Johnny’s New York Style Pizza & Subs

Good Lunch specials. They have good sauce and give to go drinks.

This place is okay. I didn’t go in with high expectations. Just wanted regular pizza. The pizza is not mind-​blowing. It’s large greasy slices. I noticed on the board they have specials on different days. I don’t remember the specific days. but one day, all kids eat free. Other days, it’s $ 3 drafts. I did think it was kind of overpriced though for the quality. I think the menu posted on this Unilocal page is outdated. They have increased the prices. The Johnny’s Deluxe slice was over $ 5 and it wasn’t THAT good that I’d pay that much for it again. I’d go for the days they offer deals.

Got a Stromboli and it was really good, perfect amount of cheese and not too much bread. Service was standard, food came out pretty quickly, good place to grab a quick bite to eat for lunch. Would recommend!

Johnny’s is always constantly good (not great) pizza, subs and salads. Nothing to write home about but it’s good. $ 1 cheese slices and drought beer 9:00 — 11:00 Friday and Saturday night. Can’t beat that deal. Nice casual service. No big deal. Maybe 3.5…

My husband like to order the pizza from them because it is close to our home. He like to order it when it is raining day or when he is lazy to go out to eat!

Absolutely horrible, we ordered 2 pizzas and were told 45 mins … 65 mins later we called and they said pizza will be there in 5 mins … We called again after 20 mins and spoke to the manager he said pizza guy is around the corner. Almost 2 hours later our pizza arrived. Will never order from here again

The quality of this place has really went down hill. Their pizza is just average, there are much better options for the same amount of money within a mile of this location.
I got a Caesar Salad, add grilled chicken, and add more grilled chicken (I just got done working out)
I pay $ 12 and some change including a tip, get it home, open it up. 6 small slivers of grilled chicken. And it was the kind you can get at walmart that is precooked and presliced in a bag for like $ 2 or $ 3 for a pound of nastiness.
I tried to eat it because I was starving, but it was disgusting. I will surely make the drive to a nearby Zaxby’s to get the same thing for about the same price.

With pizza delivery, its a fairly well-​known belief that quality will be lacking, but you are somewhat OK with it, right? Not tonight
Johnny’s Pizza was never anything special for the myriad of times I’ve given them my money, and this location’s attempt was no different. I am aware of time constraints, and that my inability to visit an actual location makes quality tough, but at what point was what I received worth waiting/​paying for?
By the time the poor delivery guy arrived at my door, full of apologies, the pizza was stone cold. The spots of mozzarella on my marge were like cold-​rubber cement, with no semblance of freshness anywhere, and the crust overpowered the rest of the pizza with quite a bit of leftover dough to make a matching set of bread sticks. Not impressed in the slightest, and will most likely not be ordering from this location (or any Johnny’s) in the foreseeable future.
If Dumbinos, Poopa John’s, Marco’s and some other locals can do mediocre consistently, then I’d rather plunk my $ 20 there for atleast some semblance of knowing what I bought into prior. I remember when Johnny’s Pizza was held in a higher standard than that of those other places, but I would love to debate anyone that says they are at this point in time.

Moving back to the east coast you appreciate good pizza like never before this place rocks

I have two confessions to make about this Johnny’s NY Pizza: 1 — I have only ever had take out from them, and 2 — I have only ever had their pizza.
That being said, their service for take out is usually pretty fast and the staff is friendly. The pizza; however, is really not all that good… Super greasy, flavorless sauce, skimpy on the cheese, crust just so so, really not much taste to it at all.
Sorry Johnny, I really wanted to like your pizza because you are just down the street from my office but I’m going to have to drive a little further down the road next time when I’m craving a couple of slices for lunch.

Pizza is pretty good, but the service was sub par. After we received our food, the waitress didn’t come back to the table to check on us for almost 25 – 30 minutes, and at that time we were done. This is a very small place, and only 3 small tables were being waited on, so no excuse for the poor service. I hate to see this because I really enjoy some of their other locations.

Great food, very accommodating. Love the chicken Parmesan. I will revisit this location.

Order delivery at least twice a month, usually on the weekends. There is always a 45+ min wait for delivery, which is fine. The pizza is always consistent. Nice medium/​thin crust, fresh sauce and toppings. I also love the garlic knots with marinara.
The only down side is that I order the same two items and always quoted a different price. Usually only a dollar off. Not a huge deal but please be aware.

Food was excellent but the service knocked this down to awful.
It was 3pm on a saturday and the server was no where to be seen. No drink re fills, the cook brought out the pizza, and the sides of ranch we asked for, we literally got uo to get our own silver and napkins. dirty plates stayed on the 4 person table. We finally got her attention and asked for a box, she brought us a slice sized boxf or practically a medium pizza. I know not everyone is cut out to be a server, but seriously. if you are aiming to chase off your lunch crowd. this is the way to do it.
We ordered salad, knots, a large pizza and a calzone and the food was all deliciously spot on. so props to the cook.

Solid 3. Service is friendly and pizza is good. Definitely have had better but today a slice of cheese did the job. The crust was yummy though.

Single slice vegetarian deluxe and share a salad with a cold beer and this place can’t be beat for casual dining. The wait staff is great!

Solid subs and generally tasty pizza. Had my safe-​bet Turkey Sub again this evening. It never disappoints.
Service is friendly and efficient.
It’s a good pizza and sandwich joint. This location has been here for a while now.

First visit. Ordered the deluxe. Solid pie

Hair on the pizza… I’m done. Plus waiter sort of ignored us after a large party came in.

After a long day of softball [& I do mean a long day], wanted to get some pizza to recharge my batteries. Used my trusty Unilocal app and tracked down a Johnny’s Pizza. This one has usually been a consistent winner for me, but being out of my area I didn’t know how this one would be. This location is smaller than the one’s closer to Atlanta and the service is sloooooowwwwww. In a pinch it will do but I won’t drive out of my way for it. At least the food was consistent with the locations closer to the city.