rather small and there were quite a few people who came in to pick up an order they called in. Overall, the pizza was delicious, especially given the price.

After reading the reviews, I was pretty excited to try to this place out but if definitely fell short of NY pizza. We ordered half plain and half veggie. The veggie half was good, but I’ve had better. The plain half was plain awful. The flavor of the sauce was lacking and the cheese had a strange buttery taste to it… I couldn’t even eat it.
The staff was friendly, the décor is pretty cool, the place was very clean and they serve beer which is also nice.
The wait for the pizza was over 30 minutes… I’m not really sure why because they didn’t seem that busy…
We were dining in… when they served it to us, it was in a box– that is very wasteful! There were 4 other groups dining in and everyone’s pizza was served in a box… Why would you waste boxes like that? And then they were just tossed in the garbage with actual garbage, they aren’t even getting recycled…
I doubt I would return here when there are other places in town with better pizza.

This is the best pizza around. Have tried a lot and this is great and have a good selection of beers on tap. Their young employees are very friendly. Ordered a 16 inch with half everything and half pepperoni. Wonderful

One of the best New York style Pizza in Titusville. I just wish they had a farther delivery area. I’d even be willing to pay a delivery fee like a competitor charges that delivers and is actually farther in miles. But still worth the drive.

Wow.
We ordered tonight and our crust is burned. We have a pizza oven and use semolina flour all the time.
I called to let them know they overcooked the crust and was told they would credit us another pizza. I was told the issue was the semolina flour. I took a few pics…
Too bad — we definitely will not be back…

Best pizza in town, hands down! We’ve tried them all, and this restaurant has the most consistent food quality and friendliest service of any pizza place in town! Yummmmmy!!!

Good pizza. Well priced. Fresh pizza made to order and only about 20 min wait time. Pizzas are big, I think we had the large which is the middle size and it was perfect for four people. Prompt and friendly staff.

Great pizza n salad!
People are really friendly.
Best pizza in town and good prices.

Pizza was awesome when first open then took a dive (over or undercooked pies) but they are doing it right again. If you haven’t been in a while give it a chance

Good pizza and cheap beer. Little seating when it’s busy but it’s busy ’cause it’s good.

Best pizza in Titusville! Coming from a true pizza snob. Get a few Canolli’s too. You may not be in the mood for them when you order, but nothing beats them for a late night snack OR for breakfast with coffee.

walked in and ordered a, regular cheese pizza, a sausage pepper and onion sub, and large garlic knots. The girl who took my order was very pleasant and friendly. I was told that it would be 20 – 25 mins. So I sat there and waited and waited. Noticed that the pizza was done in 15, & garlic knots too. Sub was not started until after the pizza was done. Time waited 35 mins. By the time I go home pizza was cold and so were garlic knots. I had to reheat them. They were not even busy, there was only one customer there and then one more walked in behind me.
Also as I was waiting I noticed that the two cooks liked to use their feet to close the bottom oven pizza door (yuck) and were constantly brushing the oven inside and scraping it. It was flying all over the place.
This is no NY style pizza. The cheese seemed & tasted like fake Mozzarella, the crust was very rubbery. The Knots were rubbery as well. I was shocked to see that the sub I ordered was sausage cut thin, like the kind you would use on a pizza. And just thrown in a roll. It was horrid! This is not the way it is served in NY. I prefer Momma Rosa’s And/​or Valentinos at Searstown. I gave two stars because they were friendly. other wise I give it a big zero!

Awesome pizza and the tsunami roll with pepperoni instead if ham is amazing!!! These guys have great customer service and i always come here when I am in town!

great take away and quaint dine in. The pizza is great! I love the beauty and the beast Pizza, good for the whole family :)

I must start this review by saying I’m no New Yorker but I’ve eaten my share of New York Style Pizza and for the most part I have enjoyed most of them. This pizza was just okay in my opinion, it was built fresh, the dough was pounded, kneaded, tossed, spun and stretched I’m amazing at the skill on display for all to see, unfortunately tonight they were extremely backed up with take out and delivery orders and our pizza was the last pizza order taken before they started turning walk-​in customers away. Not one customer was seated after we placed our order and the restaurant was mostly empty.
As you can see in my photo it’s a pretty awesome looking pizza but the crust was under cooked and doughy and also quite tough to the point the plastic tableware just couldn’t get the job done. The toppings all seemed very fresh and plentiful. It just looked like they were a little over-​whelmed and rushing to get the orders out. The sodas are canned and they sell no iced tea they do have a few draft beers on tap. The employees were extremely friendly and the service was excellent but the food failed to wow me. I may try them again if I’m in the area maybe we caught them on a bad night there seems to be a lot of praise in the reviews posted,

Ordered 2 pizzas and they told me it would be 35 minutes. When I got there after 40 minutes it was not ready and I was told it would be another 15 minutes. Offered nothing for my extra long wait. Will not be back

Perfectly made thin crust New York style pizza. Great flavor and huge slices!
To be honest, I have never been to New York –I really hope the pizza there is as pizza good as Pizzoni’s!

Giant slice of yummy New York style pizza, 2 tvs. Soda fountain. Whole pizzas, sangwhiches… yummy. The place needs a good cleaning but great pizza and salads.