Sid’s Pizza & Grill

I’ve been here twice and both times the pizza exceeded my expectations. It’s dang good pizza… Period! Apparently, after reading the reviews, there have been issued with service. Not for for me. The server was pleasant and quick with my drink, then salad, then pizza. $ 8.99 for a small delicious pizza, salad (with homemade blue cheese dressing), and soda. This place is good and I recommend it.

Got pizza from Sid’s for the first time this evening. Wow — they really know how to make an amazing pizza. Perfect amount of toppings, melty cheese, and they have green olives! I love green olives on pizza! The crust was perfect, crisp on the bottom, chewy, deliciousness.
We’ve been searching for a great pizza place in the area and we’ve definitely found it. In fact, I think (and my wife agrees), that this was the best pizza we have ever had. Hats off to Sid. Highly recommended.

Best pizza in south Forsyth! I have lived in this area for 16 years and tried almost every pizza place that people have recommended no one comes close to how good this pizza tastes! The crust is so delicious!

The Italian hoagie was the best I’ve had in Atlanta. Nice crusty bread, ripe tomatoes, and delicious meats. The chicken bbq pizza was great as well, particularly the crust.

Sid’s is an excellent staple for consistently good pizza in the John’s Creek area. I have been there several times and always receive good service and an excellent pizza. Plus, it’s a small local business that deserves my patronage. I definitely recommend giving Sid’s a try.

We love Sid’s Pizza! We pick up pizzas here weekly and we are always happy with our pizzas. Man their sauce and traditional crust are so good! Some of the best pizza we’ve had in a long time!

Its still great taste. but I gave up on delivery. They are 5 for 5 in forgetting my ranch and hot sauce and I have even begged when ordering on the phone to ask they double check since I haven’t gotten them in almost a year.

I really wanted this to be my family’s go to pizza place. We had heard so many glowing reviews. The pizza is pretty good (sauce is alittle too sweet for me, but my family likes it) and they have Take N Bake pizzas for you to take home and bake in your own oven (which is very appealing to us, as we often head to our mountain house on Friday nights and picking these up on the way are perfect). Unfortunately, the service is spotty at best. I’ve had at least 2 incidents where my order wasn’t ready when promised and I had to stand around and wait and another time when my order was wrong all together. Both times, the staff acted as if it was my error not theirs and made no offers to make me a happy patron when I left. In addition, both times I sent an email on their Contact Us page on their website that promises a response within 48 – 72 hours with no contact from anyone at the store. With all the pizza options in our area, I would think they would be concerned about customer issues and service. We will not be sending any business their way anytime soon and will be picking up Giorgio’s Pizza on our way up to the mountains from now on.

The pizza was good. (I’m from NY and a harsh pizza critic.). The thin pizza is way better than the regular which is too doughy. I found the red sauce overly sweet. My kids loved it. I did find the place a bit dirty. Lots of flies.

Ordered a large cheese pizza but was delivered a 14 inch pie.

The pizza is decent, but the service is worst I have ever seen at any restaurant or take-​out. I have had problems on multiple occasions picking up a pizza. If I order on the phone, they don’t start making the pizza until I arrive. So the last time I did not call ahead, and ordered when I got there, and went over to Target next door to pick up some items. When I returned to Sid’s in 15 minutes, they had not even started the pizza. I know this because when I asked about it, I could see the cashier go into the back and then I could see them start making it. 15 minutes later (30 minutes after I first ordered it) the pizza came out. There was only one table of 3 people seated in the store (already eating), and I could see people in the back doing nothing, so I know they were not busy. Unfortunately, this has happened more than once and the owner is very rude, so I don’t go there anymore.

Best pizza I had in Atlanta. Their unique tomato sauce on their pizza makes it delicious.

My wife and I love the Wedge pizza and the Greek salad — the crust is crispy and delicious, and the toppings are fresh and never in short supply. Quality food at a good price. The atmosphere is nothing to write home about — simple, small, clean pizza joint — but that doesn’t matter, as it’s all about the food. Recommended.

Best pizza around! Quality you can taste. The wings are awesome, crispy and wet… the sandwiches always deliver and the salads are excellent too.
We have Sids Pizza like once a week– no other place compares

Love the pizza here. The white pizza is my fav! Take extra caution ordering the extra hot wings because they do not play! My boyfriend and I had years coming out of our eyes and we normally eat really spicy food. We are going to order here tonight! That will be twice in a week!

The pizza is good here, and having grown up on the beach I love the surf theme in the restaurant. I have only come here for lunch, and the service is ok. Not excellet but not bad either. The location is convenient :)

Very good pizza but service is spotty. There are some excellent servers but if you don’t get one of them, you are out of luck.

Decided to try a new pizza place. Checked out reviews. Got the veggie one with extra sauce. Love that they actually give you extra sauce. The sauce was pretty good. Pizza crust was nice and thick, but not too dense. The garlic bread was not very good. The pizza overall was okay. I doctored it up with garlic powder and crushed red pepper. Not my favorite, but I’d get it again. Ordered carryout, and the person on the phone was very nice! Added plus! Will try again.

Arrived at 7:30PM on a Saturday night, starving as some family errands delayed my dinner. I was excited to try the pizza, as the Unilocal reviews were good.
Sign says seat yourself, so I did so. «Waitress» is behind the desk and less than 10 feet away. I waited 4 – 5 minutes. No one approached me or offered to take my order. Some other employees stood around chatting.
I finally just left. Doesn’t matter how good the food is if the service stinks.
Will not return.

I was honestly a fan of Sid’s when it first opened. I only ever ordered their pizza and lemon pepper wings, but they were both really good. Notice I said ‘WERE’. The last few times I went there the wings were overfried & dry, even when I specifically asked for extra sauce on the wings. And forget about getting their pizza delivered… it’s ONLY good if you eat it immediately out of the oven, INSIDE the restaurant. It’s weird but it tastes COMPLETELY different when you get it delivered… and I mean different in a bad way!
I don’t know what happened, but it’s like they care a little less each time you go. It’s never been a really busy place, and I’m sure they lost alot of business when the whole recession thing hit. But uhh, when you see less people are spending money to eat out, wouldn’t that make you want to put MORE effort into your business, to keep the customers you have coming back?
The owner is there sometimes, and he always seems like he’s in a bad mood. Or maybe he’s just naturally grumpy? But a little customer service would be nice. And I literally LOL’d when I read the other review about the ‘indifferent teenybopper girl’ that works there. I was gonna say the same thing! I’m pretty sure she’s his daughter, and I’m even more certain that she’s probably forced to work there… cause her attitude definitely says she doesn’t WANT to be there. You almost feel like you’re bothering her when you try to place an order. That alone will make you not want to go back.
I really hate to give them a negative review because they’re a small local, family-​owned business. But the truth is the truth. Hopefully they’ll see this and make some major changes!!!